Court hears devastating detail of Yard’s misbehaviour

The Guardian, 12 May 2011

The Royal Courts of Justice have heard hundreds of professional criminals claim that the police are bent. Yesterday, however, it was a respectable group of public figures including three former Cabinet ministers and a former police chief who claimed that Scotland Yard had twisted the truth and buried the evidence in their case.

In a series of withering attacks, the Metropolitan police were accused of misleading the High Court, parliament and the public over the phone-hacking scandal; and of keeping hundreds, possibly thousands of victims in the dark in a way which shielded Rupert Murdoch’s News International from embarrassment and expensive legal settlements.

In written and oral submissions, the court was confronted with claims that the News of the World’s private investigator, Glenn Mulcaire:

* had intercepted 45 voicemail messages from the former deputy prime minister John Prescott and sent an email about them to an executive at News of the World and that Lord Prescott had been the victim of ‘an unfortunate history of misinformation’ from the Metropolitan Police, who had told him repeatedly that he was not a victim of hacking.

* kept notes on the former Europe minister Chris Bryant including a list of 23 numbers which had made calls to his mobile phone – information which could have been obtained only by hacking his voicemail, his lawyers said – and yet the police had told him there was no evidence his phone had been hacked.

* targeted the former deputy assistant commissioner of the Metropolitan police, Brian Paddick, listing him on his computer as ‘a project’ and collecting phone details for him, his partner, his former partner and numerous associates, but the police had told him only that Mulcaire had written his name, rank and address on one piece of paper.

James Lewis QC for the Metropolitan Police acknowledged that there had been ‘some operational shortcomings’ and that there were some cases where victims had not been informed that there was clear evidence of their messages being intercepted. But he said that the evidence in relation to these claimants had not been clear until very recently.

Mr Lewis told the court that, having seized some 10,000 pages of notes from Mulcaire, the original inquiry in 2006 had failed to enter the material on to a computer system or to search and index it. And in 2009, after the Guardian revived the affair, Scotland Yard had finally started transferring the material to a database but had overlooked numerous documents and scanned others in a form that was not searchable, with the result that they had given misleading replies to some public figures who asked if there was evidence that they were victims. It was only when Scotland Yard launched Operation Weeting in January that the material had finally been fully searched and indexed.

Lord Prescott, Bryant, Paddick and a freelance journalist Brendan Montague, are asking the court to give permission for a judicial review of Scotland Yard’s handling of the hacking affair. Three others including the former secretary of state for media, culture and sport, Tessa Jowell, have asked the court to recognise them as interested parties.

Hugh Tomlinson QC, for the claimants, said that the police had submitted papers to the High Court which contained ‘patent factual inaccuracies’. They had refused to provide the standard undertaking that their paperwork was a statement of truth. This was ‘wholly inexplicable’, he said.

A written submission by the claimants’ solicitors, Bindman and Co, said that last autumn the police had told the High Court that they had given all of the claimants a complete summary of all of the relevant evidence in their possession, and yet it had now emerged that not one of the claimants had been given an accurate or complete account of the material which police held. Hundreds, if not thousands of victims had been left in the dark by Scotland Yard. The effect of this had been to protect News International from expense and embarassment: “We share the disquiet of the public about the police’s motivation for playing down the scale of unlawful behaviour and the way in which News International has, as a result, been shielded.”

The submission summarised evidence given to parliament by Scotland Yard’s assistant commissioner, John Yates, who had explained the narrow focus of the original investigation and the small number of victims who had been warned by claiming that the Crown Prosecution Service had given police a very narrow interpretation of the law on interception. The submission recorded that that claim had been ‘strongly contradicted’ by the head of the CPS, Keir Starmer QC.

Claims by Mr Yates that Scotland Yard had asked the four leading mobile phone companies to liaise with customers who had been victims, had been contradicted by all four companies who said they had received no such request from police.

The interception of Lord Prescott’s messages, the court was told, was achieved by targeting the phone of his then chief of staff, Joan Hammell. Glenn Mulcaire had emailed an editorial executive at the News of the World on April 28 2006 referring to 45 messages left on her phone by Prescott and providing detailed instructions about how to continue accessing Hammel’s phone. This was at a time when Prescott’s private life was under tabloid scrutiny. That email had finally been handed to police by the News of the World on January 26 this year.

Bindman’s submission said that, unlike Lord Prescott, Tessa Jowell had been approached by police in 2006. “However, she was not told the extent of the interception and was also left in the dark about precisely what had happened to her private information. Nor did she realise that the private information of close friends, cabinet colleagues and family members had been compromised. She has now been shown a very substantial amount of material by the new inquiry and is at a loss to understand why material which was available to police in 2006 was not shown to her.”

The submission concludes: “The Metropolitan Police misled the claimants and the wider public by stating that there was only ‘a handful’ of victims; and that, where there was evidence of hacking, victims were told. When those who thought they might have been victims contacted the police for fuller information, many were wrongly told that there was no evidence of hacking. It has now emerged that, contrary to the picture painted by the police, that telephone interception was extremely widespread.”

The police argued in court that, although there had been some failures, the launch of Operation Weeting had provided an adequate remedy and so there was no case for a judicial review. Mr Justice Foskett said he would make a decision in the near future as to whether to allow the review.