Two South Yorkshire detectives face possible criminal charges after Appeal Court judges yesterday cleared two Sheffield men of robbery and declared there was a ‘high probability’ that evidence against them had been fabricated.
Yesterday’s Appeal Court hearing followed an inquiry into South Yorkshire police which is believed to have uncovered up to ten wrongful convictions as part of an unofficial campaign of ‘rough justice’ towards known criminals who were being prosecuted for crimes regardless of their guilt.
The inquiry into the allegations was led by Detective Superintendent Ronald Sagar of Humberside CID. The Guardian reported in February 1982 that Mr Sagar had been called in to investigate claims of illegal drug dealing and had then uncovered the wider claims of wrongful convictions.
Mr Sagar’s team considered that one particular conviction was so doubtful that the two men involved – Nicholas Froggart and Mark Brennan – should be released immediately until their case could be reconsidered by the Court of Appeal.
At yesterday’s hearing, Mr Sagar repeated his belief that Mr Froggart and Mr Brennan were probably telling the truth when they claimed that evidence against them had been fabricated by Detective Sergeant Price and Detective Constable Gutcher of the South Yorkshire force.
Lord Justice Dorian, sitting with Mr Justice Cantley and Mr Justice Stuart-Smith, said he believed there was a high probability that interviews which Mr Froggart and Mr Brennan were said to confessed had never actually taken place.
Mr Sagar told the court that he had no hard against the two detectives. It is understood that they have been suspended from duty while the case is considered and that the Director of Public Prosecutions has been consulted.
Mr Froggart, and Mr Brennan, both aged 23, were convicted on November 13, 1981 in Sheffield of robbing a casino manageress of items worth £63. Both had criminal records and they were gaoled for five years.
At their trial, they denied confessing to the robbery. After Mr Froggart and Mr Brennan were gaoled, two other men confessed to the robbery but refused to make statements under caution to confirm the confessions. Mr Sagar told the Appeal Court yesterday that he believed these confessions were genuine.