A second Battle of Stonehenge appears likely this summer after the failure of the Summit of Salisbury to agree on a peace formula between warring landowners and festival-goers.
When police in riot gear clashed with the Peace Convoy last June, there were scores of injuries and more than 500 arrests. In an attempt to avoid a repetition of such events, the various sides met in Salisbury town hall on Friday night.
It was no ordinary meeting. Pagans, Druids, Odinists, worshippers of the sun and the moon, the Daughters of Albion and the Robin Greenwood gang sat side by side in neat rows with the Country Landowners’ Association, the National Farmers’ Union and the vicars, councillors and villagers of Wiltshire.
They quoted the Magna Carta and the rights of man; discussed pollution and nuclear war; called for liberty, respect for private property and the law, the legalisation of cannabis and the growth of pagan ritual.
But always the debate came back to the ancient stones, the scene of an annual free festival since 1974. It is regarded by the Wiltshire establishment as an orgy of violence, lawlessness and anti-social behaviour. By festival-goers it is seen as the central event of their year, the focus of their social and religious life.
The National Trust, which owns the land at Stonehenge, and English Heritage, which owns the stones themselves, began the meeting in uncompromising style. There was no question, they said, of allowing a festival there in 1986. Too much damage had been done in the past.
Not so, said the festival-goers: the worst of the damage had been caused by farmers and by police trying to evict them in 1984. In any case, they argued, this was a religious event and they had a right to peacefully worship.
The Archdruid of the Druid Order, David Loxley, complained that some festival-goers had interfered with his group’s ritual: “If that was spiritual and peaceful, then bank robbery and invasion are spiritual and peaceful.”
Prudence Jones, who wore a purple suit and sensible shoes, spoke up on behalf of the Pagan Anti-Defamation League. She wanted more than solemn ceremony at the stones – traditional Pagan games and dancing, for example: “We want a jolly, enjoyable, exciting festival.”
Tamith Maat of the Temple of Black Flame and Silver Star agreed: “We have to have access to our sacred sites from the new moon on 7 June to the full moon on the 24th.”
But the Wiltshire farmers and councillors were not to be moved. They acknowledged the right to worship but insisted that the real issue was violence, intimidation and theft. David Lever from the Farmers’ Union said crops and animals had to be protected – but denied that his members had passed a resolution to shoot all hippies.
The argument raged on. Willy X (“I am the Christ and the messiah”) of the Polyantric Circle said 200 people had been at the stones for the spring equinox last week. Sid Rawle, leader of the Peace Convoy, advised farmers to “raise a good crop of hippies and make some money out of them.”
Both sides suggested compromises such as finding an alternative site, building a Wood Henge for the festival, suspending the festival for at least a year, shortening it from one month to a fortnight, improving the organisation. But none was taken up.
The Rev Peter Lewes, vicar of Amesbury, could see little chance of reaching any agreement: “I can’t see that either side is willing to back down.” Don Aitken, chairman of the Festival Welfare Services, said: “Things are cracking up in the same way as last year. There is no reason to suppose that anything will be different this year. People are still in their entrenched positions.”
One final resolution of the problem remains. Wiltshire police are appealing against a magistrate’s decision to dimiss almost all of the charges brought against those arrested last year. The High Court decision is expected to establish whether that police operation was legal. If not, the festival may go ahead regardless of local opposition.