At the Republican Convention in New Orleans this summer, the co-chairman of the Republican National Committee provoked some anxiety by referring to the League of Women Voters as the League of Women Vultures and then caught the attention of a second group of party faithful by hurling crockery at them.
This co-chairman with the gentle touch is Maureen Reagan, aged 47, eldest child of the president, thrice married and thrice divorced, previously described by co-workers who prefer to remain anonymous as “an ego cannibal with a need to devour those who disagree with her” and “the kind of person who in the middle of a war would go out and shoot our wounded”.
The behaviour of this forceful First Daughter has become a rather touchy point during an election in which issues have taken a poor second place to symbols – the pledge of allegiance, the flag and, the most reliable crowd-pleaser of all, the family. It has always been compulsory for American politicians to refer at least once in every speech to ‘This Great Country of Ours’, but this year it is essential that they also use the words ‘My Wonderful Family’ and pause for applause.
The mere possession of a mate and off-spring is not, of course, enough. They must fit the fantasy, and here it is TV producers and not politicians who have set the pace. The most popular television show in America is the Cosby Show. Forty five million Americans stop their lives once a week to watch Bill Cosby as the successful, easy-going Dr Cliff Huxtable living in simple suburban bliss with his wife, Clair, and their five children.
This autumn, the show starts its fifth season. It will be challenged for its place at the top of the ratings by no less than eight other copy-cat sitcoms exploring the same theme – the mild-mannered, middle class world of an American family. It is a world where adults are always happy and healthy, children are always cute and cuddly, where there is always money in the bank and a joke in the air, where there may be problems but there are always solutions.
For the last eight years, President Reagan has been using this most popular of American fantasies as the core of his political appeal, conjuring up the prospect of a clean, healthy, all-American family life, traditional as apple pie and safe from the anxieties of the real world. Which is where his own family comes in.
It is one of the finer paradoxes on the American political scene that this President who has done so much to resurrect the ideal of My Wonderful Family (pause for applause) is himself the head of a family which is, to put it at its plainest, an emotional scrapheap, a fact which, according to those who know him best, derives directly from his own unexpected personal problems.
While his public persona is affable, easy-going and warm, the President is evidently a very different man in private without his speech-writers and his autocue. Michael Deaver, who was the President’s closest adviser until alcohol and influence-peddling brought him down, says in his memoirs that he has never once seen the president show genuine emotion. Simple as that.
Don Regan, the former chief of staff, found a man who was emotionally crippled by self-doubt and says that he and Michael Deaver spent much of their time trying to massage the president’s self-confidence by “organising a psychic atmosphere in which he was routinely made aware of the good things that were being said about him.”
This unhappy man’s relationship with his four children seems to fluctuate between the merely unpleasant and the completely non-existent. The president’s former PR man, Larry Speakes, professed himself amazed at the emotional desert in which the First Family lived. He was particularly struck during periods when the president was ill. “Most of the time, the children didn’t call to see how he was, and he and Mrs Reagan didn’t call them. It was very strange.”
In the case of Maureen, who is Reagan’s oldest child and the product of his marriage to Hollywood actress Jane Wyman, the amateur psychiatrists on Capitol Hill have her marked down as a classic case of a child going to self-destructive lengths to win attention from a father who has never bothered with her. “She is like a child with a father fetish,” according to a leading California Republican, Mary Stanley.
When Maureen was eight, her parents divorced. Jane Wyman took custody of her and packed her off to boarding school while she concentrated on acting. Her father, she has said, visited her only occasionally during the next three years and then stopped seeing her altogether when he married Nancy who wanted him to make a fresh start without any burdens from his first marriage. Maureen remained locked out. Speaking of her father and Nancy, she once told an interviewer: “They live in a world of their own. They don’t need anybody else.”
Maureen dropped out of college, worked as a secretary, married a traffic cop because, she told friends, it would upset her father, divorced him, went through two more weddings which her father did not bother to attend, and maintained a relationship which is symbolised by the fact that when she needed to borrow money, her father told her to deal with his lawyer and charged her interest on the loan.
Now, reborn as a daughter of the Reagan revolution, Maureen treats the Republican Party to the full range of her pent-up feelings. She loves the party and works with inspired devotion; she hates it and pours vicious scorn on those around her. Aides walk out or, in one case, collapse in tears on the floor, but her father now rewards her with a little attention and even lets her stay at the White House when she is in Washington.
When Maureen was four, her parents adopted a boy, Michael, because Reagan wanted a son and Jane Wyman did not want to interrupt her career with another pregnancy. Michael’s story, disclosed in his autobiography earlier this year, makes Maureen’s miserable childhood look like a scene from the Cosby Show: given away by his natural mother; packed off to boarding school by his new mother; deserted by his new father who went off and remarried; sexually molested at school camp when he was seven.
Like Maureen, he found himself locked out of his father’s second marriage. In High School, he argued with Nancy about his bad school marks, and she told him to buck up or leave the family. He challenged her to tell him his real mother’s name so that he could do just that. A week later an icy Nancy obliged, throwing in the news that he was illegitimate as she showed him to the door.
As an adult, Michael found himself accused of being a kleptomaniac by the Secret Service who told the president that Michael was mentally ill and should go to a psychiatrist. Michael protested his innocence, but the president and Nancy told him they agreed with the Secret Service. Michael eventually proved his innocence and his sanity and received a written apology from the Secret Service but, by that time, it was too late for the president to play the good father.
Reagan’s two children from his marriage to Nancy have also had a difficult time. Their daughter, Patti, has not been on speaking terms since the publication two years ago of her novel whose portrayal of family life was painfully close to autobiography. The youngest son, Ron Jr, maintains a tactful distance, making little secret of his disregard for the First Couple.
But it is only Reagan’s touting of the Wonderful Family ideal that makes his own family wreckage notable, for, in truth, it is the Reagan Family and not the fictitious Cosby Family which represents the real norm. Two conservative sociologists, Sar Levitan and Richard Belous, who welcomed the Reagan era seven years ago with a book which foresaw a revival of traditional family values, have just published a new edition in which they acknowledge that the fantasy has not been realised.
“The optimism reflected in the first edition of this book, that the conservative national turn would affect family stability, did not materialise… President Reagan and his allies in the self-proclaimed Moral Majority were successful at the ballot box, but not in the bedroom.”
Presidential candidates, however, are not about to let a few stupid facts interrupt their campaigns. Michael Dukakis routinely opens his speeches by introducing My Wonderful Wife and pausing in the required manner, while George Bush has marshalled up to 68 relatives at a time for ‘photo opportunities’ and, after a shaky start, has even started hugging the mighty Barbara in public. Wonderful, indeed.