Journalists from Rupert Murdoch’s News International repeatedly targeted the former prime minister Gordon Brown, attempting to access his voicemail, and obtaining information from his bank account, his legal file and his family’s medical records.
There is also evidence that a private investigator used a serving police officer to trawl the police national computer for information about him. That investigator also targeted another Labour MP who was the subject of hostile inquiries by the News of the World, but it is not confirmed that the paper was specifically involved in the case of Gordon Brown.
Separately, Brown’s tax paperwork was taken from his accountant’s office apparently by hacking into the firm’s computer. This was passed to the now defunct Sunday Business.
Brown was targeted during a period of more than ten years. Some of the activity clearly was illegal. Other incidents breached his privacy but not the law. It is now known that:
* Scotland Yard has discovered references to both the former prime minister and his wife, Sarah, in paperwork seized from Glenn Mulcaire, the private investigator who specialised in phone-hacking for the News of the World;
* Abbey National Bank found evidence that a ‘blagger’ acting for the Sunday Times on six occasions posed as Brown and gained details from his account;
* Brown’s London lawyers, Allen and Overy, were tricked into handing over details from his file by a conman working for the Sunday Times;
* His infant son’s confidential medical condition was obtained by the Sun who published a story about the child’s serious illness.
Brown joins a long list of Labour politicians who are known to have been targeted by private investigators working for News International, including the former Prime Minister Tony Blair and his media adviser Alastair Campbell; the former Deputy Prime Minister John Prescott and his political adviser Joan Hammell; Peter Mandelson as Trade Secretary; Jack Straw and David Blunkett as Home Secretaries; Tessa Jowell as Media Secretary and her special adviser, Bill Bush; and Chris Bryant as Minister for Europe.
The sheer scale of the data assault on Brown is unusual, with evidence of attempts to obtain his legal, financial, tax, medical and police records as well as to listen to his voicemail. All of these incidents are linked to media organisations. In most cases, there is evidence of a direct link to News International.
Scotland Yard recently wrote separately to Brown and to his wife, Sarah, to tell them that their details had been found in evidence collected by Operation Weeting, the special inquiry into phone-hacking at the News of the World. It is believed that this refers to hand-written notes kept by Glenn Mulcaire, which were seized by police in August 2006 and never previously investigated. Brown last year asked Scotland Yard if there was evidence that he had been targeted by Mulcaire and was told there was none.
Journalists who have worked at News International say they believe that Brown’s personal bank account was accessed on several occasions when he was chancellor of the exchequer. An internal inquiry by Abbey National’s fraud department found that during January 2000, somebody acting on behalf of the Sunday Times contacted their Bradford call centre six times, posing as Gordon Brown, and succeeded in extracting details from his account.
Abbey National’s senior lawyer sent a summary of their evidence to the editor of the Sunday Times, John Witherow, concluding: “On the basis of these facts and inquiries, I am drawn to the conclusion that someone from the Sunday Times or acting on its behalf has masqueraded as Mr Brown for the purpose of obtaining information from Abbey National by deception.”
Abbey National were not able to identify the bogus caller who tricked their staff. It is a matter of public record that the Sunday Times frequently used the services of a former actor, John Ford, who specialised in ‘blagging’ confidential data from banks, phone companies and the Inland Revenue.
Also in January 2000, the Sunday Times used a conman named Barry Beardall, who was subsequently jailed for fraud, to trick staff at Gordon Brown’s solicitor, Allen and Overy, into handing over details from his personal file. A tape made by Beardall at the time reveals that he claimed to be an accountant from the ‘Dealson group of companies’ and that they were interested in buying Gordon Brown’s flat. Beardall also used trickery in an attempt to provide material for Sunday Times stories about the then Prime Minister, Tony Blair, and Labour’s candidate to become the mayor of London, Frank Dobson.
Confidential health details for Brown’s family have reached the media on two different occasions. In October 2006, the then editor of the Sun, Rebekah Brooks, contacted the Browns to tell them that they had obtained information that their four-month-old son, Fraser, was suffering from cystic fibrosis. This appears to have involved a clear breach of the Data Protection Act, which would allow such a disclosure only if it was in the public interest. Friends of the Browns say the call caused them immense distress, since they were just coming to terms with the diagnosis, which had not been confirmed. The Sun published the story.
Five years earlier, when their first child, Jennifer, was born on December 28 2001, a small group of specialist doctors and nurses was aware that she had suffered a brain haemorrhage and was dying. By some means which has not been discovered, this highly sensitive information was obtained by news organisations, who published it over the weekend before Jennifer died, on Monday January 6 2002.
In 2003, Devon and Cornwall police discovered that one of their officers was providing information from the police national computer to a network of private investigators. The Guardian has established that one of these investigators, Glen Lawson of Abbey Investigations in Newcastle upon Tyne, used this contact to commission a search of police records for information about Brown. Lawson also commissioned searches related to two other Labour MPs – Nick Brown and Martin Salter.
Lawson made these searches on behalf of journalists. Paperwork seen by the Guardian shows that the search on Martin Salter was made at a time when the News of the World, then edited by Rebekah Brooks, was attacking him for refusing to support the paper’s campaign for ‘Sarah’s law’, requiring more disclosure of information about paedophiles. Lawson currently refuses to name the journalists who commissioned him.
An attempt to prosecute this network was blocked by a Westcountry judge, Paul Darlow, who shocked police by ruling that it would be a misuse of public money to pursue the case. A senior officer from Devon and Cornwall contacted the office of Gordon Brown, then Chancellor of the Exchequer, to warn him that he had been a victim.
Brown’s tax paperwork was obtained from the offices of his accountants, Auerbach Hope, in late 1998. The first sign that the records had been taken came when a journalist from the now defunct Sunday Business newspaper called the accountants to say that they had been passed a copy of the records, including a schedule of Brown’s income for the most recent year. The journalist acknowledged that the paperwork showed no sign of any kind of wrong-doing on Brown’s part but wanted to do a story about the fact that it had been stolen.
Police came and found no sign of any break-in. The originals of the documents were still in Brown’s file, which ruled out the possibility that they had been taken from the firm’s dustbins. Auerbach Hope discounted theft by an insider on the grounds that they would have stolen paperwork which showed wrong-doing by some client which would have had greater media value. They concluded that the most likely explanation was that somebody had hacked into their computer systems, specifically targeting Gordon Brown.
Senior Labour figures also strongly suspect that a news organisation broke the law to obtain the emails which led to the resignation in April 2009 of Gordon Brown’s close aide, Damian McBride. The emails, which disclosed a scheme to smear Tory MPs, had been exchanged between McBride and a Labour party activist, Derek Draper. The Labour figures believe that the emails were hacked from Draper’s computer on behalf of a news organisation and that their contents were then ‘laundered’ by supplying them to the political blogger Guido Fawkes, whose stories were then followed by Fleet Street.