Voices of America 4: the conservative

Autumn 1988, 3 November 1988

I discovered the secret of my conservative friend one Saturday afternoon in the Spring when he held a jumble sale to get rid of his cast-off possessions. There, among his old conservative clothes and his old conservative furniture, was a little book whose title caught my eye. “Look out, Whitey! Black power’s gon’ get your mama!” it said.

What ever was he doing with that? I bought it for ten cents and found that this slim, little volume with its parched pages going brown with age turned out to have some strange stories to tell about America and about my conservative friend.

You have to understand that my friend is really very conservative. He voted for Ronald Reagan to be President; he is proud that his four-year-old daughter starts each day by pledging allegiance to the American flag; he likes to trumpet the virtues of capitalism from his arm chair and frequently complains that “blacks in this town get too much just given them on a plate by the welfare system”. His old book tells a different story.

Its message is undimmed since it was written 20 years ago – in the political annus mirabilis 1968 –  by one Julius Lester, then a leading black radical in New York. Simply, it is a rallying call for violent insurrection, for black Americans to rise up and remove the heel of the white capitalist oppressor from their necks by whatever means are necessary, including riot and murder.

Some samples: “You can’t do what has been done to blacks and not expect retribution…The victim must become the executioner…We’re tired of whoring so you can wash your guilt in our blood. If there’s any washing to be done in the future, it’ll be us washing ourselves in your blood.” And so on – none of it exactly conservative.

Lester has a message not only for his black readers, but also for white radicals who might be wondering about their role in the coming conflict. Lester explains that they have one last chance to redeem themselves – by emulating John Brown, the nineteenth century white preacher who raised a volunteer army to free slaves by force of arms.

“Whites can’t help it if they’re white, but they can determine what they do. Ol’ John Brown didn’t bother to write letters to his congressman. He would’ve come riding into Birmingham, Alabama like he had ridden into Lawrence, Kansas, burning every building that stood and killing every white man, white woman and white child that ran from his onslaught. Killing, killing, killing, turning men into fountains of blood, spouting, spouting, spouting until Heaven itself drew back before the frothing red ocean.”

In the margin, by the side of this passage, some hand from the 1960s has written – “Great. What to do (white).” Whose hand scribbled that approval? It was my supposedly conservative friend. And he wrote a lot more. I began to see a whole new dimension to his philosophy.

Towards the end of the book, as Lester’s call to arms reaches its pitch, whole pages are underlined and marked with asterisks, and the margins are cluttered with enthusiastic comments, scrawled in blue biro – “Good!”, “Wow!”, “Sock it!”.

Lester fires a volley at the capitalist system. “Show me a capitalist, I’ll show you a blood sucker,” he writes. “Yes!” says the voice in the margin. “America is a country that is built upon principles of inhumanity,” says Lester. “GREAT! Tackles the whole problem,” writes the familiar hand. “Black power is not a move to have the power of this country more evenly distributed. It is a move to destroy power as it now exists,” writes Lester. “Good! Do it!” comes the voice of my conservative friend.

Can this be the same man who sings the praises of South Africa and supports the Contras in Nicaragua, who swears by private enterprise and solemnly pledges that no child of his will have sex before marriage? I asked him, and he confessed. In his words: “I used to be a raving socialist. Spent most of my time smoking dope and planning revolution.”

This was only the beginning of the secrets of this little book. Flipping to the back cover, I found a quotation from a review. “Look out, Whitey! Black power’s gon’ get your mama!” was described as “a magnificent example of the new black revolutionary writing that could generate the tidal force to sweep aside all the tired and dead matter on our literary shores”. So who wrote that? Socialist Weekly? The Revolutionary Review? No.

That was the view in 1968 of the New York Times – the absolutely respectable, entirely middle-of-the-road New York Times. Race war and revolution? “Right on,” replied the American intellectual establishment. The scruffy little book was revealing something extraordinary not just about my friend but about American society as a whole.

There was another clue to all this. Julius Lester? That name was familiar. The book merely said that he lived in New York “where he works as a Field Secretary for the Student Non-Violent Coordinating Committee”. Not any more he doesn’t.

