Police describe ‘potential riot’ with missiles thrown at officers

The Guardian, 7 May 1980

Two police inspectors, one of whom chased demonstrators down the road where Blair Peach was killed, told the inquest yesterday how a ‘potential riot’ was developing in Southall’s Broadway last April 23.

Both men were closely questioned on the use of police truncheons. Inspector Douglas Hopkins admitted that the police sometimes used unauthorised weapons, and the jury was shown 25 items found in the lockers of two Special Patrol Group Units.

A bird’s eye view of the scene immediately before Mr Peach was struck down was first given by Inspector Peter Francis who was drafted in for the demonstration from Kingston. He had been instructed to stand on the roof of a supermarket, about 200 yards from the crowd, at the junction of Beechcroft Avenue – the street where Mr Peach was later found with a fractured skull.

He said his immediate job was to identify demonstrators in the crowd directly below him who were throwing missiles at the police cordon in front of the town hall where the National Front was meeting. The 200-300 people further down the road at Beechcroft Avenue were becoming increasingly hostile, he said. He heard the sound of breaking glass and saw a police coach driving away from the crowd at high speed.

On his personal radio he sent a message to the police control saying that the crowd was unpoliced and requesting urgent assistance. Two Special Patrol Group vans which had been parked below him, drove up the Broadway and through the crowd. Missiles were thrown at them, and people were beating on the side of the vans. A few minutes later the vans returned. One stopped in the crowd, and the other returned to its original position, nearer to him.

From the first van, 10-15 officers jumped out and began to disperse the crowd and make arrests. There were many fights and scuffles. Most of the demonstrators ran down Beechcroft Avenue, out of his line of vision.

For the Peach family, Mr Stephen Sedley questioned the inspector on the general use of police truncheons. Inspector Francis agreed that truncheons should only be used for self-defence but he added: “One could argue that attack is the best form of defence.”

He accepted that any officer who armed himself with a weapon more deadly than a truncheon would be guilty of the ‘gravest possible breach of discipline’. Using truncheons just to make people run away would not be a legitimate use.

Inspector Douglas Hopkins, the head of the No. 3 SPG unit based at Leytonstone, acknowledged that his grandfather’s truncheon had been found in his locker. He said he had not used it since he had joined the SPG but he had taken it out on occasions to deal with suspected robberies.

When he worked in the East End of London, he said, he had often had to deal with young robbers armed with pick-axe handles. “A truncheon is a flimsy thing, and it was quite common for officers to take pick-axe handles with them or, as in my case, my grandfather’s truncheon.”

Policemen were not given equipment to execute warrants, he added, and they would bring their own sledge-hammers or jemmies from home to enter premises.

Under cross examination by Mr Sedley, Inspector Hopkins spoke on the question of police general orders for the use of truncheons. He said they were just directions, without the force of law. The Criminal Law Act gave the police powers to use force to arrest people and to defend themselves, he said.

Describing his role in policing the demonstration, Inspector Hopkins said his unit had two vans in the Broadway – the ones parked below Inspector Francis. As a result of a radio message, he drove up to the crowd at Beechcroft Avenue and recovered two milk crates full of bottles and bricks.

After depositing these behind a garage beyond the demonstrators, the two vans returned along the Broadway. He saw several windows being broken and a petrol bomb being thrown. “We were encircled by the crowd and we drove through it at quite a fast speed. There was a heavy barrage of bricks and other missiles. We decided to stop to arrest the offenders or anyone holding missiles. Most of them were young Asians,” he said.

Under a further hail of missiles from the mouth of Beechcroft Avenue, his officers – about 12 in all – collected their riot shields and drew their truncheons. “I saw one of my constables go down and he was obviously quite badly injured.”

Leaving a sergeant to radio for more help, his men advanced towards the crowd in Beechcroft behind their shields. About four young men continued to throw things. He estimated there were between 100 and 150 youths in the junction, three ranks deep.

As he was giving his signal to advance, Inspector Hopkins said he was struck on the leg with a brick and he chased the thrower down the street. At the end, a few yards from where Mr Peach was struck down, he caught up with the man and arrested him after a brief struggle. “I jabbed him in the chest or the stomach with my truncheon to try and straighten him up,” he said.

At that stage a few missiles were still being thrown, he said. The next memory he had was that of the arrival of the SPG van which had swung into the street. With it was Inspector Alan Murray of No 1 SPG unit, and the driver PC White.

Mr Hopkins said that it was common practice for officers to use large weapons instead of truncheons and senior officers knew this. “Anyone who has risen through the ranks must be aware that pick-axe handles are often kept or have been in the past. As a result of this case they probably won’t be in the future. They will probably be issued.”

But despite this common practice, he found it inconceivable that any SPG men should have used his own weapons at Southall. “There’s no way a police officer in a situation like that – looked at by the public, by television, with senior officers there – would have anything with him other than a truncheon.”

Mr Sedley showed him a blackjack, purchased by the Peach family solicitors in the United States. Mr Hopkins said he had never seen it before and his men would not use such a weapon. He would have seen them if they had tried.

The jury was shown 25 staves, iron bars, knives and other tools which had been taken from SPG lockers at Barnes and Leytonstone police stations in searches conducted on June 5 and June 6 last year. Seven of the items were found in the locker of one officer, PC White. The court heard that he was the only officer who was suspended as a result of the search.