The Chief Constable of West Yorkshire last night ordered an inquiry into the force’s handling of the hunt for the Yorkshire Ripper in the wake of the 20 life sentences passed on Peter Sutcliffe at the Old Bailey.
The need for an inquiry was taken up in the House of Commons by Yorkshire MPs, who also attacked the Attorney General, Sir Michael Havers, for his role in the prosecution of Sutcliffe.
Sir Michael opened the 15-day trial by telling the judge, Mr Justice Boreham, that he did not believe that Sutcliffe was guilty of murder. He told the judge that he accepted the view of doctors who diagnosed Sutcliffe as a schizophrenic. But the judge refused to accept this and yesterday the jury decided that he had murdered 13 women in the Yorkshire area between 1975 and 1980.
The judge passed sentences of life imprisonment for each of the 13 murders as well as the seven attempted murders which Sutcliffe admitted at the start of the trial. He said he hoped that Sutcliffe would never be released and recommended that he should serve at least 30 years before release was even considered.
One of the defence psychiatrists was called into the witness box to confirm that the state of Sutcliffe’s schizophrenia was such that “he should be in custody for the rest of his natural life.” The judge said that 30 years was an unusually long period, but added: “I believe you are an unusually dangerous man.”
After passing sentence, the judge commended three of the officers from the Ripper Squad for their impeccable conduct. He also commended the two Sheffield officers who arrested Sutcliffe in January and later found weapons which he had tried to conceal.
The acting Assistant Chief Constable of West Yorkshire, Mr Jim Hobson, who was at the Old Bailey, said that it was ridiculous to suggest that they could have caught Sutcliffe earlier. “The judge has answered most of these criticisms,” he said. “I am very pleased with what he has said.”
But in Leeds, his chief constable, Mr Ronald Gregory, said that some of his senior officers woud start an internal inquiry. “There will be some reorganisation and some changes made in the light of our experience,” he added.
He said that Sutcliffe had been “extremely lucky and very clever.” He added: “The truth is that we never had sufficient evidence to charge Sutcliffe. He was interviewed several times at home. His wife gave him alibis, and nothing was found in his garage or car.” He had never been among the 60 top suspects.
The mother of Sutcliffe’s last victim, Mrs Doreen Hill, said at the court that she intended to question Mr Gregory about the police investigation. “Certain aspects of the police handling of the case, I am not keen on,” she said. The mother of another victim, Mrs Irene MacDonald, also supported the call for an inquiry.
In the Commons, Mr Bob Cryer, Labour MP for Keighley, called on the Home Secretary to add his weight to the post-mortem. “There are some clear blunders and discrepancies,” he said.
Mr Tom Torney, Labour MP for Bradford South, added: “I absolutely deplore the Attorney General’s stance in this matter, and the judge was quite right to refuse to accept these pleas.”
Sutcliffe’s wife, Sonia, was not in court to hear her husband sentenced. The back row was taken up with relatives of the dead and survivors of some of Sutcliffe’s attacks. All said that they were glad the jury had agreed on a murder verdict. “If they’d have said diminished responsibility, I would have exploded,” said one.
The jury of six men and six women took five hours and fifty-five minutes to reach their verdict and did so only after the judge, Mr Justice Boreham, told them that they need not be unanimous. When they returned at 4.18 it took the jury foreman seven minutes to deliver the 13 verdicts of murder by a majority of 10 to two to the clerk of the court, Mr Michael MacKenzie.
The judge then turned to the dock: “Peter William Sutciffe, the jury have found you guilty of 13 charges of murder, and, if I may say so, murder of a very cowardly quality.
“It is difficult to find words that are adequate in my judgement to describe the brutality and the gravity of these offences, and I say at once I am not going to pause to seek those words. I am prepared to let the catalogue of your crimes speak for itself.”
