Jury rejects Yard’s account of the death of a detective

The Observer, 15 December 1985

Scotland Yard’s criminal intelligence squad, C11, faces a grave crisis after an Old Bailey jury acquitted two men accused of murdering one of its undercover surveillance officers, Detective Constable John Fordham.

The collapse of the court case exposed a catalogue of errors in one of C11’s major operations and, more seriously, disclosed publicly for the first time the fragile legal basis of its secret work.

On the night of 26 January, C11, working with the Flying Squad, was approaching the climax of a long inquiry into Britain’s biggest armed robbery – the theft of £26 million of gold bullion from Heathrow in November 1983.

Two officers – Fordham and a colleague, Neil Murphy – dressed in camouflage and wearing balaclavas, prowled through the 20-acre grounds of the Kent home of one of the suspects, millionaire Ken Noye, and his guest, Brian Reader, another suspect.

At the core of the disastrous trial was the claim by Scotland Yard that the officers were preparing to execute a search warrant – one of 36 obtained the day before for suspects ranged across the South of England. The claim was crucial if the Yard were to demonstrate that they were acting lawfully.

If not, Noye could argue that he was legally justified in defending himself against an unidentified trespasser. And C11 would be forced to admit that some operations break the law.

But was C11 preparing to move in and use the search warrant to begin the final phase of the gold bullion inquiry? Our inquiries establish that :

* Two key suspects, Derek ‘Little Legs’ Larkins and Chris Weyman, who had been secretly trailed by C11, were not under surveillance that Saturday night. A third suspect, John Palmer, was on holiday in Tenerife . All three are still at liberty.

* The missing gold bullion had not been located, and no officers were in place to execute any of the other 35 search warrants obtained against suspects.

* The officer in charge was at home with his family; his deputy was 20 miles away in Scotland Yard; the senior officer on the spot was a mile and a half away from the house and, of the handful of officers at the scene, three were packing up to go home.

Fordham and Murphy entered the grounds of Noye’s home with no weapons to deal with a man who was the registered owner of seven shotguns and two handguns, and no dog handlers to deal with his three Rottweilers.

At best, raiding the Noye home that night would have been a most uncharacteristic Flying Squad operation. One person who has been on the receiving end of more than one, told us: “Even when I lived in a council flat with one door, they would use at least seven officers on the raid and often more than a dozen. This would include armed officers and an armed handler for our Rottweiler.”

Murphy was to tell the Old Bailey that, although he knew a warrant had been issued for Mr Noye’s home, he had not been told of any decision to execute it.

Legal experts are in no doubt. Leonard Leigh, Professor of Law at London University and author of a study on police powers, said: “If they were on that land and not intending to execute a search warrant, then it was civil trespass.”

The effect was not only to compromise the police case in court. More immediately and tragically, it put John Fordham in an impossible position that night. If he allowed himself to be identified, it would not only blow the whole operation, it would also reveal his illegal presence.

There was even some dispute at the trial over whether he was carrying his police ID – the only way he could have saved himself when confronted by Noye, armed with a knife. All he could do was to claim he was on ‘SAS manoeuvres.’

The ID was not listed in his belongings at the hospital where he died, but the inspector who rode in the ambulance said he removed it along with his wallet en route. Ambulanceman Brian Moore said that was impossible since he had been working continually on the dying man’s body and had seen nothing removed from it .

The police inquiry into the death was beset by problems. Within weeks, Fordham’s colleague Neil Murphy was seen twice by store detectives at an Asda superstore in Barking, Essex, acting suspiciously. On the second occasion he was accused of trying to steal pop music cassettes. Asda agreed not to press charges, and the Director of Public Prosecutions agreed not to prosecute. Murphy’s key evidence as the only eye-witness to the incident – particularly against Brian Reader – was saved.

There was more trouble. Scotland Yard had from the moment of John Fordham’s death, treated Noye’s wife Brenda as a full accomplice to the killing. They charged her with murder, but when the case reached the magistrate, the court declared that she had no case to answer.

In the weeks after the incident, John Fordham’s widow, Ann, felt deeply that her husband had been exposed to enormous risk. According to one Yard source: “She was very bitter at first. She didn’t really know what John had been doing and she blamed his superiors for what had happened. But she has been counselled, and it has all been explained to her, and there is no animosity.”