If the new film about the life of Jesus, The Last Temptation of Christ, survives the organised hysteria which is now assailing it, its director Martin Scorsese should give thanks to a frail Russian immigrant to America, who once faced a similar barrage of hostility and was destroyed by it.
By chance it is exactly seventy years this week since a young Russian bookbinder called Jacob Abrams brought the American establishment crashing down around his head by daring to publish a leaflet pleading with Americans not to support the army which President Woodrow Wilson had just sent to the Soviet Union to attack the new born Bolshevik revolution.
It was not exactly a major publishing event. On August 22 1918, several dozen copies of the leaflet, which was written in Yiddish, were scattered by Abrams and four friends from the roof of a tenement building on the seedy Lower East Side of New York. All five of them were promptly arrested, thrown into jail, beaten and charged with the criminal offence of conspiracy “to utter…disloyal, scurrilous and abusive language about the United States”.
The five, who were all anarchists of one shade or another, were tried in an atmosphere of strident patriotism, inspired by American involvement in the First World War. This mood of aggressive nationalism steam-rollered their plea that the constitution guaranteed them free speech. In court, when Abrams claimed the American heritage of freedom as his own by referring to “our forefathers of the American revolution”, the judge angrily cut across the little immigrant. “Your what?” he demanded.
One of the five died from the injuries he received at the hands of the New York police. Abrams and the three others were sentenced to a crippling 20 years in jail and sent to the federal penitentiary in Alabama where, according to prison rules, inmates were liable to be flogged, to wear heavy leg irons and manacles, and to be hung by their thumbs for discipline.
Their lawyer eventually secured a deal for them which permitted their early release on condition that they be banished from the country for ever. Years later, in 1953, a frail and sickly Jacob Abrams was given an emergency visa allowing him to return to the United States for treatment for the throat cancer which was killing him. Two armed FBI agents kept him under surveillance 24 hours a day until his treatment was finished and he was sent back to his exile in Mexico to die.
The relevance of this act of heavy-handed persecution to the beleaguered Martin Scorsese is that from their cells in Alabama in 1919, Abrams and his three fellow prisoners appealed against their conviction to the Supreme Court and struck a chord with Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, the most revered liberal jurist in the history of American law.
Holmes was brave enough to stand up to the national mood and he handed down a judgement which, decades later, still resounds: “When men have realised that time has upset many fighting faiths, they may come to believe – even more than they believe the very foundations of their own conduct – that the ultimate good desired is better reached by free trade in ideas.”
Holmes argued that the right to free speech was basic to human society and could be compromised only by the present danger of immediate evil. “The defendants had as much right to publish (the leaflets) as the government of the United States has to publish the Constitution of the United States,” he concluded.
But Holmes was ahead of his chauvinistic time. His colleagues on the Supreme Court over-rode him and rejected the appeal. A Harvard lawyer who had helped Holmes draft his ruling was vilified by his university colleagues who said he was unfit to “be entrusted with the training of youth”. The national mood asserted itself over the claims of freedom.
Holmes’ dissenting judgement, however, was preserved and subsequently, in more liberal times, became the precedent for Supreme Court rulings which now establish precisely the freedom which was denied to Jacob Abrams – but which now protects Martin Scorsese.
In Britain, the Attorney General has declared he will consider prosecuting the distributors of the film for the archaic criminal offence of blasphemy. In America, thanks to Jacob Abrams, and to the chagrin of the film’s opponents, Scorsese has the law on his side. But he faces something else just as unpleasant, which also underlay the hounding of Abrams – a national mood of surly paranoia.
The terrible furore over the film in America has been one of those events which plough deep into a nation’s culture and churn up issues and assumptions which are normally hidden and which, once exposed, turn out to be ugly and indefensible.
Opponents of the film claim to find the film blasphemous because it portrays Christ as a man plagued by doubt about his own divinity and even tempted into sexual fantasy. Yet the film is, in most respects, a work of traditional Christianity, accepting without question that God and the Devil exist and that Jesus was literally God’s son. Many American Christians are happy with its treatment of Jesus and temptation. So, the intellectual debate has been reduced to doctrinal angst about the small print of Christianity. Manichaeism and the third century heresy of Docetism have become contemporary insults between feuding wings of the American church.
However, the power of the protests on the street reflects something quite different, a facet of life in the United States which is now commonplace and yet generally unrecognised – the deep intolerance of many Americans to any challenge to their accepted way of looking at the world. Americans can be the most dogmatic of democrats and will, at their paradoxical worst, abuse and squander the freedoms about which they so love to boast.
At an everyday social level, Americans habitually claim that theirs is “the greatest country in the world” and flare up in a defensive panic at anyone who dares to question the claim. At a political level, when the rest of the world condemns them – for shooting down the Iran Air jet or bombing residential areas of Tripoli – they huddle together around the flag and work themselves up into a froth of patriotic indignation.
Scorsese’s film has released this intolerance at a cultural level. I saw the film in Washington last week. Outside, Christian Americans chanted and occasionally threatened. “Don’t Mess with Jesus,” said their placards. Inside, armed policemen chained off the end of the aisles to protect the screen, nervously searched under the seats and rifled through everybody’s bags because, they said, the Christians had threatened to put a bomb in the cinema.
The Rev Donald Wildmon of The American Family Association is organising a holy boycott of Universal Pictures. “I guarantee you that we’re going to do everything we can to determine that Universal Pictures commits financial suicide,” he says. “We’re putting everything we’ve got into it.”
Wildmon, who promotes ‘the Biblical ethic of decency’ from an office in Tupelo, Mississippi, succeeded in 1983 in putting such pressure on Paramount Pictures that they cancelled an earlier contract for Scorsese to make the film. The Rev R.L.Hymers, a Baptist pastor from Los Angeles, suggested that cinema screens should be slashed or sprayed with paint. Bill Bright of the Campus Crusade for Christ tried to buy up all copies of the film so that he could burn them unseen.
The film’s opponents have staged mock crucifictions outside the home of the film’s producers, painted glue over the floor of toilets in offending cinemas, and successfully used the threat of a mass boycott to persuade one of the country’s biggest film distributors, General Cinema, to refuse to handle it. The embrace of threats and blackmail by Christians is only the beginning of the irony.
The parodoxes multiply. They claim to be protecting the King of the Jews while they engage in openly anti-semitic attacks on the Jewish producers of the film (“Jewish money, Jewish money” the Christian pickets chant.) They claim to be defending family values by attacking a film which romanticises and celebrates precisely the same values
This group of fundamentalist preachers who condemn out of hand the very idea that Christ might be tempted by sex are the same bible-thumpers whose ranks have recently spawned Jim Bakker and Jimmy Swaggart, priests whose temptation lasted only as long as it took to lock the door and get down to business.
The fact that they have refused to watch the film which they are attacking is less damning than the inevitable comparisons which are drawn by those who have seen it between the Rev Wildmon and his flock and the hypocritical rabbis in the film, clothed in gold, ensconced in dogma and sternly scolding the rebel Jesus who dares to enter their temple and tell them they have got it all wrong.
For the opponents of the film, Justice Holmes’ endorsement of the free trade in ideas is less a liberation than a constraint on their ability to bully their targets. Which points to the deepest paradox – the use of freedom to inflict intolerance. As Scorsese’s Christ tells the hypocritical rabbis:”You think God belongs only to you. God belongs to everyone.” Freedom, too.