The firey black revolutionary is now the professor of Judaic and Near Eastern studies at the University of Amherst in Massachussets. His name was familiar because he had recently clashed publicly with fellow black academics who wanted him sacked – for being too conservative. Professor Lester had attacked Jesse Jackson and the novelist James Baldwin, they complained. They called him an “anti-negro negro”. Whitey can evidently now afford to relax with his mama.

The mystery of my conservative friend’s past began to become clear: in travelling all the way across the political spectrum from one extreme to another, he had been part of an intellectual tidal wave. In 1968, he and the New York Times and Julius Lester were part of the mainstream of American thought; since then, they had simply floated with the tide and arrived in the intellectual equivalent of another world. Where have all the flowers gone? The Republican Party.

It is not that everyone in America 20 years ago was a full-blooded revolutionary, but that the political centre then was in a different place. The group of ideas and assumptions which were taken for granted, and within which political debate took place, was quite different. Reaganism then would have been as heretical and unacceptable as socialism is now.

The shift is so extreme that even those who have led it find it hard to understand it. In August, a dozen American intellectuals who were outspoken leaders in the 1960s published Political Passages, a collection of essays in which they try to explain their personal reasons for becoming conservatives. They find no common theme: some sneer at the left, some sneer at themselves, some pick on the Soviet Union, others pick on drug abuse, some trace it all to Vietnam.

But there is a common tone.  It is Professor Julius Lester himself who expresses it most neatly in his contribution to the book when he recalls an article he wrote in which he described killing as an act of love. “I read and reread those words with disbelief and shame,” he says. It is the tone of repentance, as if a whole generation of prodigal children had returned to the fold and now sought nothing more than forgiveness and acceptance from the elders they once scorned.

My conservative friend’s own explanation is largely political. At one point, he confessed, he committed his whole life to revolution – flew to Paris to join the uprising of 1968, dropped out of college to concentrate on agitation, helped to lead mass demonstrations which seriously planned to paralyse the country by disrupting key targets.

But then he peaked. “I got involved with some pretty tough people. A lot of these black guys treated us like dirt and we were only too willing to play along. Then they got hold of guns, and these people were serious. They wanted to use them and that did it for me. I didn’t want to be involved in that.” Slowly, his beliefs unravelled. As the intellectual tidal wave gathered, he began not merely to doubt but to actively loathe his former philosophy. He repented and offered atonement by embracing his former enemies on the right.

Now he lives in suburban bliss with his wife, two children, two cars, and a red-brick house full of labour-saving devices. He works for the US Government. He is now as proud of his conservative beliefs as he is ashamed of his former socialism.

Yet, despite the sweeping change, he and his friends in the New Right of the 1980s retain many characteristics from their former embodiment as the New Left of the 1960s: the faith in a magical formula for a new order where everything will be wonderful; the almost paranoid intensity of their beliefs which dismisses all doubters as enemies; the readiness to dispell all individual thinking in favour of riding on the philosophical bandwagon of the moment.

At the end of the 1950s, after Senator Joe McCarthy had disembowelled the American left, few would have predicted its revival as a mass movement in the 1960s. With the left now so unpopular that “liberal” has joined “socialist” as a political insult, the consensus is now the same. Yet, my conservative friend’s new roots are not as deep as he likes to think.

Several months after his jumble sale, I took him to a Bob Dylan concert in Maryland. It was an outdoor concert and it was raining, but Dylan was in powerful form and the atmosphere was bursting with enthusiasm. He produced a stunning version of Like a Rolling Stone and in the corner of my eye I could see my conservative friend grinning like a lunatic, punching his fist into the air and shouting with everyone else: “How does it feel? To be on your own?” Then a strange thing happened.

Someone in the crowd offered him a pipe of hash. A blast from his past. In the excitement of the moment, he accepted, but he had lost the dexterity of his youth and clumsily dropped the hash out of the bowl of the pipe, down into the muddy grass. It was dark by now, and I expected him to shrug and forget it. Instead of which he created a moment of perfect symbolism: as Dylan wailed in the background, my conservative friend sank to his kness in the dark and, frantically flicking his cigarette lighter at the mud, he grovelled in search of his past. “With no direction home. Like a complete unknown. Like a rolling stone.”