Lawyers highlight discrepancies in police evidence

The Guardian, 15 May 1980

A series of discrepancies in the evidence of Special Patrol Group officers was highlighted yesterday by counsel for the family of Blair Peach at the resumed inquest into his death.

One SPG man was accused of remembering ‘just enough to exculpate himself from any blame’ for the death of Mr Peach, who died from a fractured skull after taking part in demonstrations against a National Front meeting in Southall last April 23.

Three other officers who said that they had left the place where Mr Peach was to receive a fatal blow to his head before the incident occurred, found their evidence contradicted by PC Raymond White who told the court that he had no recollection of any of the three officers being in his van as he drove away from the scene shortly before Mr Peach was struck.

Two officers, PC Freestone and PC Scottow, both said that they had been running down Beechcroft Avenue towards the Broadway at the time of the incident, but PC Scottow told Mr Sedley that he could not remember seeing any officer running near him at the time. Mr Sedley and Mr Richard Harvey, counsel for the Anti-Nazi League, described to the two officers the ‘posse of policemen’ who had been chasing an Asian with a yellow sweater through Beechcroft Avenue close to where the officers placed themselves. Neither officer could remember seeing the chase.

The officers are all said to have been in an SPG van driven by PC White which drove from the Broadway, where the main demonstration had been held, into Beechcroft Avenue which turns into a T-junction with Orchard Avenue. Mr Peach is believed to have received his injury at the junction of the two avenues.

PC Michael Freestone, who has since been transferred out of the SPG, said that he was exhausted by the time the van arrived in Beechcroft Avenue: he had been carrying a heavy riot shield round all afternoon and was also suffering some pain in his back after being struck in the kidneys by a bottle.

The van had stopped just over two thirds of the way down the road. He had got out and seen a white man holding a brick, as if to throw it at him. He had started to chase the man who turned and ran back towards the Broadway. He had been too exhausted to catch him and soon gave up the chase, he said.

Under cross-examination, PC Freestone said that he could not remember how the van had first driven into Beechcroft Avenue; nor whether it had stopped, slowed down, or made a clean sweep; nor who was in the van; nor who was in charge of the van; nor which door he got out of; nor who had ordered him to get out of the van.

He said that he could not describe the man who he had chased and that he had been too exhausted to point him out to any other officer. He could not remember what he had seen while he was walking back down Beechcroft Avenue; nor where he found his van, nor who was in it when he rejoined it, nor or whether officers had their truncheons drawn in Orchard Avenue.

Mr Sedley said: “I suggest that you can remember just enough to exculpate yourself from any blame for this incident.” PC Freestone replied: “Not at all, sir.”

PC Anthony Richardson, who has since been transferred out of the SPG, said that the van drove nearly to the bottom of Beechcroft Avenue before stopping. He had jumped out to chase two youths who he had seen running down the avenue away from the missile-throwing at the Broadway end.

He had chased them into the Orchard Avenue cul-de-sac right at the end of Beechcroft Avenue. They had jumped over a wire fence and ducked through an alley. He had half-climbed the fence before deciding that there was no hope of catching them. He had turned back into Beechcroft Avenue and walked away from the rest of his colleagues until he had reached the Broadway. There he joined another SPG van and waited a few minutes before his own van appeared and he could rejoin his colleagues.

Mr Sedley described to him ‘the row of about eight officers’ mentioned by other witnesses as chasing an Asian man with a yellow sweater into the same cul-de-sac. PC Richardson said that he had not seen them. He had not seen any officers in the area with their truncheons drawn, he added. He was sure that he had got into a van in the Broadway but he could not remember exactly where it was nor how many people were on it nor whether the driver was a man or woman. He had rejoined his own van but he could not remember whether it was completely empty or completely full.

PC James Scottow, who has since left the SPG, said that his van stopped about 25 yards before the end of Beechcroft Avenue. As he jumped out, he had the impression that there was something going on at the avenue’s junction with Orchard Avenue. “I can remember seeing police helmets – that’s what sticks in my mind – and the crowd jostling,” he said. He had realised that other demonstrators were still coming down the avenue from the Broadway and he was afraid they might hem in his colleagues. He had turned towards the Broadway to disperse them.

He agreed that he had used strong language and swung his truncheon to scatter the crowd. Having done that, he had turned back towards Orchard Avenue and had found he was virtually alone. He had trotted round into Orchard Avenue. “As I got round the corner, I saw a man sitting on the pavement. I can’t remember whether I actually stopped. I may have paused momentarily or slowed down as I was running. I told him to clear off. I think my exact words were: ‘And you, mate. On your bike.'” He now believed that this man could have been Mr Peach and he had told his inspector about this incident a few days later.

Cross-examined by Mr Sedley, he said that he could not remember any other officer from his van running alongside him back towards the Broadway; nor any officer chasing a man with a brick in that direction and giving up from exhaustion. He told Mr Harvey that he had not seen any other officers with truncheons in the area, nor had he seen any officers strike anyone. He had not seen anyone injured. “In that case,” asked Harvey, “how is it that you connected the man on the pavement with the person who had been killed?” PC Scottow replied that had read in a newspaper that Mr Peach had been seen sitting on the pavement.

PC Raymond White, who has been suspended from duty since last June, described how he drove the SPG van down Beechcroft Avenue and stopped near the left-hand junction with Orchard Avenue. Mr Sedley told PC White that the court had heard evidence that Inspector Hopkins and PC Page had got in to his van with a prisoner as he was parked at the junction with Orchard Avenue. “I don’t recollect them being there,” said PC White.

Mr Sedley told him that PC Bint had remembered getting into the van on the corner with another prisoner. “My recollection is that I drove along Orchard Avenue empty,” said PC White. PC Greville Bint was the only officer on the van to say that it stopped briefly at the junction of Beechcroft Avenue and the Broadway.

The inquest continues.

** PC Raymond White, the Special Patrol Group officer who was found to have seven unauthorised weapons in his locker, yesterday told the inquest on the death of Blair Peach that he had tried to conceal one of them, a metal cosh, when he realised that his locker was about to be searched.

Another officer, PC Greville Bint, had told the coroner earlier about his collection of Nazi regalia. They had been found at his home as well as British regimental badges and bayonets and a leather-covered, lead-weighted piece of wood.

PC White, who was suspended after the search, said he had been changing by his locker when he heard that officers from the Complaints Investigation Bureau were on the way. “I think in a moment of panic, or whatever happens in those split seconds, I suddenly, sillily put the cosh in my anorak pocket. There was no point, because the anorak was there for them to see anyway,” he said.

He had been keeping a crowbar and a jemmy in his locker to help with executing search warrants. The metal cosh and a long whip were souvenirs of a trip to America. He had found a whip handle on the floor of one of the SPG vans.

PC White rejected a suggestion from Mr Stephen Sedley, for the Peach family, that he was the SPG unit’s ‘armourer’.

PC George Woodcock said that the large American truncheon which had been found in his locker had been given to him by a policeman with whom he had stayed in the United States in 1966.

PC Bint said that he collected Nazi regalia and other military objects as a hobby.