South Yorkshire reinstates accused detectives

The Guardian, 21 July 1983

Two South Yorkshire detectives who were named in the Appeal Court on Monday in connection with the fabrication of evidence have been reinstated and will not face criminal charges.

South Yorkshire police refused to comment yesterday on the progress of the internal inquiry, led by Det Supt Ronald Sagar of the Humberside force, into claims that up to 10 people had been wrongly convicted in an unofficial campaign of ‘rough justice’ against known criminals.

Two Sheffield men were cleared of robbery charges in the Court of Appeal on Monday. Lord Justice Dunn said it was highly probable that evidence against them had been fabricated. Mr Sagar told theappeal hearing that he believed Det Sgt Terry Price and Det Con David Gutcher had concocted evidence in the form of false confessions.

The two detectives were suspended from duty after Mr Sagar began his inquiries in February 1982. A spokesman for South Yorkshire police said yesterday: “The two officers are not now suspended. They are back on duties.”

The office of the Director of Public Prosecutions confirmed that he had considered the case. A spokesman said: “No action will be taken against them.” Mr Sagar was originally appointed to investigate allegations of illegal drug dealing, but his inquiry broadened after he received claims that officers were framing known criminals for offences which they had not committed.