The last of the 38 Special Patrol Group officers to give evidence at the Blair Peach inquest yesterday all denied seeing anyone hit by a police truncheon.
Mr Peach, a teacher from New Zealand, aged 33, was taking part in a demonstration against the National Front In Southall a year ago. He died from a fractured skull.
Sergeant Anthony Lake, the officer in charge of the second SPG van which went down Beechcroft Avenue, was challenged about his claim that he saw a van, not his own, stopping at the corner of the street where Mr Peach was fatally injured to let several policemen get inside. Mr Stephen Sedley, counsel for the Peach family, told him that the driver of that van, PC Raymond White, had already given evidence that he drove away from the corner with the van empty.
In earlier evidence two officers, including Inspector Douglas Hopkins, said that they had boarded the van at the corner with a prisoner. Sgt Lake said he knew the two officers concerned but he did not recognise them among the policemen who got in. Sgt Lake said he had been interviewed four times by officers investigating the death of Mr Peach, and he had made five or six statements. He had stood on one identification parade, but none of the eight witnesses picked him out.
Cross-examined by Mr Richard Harvey, for the Anti-Nazi League, Sgt Lake agreed that he had failed to record later that shields had been drawn in Beechcroft Avenue. He did not know why he had omitted this detail; nor could he give an explanation of why he had not asked his constables whether they had drawn their truncheons; he did not see any truncheons being drawn.
He said he had first got out of his van at the top of Beechcroft Avenue – about 100 yards from where Mr Peach was struck – and he had run down with a shield to assess the situation. At the bottom he summoned his van and boarded it at the corner.
Another SPG officer, PC Brian Lovell – asked by Mr Sedley to say what else he had been doing in Beechcroft that he had not described in his evidence – replied that he had described everything. PC Lovell had told the court how he had jumped out of the second van at the top of Beechcroft Avenue, run down the avenue into the cul-de-sac at the bottom and into a house where he stopped a demonstrator. He then walked back up Beechcroft Avenue to the Broadway where he found his van parked nearby.
Questioned by Mr Sedley, PC Lovell agreed that the chase he had described would have taken three or four minutes. But Mr Sedley said it would take “a much longer span of time” for the vans to leave the Broadway, travel down Beechcroft Avenue, stop, continue along Orchard Avenue, stop and return to the Broadway for PC Lovell to find them. “Would you like to tell us what else you may have done during the time you were in Beechcroft Avenue?” asked Mr Sedley. “I didn’t do anything else,” PC Lovell replied.
Dr John Burton, the coroner, asked PC Lovell whether, as he ran through the cul-de-sac, he had seen PC Richardson, who has told the inquest that he ran through it in pursuit of two demonstrators. PC Lovell: “I seem to remember him at that cul-de-sac but I can’t be certain about it. I don’t remember what he was doing. I can’t be certain about it but I seem to remember him being there, but exactly where it was – whether I was running down or coming back – I just can’t remember, sir.”
PC Stephen Hill, the driver of Sgt Lake’s van, said he had jumped out at the top of Beechcroft Avenue and had been in the front of the officers who ran down the avenue. “There was a crowd of demonstrators at the end of the road,” he said. “They were throwing bricks, bottles and various missiles. I ran down the left side of the pavement trying to avoid the bricks and stones and then zig-zagged across the road. Half way down I drew my truncheon and crossed over to the left side.”
He turned into Orchard Avenue with the intention of dispersing the fleeing crowd and, half way down, he said, he pushed a man with both hands. “He was smartly dressed, in a blazer, and I didn’t know if he was a demonstrator or not. It was partly for his own protection. I wanted the street cleared. I think I shouted ‘Get out of it’.”
The inquest was adjourned.