The judge said that in deciding on his sentence, he had considered the depth in human terms of the terror which he had brought to a wide area of Yorkshire. “It is a population which to my knowledge does not lack fortitude. But I am left in no doubt that women from a wide area were in the deepest fear and I have no doubts too, that that fear spilled over to their men folk on their account.”
He said he had also considered the danger which Sutcliffe would represent in the future if he were at large. “I have no doubt that you are a very dangerous man indeed,” he added. “The sentence for murder is laid down by the law and is immutable. It is a sentence that you be imprisoned for life.”
He told Sutcliffe that he would recommend to the Home Secretary that he should serve at least 30 years. “That is a long period,” he said, “an unusually long period, but I believe you are an unusually dangerous man. I express the hope that when I have said life imprisonment, it will mean precisely that.
“For reasons that I have already discussed with your counsel in your presence, I do believe that I can make that as a recommendation in statute.”
The judge finally told Sutcliffe that the seven charges of attempted murder, to which he pleaded guilty at the start of the trial, also incurred life sentences. “You may go,” he said.
The prison officers turned, and at 4.22, Sutcliffe, his face still expressionless, descended the steps into the cells to begin his sentence at Wormwood Scrubs, London. He will later be moved to Wakefield.
The judge then went on to commend the members of “the Ripper Squad, as I think they all themselves” and cited by name Sergeant Desmond O’Boyle, Sergeant Peter Smith and Detective Inspector John Boyle, the three officers who conducted the interviews with Sutcliffe in which he admitted the killings.
“It is unfortunate but true that there are often allegations of impropriety against policemen. Sometimes, they are, unhappily, well-founded. Often, they are ill-founded. In this case these three officers behaved quite immaculately. They never put a foot wrong, and that can be said of few of us.”
He went on to commend the two uniformed officers who arrested Sutcliffe with a Sheffield prostitute, Olivia Reivers, in January: Sergeant Bob Ring and Constable Bob Hyde. “They were engaged in what I suspect from what I heard, sitting in this court, is often a very humdrum, routine duty.
“They must be very grateful, and the public in general and Miss Reivers in particular must be very relieved, that these basic police tasks which they perform were carried out assiduously and with such attention to duty.”
Referring to a remark made by Sergeant Ring to Sutcliffe during the arrest, the judge said: “I do not mean to introduce levity, but I cannot help but recall the remarks of the officer – that he had not fallen off a Christmas tree. We are very grateful that he had not.”
The judge closed by telling the jurors that they need not serve on a jury again for ten years unless they wanted to; and by commending the barristers who had helped to conduct the trial so speedily. He hoped that the taxing authorities would bear this in mind when they came to examine the costs of the defence.
Those in court to hear the verdict included Mrs Hill, the mother of Jacqueline Hill, the 19-year-old girl who became the last murder victim. Had she lived, Jacqueline would have been celebrating her 21st birthday yesterday and announcing her engagement. Mrs Beryl Leach whose daughter, Barbara, was murdered in Bradford by Sutcliffe in September, 1979, was sitting alongside her husband, David.
Outside the court, a crowd of about 250 people cheered loudly when news of the verdicts reached them. Mr Jim Hobson, acting assistant chief constable in the West Yorkshire police force, was advised not to walk straight out of the Old Bailey by uniformed officers in case he was mobbed. But Mr Hobson appeared, to loud shouts.
Senior detectives in the Ripper Squad may have to interview Sutcliffe again in an attempt to discover whether his catalogue of killing and brutality is much worse than has been revealed. West Yorkshire police have had discussions with Strathclyde detectives about certain murder cases in Scotland.
The murders, thought to number at least five, involved prostitutes, although as far as is known there is no evidence to suggest that Sutcliffe was responsible. Sutcliffe did, however, make many working trips to Scotland and to the Strathclyde area in particular.
There are also a number of unsolved attacks on women in the north of England that West Yorkshire police will probably raise with Sutcliffe. Mr Hobson confirmed yesterday that there had been formal contact between Strathclyde and his own force.