Surveillance officers working on the edge of the law

The Observer, 13 December 1985

C11 has kept a far lower profile than other detective squads. The reason is not simply that its work has to be kept secret from its targets. Secrecy is, in addition, thrust upon it because it works on the borderline of legality.

Last year it was reorganised as part of the Commissioner’s shake-up of the Metropolitan Police. In a key development it took control of a small group of officers and civil servants known as the Technical Support Unit.

The unit’s job is to procure the gadgetry for specialist operations and to learn how to use it. It is, therefore, at the centre of the controversial business of tapping and bugging, concealed cameras, spike mikes which burrow through walls, and fibre optic lenses which film through a pin hole.

The greatest operational difficulty in using secret surveillance equipment is gaining access in order to plant devices. Here, therefore, working on the legal borderline involves a daily effort by London policemen to do their job without being accused of breaking and entering.

“The powers that be would go potty if you were caught doing anything like that,” said a former C11 officer. “That’s the restriction you work under. Most of the work is simple surveillance. Wherever the target goes, you go. If he walks, you walk. If he gets in a car, you get in a car. If he gets in a train, you get in the train. You swap environments; that’s the whole essence.

“You may get spotted occasionally. That’s where experience comes in. Then you pull out and start again the next day rather than be blown. There’s always another day. But you keep at them day and night. That’s the name of the game.”

The surveillance units have the two advantages of numbers and communication. A whole team of 10 may follow one man, taking it in turns to move in close, retiring temporarily to change a coat or a car and then returning, liaising with central control through throat microphones and hidden ear-pieces.

But even this standard form of surveillance can bring legal problems. “You have to grab observation points where you find them, and that may mean that technically you are trespassing. If the target goes into a house, you may go over a wall into the back garden next door. That’s trespass. Sometimes you might go and ask the householder. But if you’re in a hurry or it’s the middle of the night, you’re not going to bother. I don’t consider civil trespass a serious offence. It’s a well-known problem in surveillance.”

Forty-eight hours after John Fordham’s death there was a summit meeting of senior officers from London and Kent to resolve territorial disputes that had flared between the two forces.

According to a confidential minute of that meeting, signed by the Yard’s Assistant Commissioner for Crime, Mr John Dellow, there were two questions on the agenda: had the Yard broken police protocol by trespassing on Kent’s area without their consent; and should Kent allow the Yard to wrest control of the inquiry into the death of the officer?

Although both forces maintain the official line that there has been no friction, they nevertheless found it necessary to draw up a formal written agreement stating that in future if Metropolitan officers wanted to go into Kent’s area “the Assistant Chief Constable of Kent would be consulted beforehand.”

Kent’s present Assistant Chief Constable, Mr Paul Condon, said last week that his force had known of the Yard’s presence in Kent, but he refused to say whether they had known of the Yard’s plans to raid Mr Noye’s home.

After consulting the Director of Public Prosecutions, the summit meeting agreed that the Yard would take control of the inquiry – a decision which provoked criticism at the subsequent trial that Mr Fordham’s death was being investigated by some of his closest friends.

Mr Dellow refused to discuss allegations that C11 had been illegally trespassing at Mr Noye’s home. “I am not here to rebut allegations,” he said at a press conference after the Old Bailey trial. He said he had no intention of holding an internal inquiry or making any change to Cll’s operational guidelines. “Decisions that were taken then were right, and I have no reason to question them now,” he added.