An unexpected ruling by a judge six years ago effectively covered up the chance to publicly expose evidence of the illegal targeting of Gordon Brown which had been unearthed by a startled team of provincial detectives.
Operation Reproof, by police in Plymouth, revealed the first of what became many systematic attempts to gain illegal confidential information on the prime minister and his family, but their findings were suppressed. The Guardian has now been able to document the facts.
Files buried in police archives detail the discovery of an extraordinary nationwide network of private investigators, whom a corrupt local police officer was feeding with information filched from the police national computer (PNC). To the detectives’ surprise, the targets included the then chancellor of the exchequer, listed by his full name, James Gordon Brown, and date of birth, as well as two other Labour politicians. They were the chancellor’s close colleague, the agriculture minister Nick Brown, plus the MP for Reading West, Martin Salter, who at the time of the PNC break-in had been publicly put on an ‘enemies list’ by the then News of the World editor, Rebekah Brooks.
An Exeter detective constable, Phil Diss, was covertly performing PNC checks, which were subsequently sold on to private investigators in bulk, for as little as £40 or even £20 a time. Gordon Brown’s office was privately warned in 2003 at the time of the discovery of the illegal data checks, according to sources familiar with the case. So too were Nick Brown and Martin Salter.
Diss, a popular and long-serving police officer, used his official access to the PNC to supply results to his former boss, a retired police inspector, who ran a commercial investigation agency in Exmouth, servicing other private detectives across the country. SAS Investigations in Exmouth gleaned material from a stable of several local police officers and civil servants able to get into official databases, containing criminal records, other police intelligence and social security details.
The purchaser of information on the three Labour politicians was Glen Lawson, a private detective in Newcastle upon Tyne, according to police records and court transcripts obtained by the Guardian. Lawson, who still trades in Tyneside under the name Abbey Investigations, refuses to say which journalists contracted him to pursue Gordon Brown and other members of the Labour government. He told the Guardian: “I am not going to make any comment.”
Lawson was raided on 26 February 2003 by Devon and Cornwall police and his files seized. He was not charged, the court was later told, because of a CPS decision to try to avoid excessive prosecution delays. But the evidence involving Gordon Brown did form part of the crown case against Diss and his former boss, Alan Stidwill of SAS Investigations. Eventually six people were charged with offences involving misconduct in public office after Operation Reproof, a three-year investigation across the country.
It strained the budget of Devon and Cornwall police, who agreed to limit the range of defendants and to focus research in the West Country. But, a police spokesman told the Guardian this week, as far as those six were concerned: “We thought we had a strong case.”
The police team were then surprised and upset when Judge Paul Darlow refused in 2005 to regard the issue as sufficiently serious to go to trial. He prevented a jury from hearing the case, saying the alleged behaviour was too trivial to justify criminal misconduct charges, and the proposed trial would be a waste of public money.
The papers in front of him identified the two ministers and an MP. Darlow specifically referred at a pretrial hearing to the fact that “particulars in respect of the chancellor of the exchequer were sought and obtained”. But he nonetheless accepted defence claims that the illegal PNC information had been primarily passed to respectable insurance companies, finance houses and other detective agencies, in order to prevent fraud.
He asserted that an eight-week trial might cost as much as £1m in legal fees: “In my judgment it is not a proportionate use of valuable resources to prosecute these matters,” he said. As a result, all the defendants were formally acquitted, and none of the evidence was made public.