A lawsuit alleging a police cover-up of phone hacking has been launched by one of Scotland Yard’s own former senior officers, Brian Paddick, together with the former Labour minister Chris Bryant. The former deputy prime minister John Prescott and at least one other person are expected to join the action, which has the potential to force open some of the Metropolitan police’s locked files.
The claim for judicial review filed yesterday accuses the assistant commissioner of the Met police, John Yates, of making misleading statements to parliament and the public, and it claims that the police failed to carry out a proper investigation.
The two who are suing, along with a third – freelance journalist Brendan Montague – claim to have been likely victims of the News of the World. They name five senior journalists who may have worked with the phone-hacking private detective Glenn Mulcaire at the time when Andy Coulson was editor.
Paddick, former Met deputy assistant commissioner, feared interception after a tabloid story emerged that he had bought his partner an expensive watch while on holiday in Sydney. The claim says: “He had not told anyone apart from his partner about the purchase, but had to speak to the bank on his mobile phone … to allow the bar on his credit card to be lifted.”
Subsequently, another tabloid discovered Paddick’s then partner was on a particular transatlantic flight, and was able to accost him: “The inference must be that private information was obtained.”
Paddick says Scotland Yard last November denied having any information linking him to News of the World hacking. When pressed again, they eventually admitted his ‘name and occupation’ did in fact appear in the seized documents.
Bryant, Labour’s former Europe minister, says newspapers got hold of his father’s new phone number “only days after he had moved to a new house. His new number was not listed in the telephone directory or known to anyone other than close family members.”
The phone company Orange confirmed several illegal attempts had been made to access Bryant’s mobile phone mailbox. After five months of delay, police confirmed his name and address were in the hacking files but refused to give any further details.
The claim describes how Montague tried to sell a story about a celebrity chef to the Sunday Mirror rather than the News of the World. It alleges: “The news editor there warned him the News of the World may try to access his telephone records.” Subsequently, the phone company T-Mobile told him a fake caller had obtained copies of his phone records.
Yates is personally accused in the claim of making a number of misleading statements, including to a Commons committee: “Yates insisted all reasonable steps were taken to warn people when there was the ‘minutest possibility’ they had been hacked. That statement is not true.” The claim adds that when Yates was asked if Bryant had been warned, he gave a ‘misleading impression’ by saying that he was ‘in correspondence’ with the politician.
The claim says police deliberately ‘ring-fenced’ the investigation despite the “clear inference that numerous journalists at the News of the World and other tabloid newspapers were involved in hacking”. Scotland Yard had refused to disclose how many people they had warned, because that would have reveale that ‘only a small proportion’ had been notified.
Last week, Yates wrote to the Guardian about allegations made by Bryant: “I strongly object to the reference … of [him] accusing me of giving a misleading account and stating in respect of part of my evidence to the home affairs select committee that ‘It was a fib’. I am writing to Chris Bryant indicating that the relevant paragraph is both wrong and defamatory and asking him not to repeat it.”
In separate developments yesterday, other pending lawsuits increased the prospect of disclosure of key documents. Mulcaire faces orders to disclose the names of all News of the World employees involved with the hacking of former MP George Galloway and football agent Sky Andrew, who are suing Mulcaire and the News of the World’s parent company, News Group, for breach of privacy. A claim has also been lodged by Nicola Phillips, former assistant to celebrity PR agent Max Clifford, who claims her voicemail was intercepted as part of a News of the World operation against Clifford. News Group disputes all three claims.