‘Mad Frankie’ Fraser – a legend in his own gaol time

The Guardian, 12 October 1980

Frank Fraser is a thorn in the Prison Department’s side – a thorn so big that he is possibly the only British criminal who has become a legend simply by serving time.

Prisoners and ex-prisoners all over Britain speak about him with undisguised admiration. They tell stories about him, and one man in Gartree prison wrote a song about him which he recorded when he was released.

The kernel of the legend is that he is too tough for the prison authorities to tame. He has attacked prison officers and governors; been beaten and sent to hospital; led protests and a riot; spent years in solitary; and dragged the Prison Department through the courts.

The prison authorities have no sympathy with the legend. Officers nicknamed him Mad Frankie – a name which was picked up by the popular press. They see him as a vicious psychopath who needs discipline. But privately they concede that his relentless rebellion and his status among other prisoners are a worrying clue to the weakness of their policy for dealing with professional criminals.

Fraser is 56, and is in Armley Gaol, Leeds. He has been in custody since 1966. Since he was 13, he has spent a total of 32 years in prison cells, and only 12 years at liberty. So long is his career as a prisoner that he has seen two generations of prison authorities: the governor of Strangeways in Manchester, where he is an occasional inmate, is the son of the man who ran Portland Borstal when he was there in 1939.

At liberty, he was courted by the Kray twins, recruited by the Richardson gang, and was one of the central characters in the shifting power struggle among London villains in the 50s and 60s. His progress through the courts suggests that he was immune to the intended deterrence of successively higher sentences.

He was first sent to approved school in 1938, aged 13, for stealing 40 cigarettes. He escaped, was recaptured and was sent to Borstal, where he proved so hard to control that he was transferred to Chelmsford prison. There he met Billy Hill and other East End figures with whom he was to work for the next 15 years.

On his release, he was sentenced to six months, then 15 months, then 21 months, and then three years, for stealing cigarettes again – a quarter of a million this time. He was twice certified insane. On each sentence he lost virtually all the remission available. He was once sentenced to 18 strokes of the birch. None of this stopped him.

He had been at liberty for only a year when in 1956 he was convicted of slashing Jack ‘Spot’ Comer, who was fighting Billy Hill for control of London’s gangs. He was imprisoned for seven years, and again he lost nearly all his remission.

In his remaining two years of liberty, in 1964 and 1965, he earned himself a fiveyear sentence for his part in the Battle of Mr Smith’s Club – a furious outbreak of violence between the Richardsons and another gang – and a further ten years for his role as the Richardsons’ henchman.

A normal prisoner would have been released in 1976. Instead, he lost all his remission again, refused to compromise with the authorities by applying for parole, and picked up an extra five years for his part in a bloody riot at Parkhurst in 1969.

To try to control him, the Prison Department switches him repeatedly from one prison to another. He has been in Bedford, Parkhurst, Bristol, Hull, Gartree, Leicester, Wakefield, Wandsworth, Chelmsford, Cardiff, Shrewsbury, Wormwood Scrubs, Strangeways, Exeter, Lewes, Gloucester, Canterbury, Winson Green, Norwich, Durham, Leeds, Dorchester, Stafford, and Lincoln – often more than once.

In Wandsworth he lost 300 days’ remission and was put in solitary confinement for 400 days for joining a protest about new productivity rates for sewing mail bags.

In Leicester he lost 168 days’ remission for hitting the governor and went on hunger strike for 34 days to protest that he had been unjustly punished.

In Bristol he lost more remission for attacking two prison officers – a charge which he vigorously denied. His lawyers went before Lord Denning to ask for permission to act for Fraser at the internal disciplinary hearing. They were unsuccessful.

In Parkhurst he led the 1969 riot and received a five-year sentence. Paradoxically, he sued eight prison officers and an assistant governor and was awarded damages out of court by the Home Office. On that occasion he had 48 stitches in his face and a broken nose, and was confined to a wheelchair for several weeks.

He had his ribs broken during one of his stays in Wandsworth, and was forcibly injected with drugs in Chelmsford.

The friction between Fraser and the prison officers came to a head in 1971 when a Wakefield officer was conditionally discharged after stealing Fraser’s medical records and sending threatening letters to his sister. The officer had slipped part of the medical record, which suggested that Fraser would spend 20 years in solitary, under his cell door “to blow him up to kick up trouble, so the authorities would have him moved.”

Fraser’s family say he is often the target for officers who dislike his reputation, or fear him. “Nine out of ten times they are deliberately provoking him,” said his sister, Eva Brindle.

The conflicts go on. In Lincoln last year, Fraser was told that he had to wear shoes, not the slippers he is normally allowed to wear for medical reasons. He argued, got nowhere, and responded by tipping his slop pot over the governor’s head. He lost 200 days’ remission.

In Norwich he met an officer who had worked at Parkhurst and who told him that he was glad that he had been given an extra five years. There was a fight, and Fraser lost another 56 days’ remission.

His detractors say this is all evidence of a character who deserves all the punish-ment he attracts. His supporters say it shows that long sentences, solitary con-finement, loss of remission, and parole opportunities are ineffective and even counter-productive.