Liberal governor is forced out of Styal by prison officers

The Observer, 23 February 1986

One of the country’s most liberal prison governors, James Anderson, has been ousted from his post at Styal women’s prison, Cheshire, after a sustained campaign by the Prison Officers Association.

Mr Anderson’s transfer has caused turmoil in the prison world. It is being seen as a key victory for the POA in the power struggle between officers and governors over who runs Britain’s prisons and whether their regimes should be more relaxed. Liberal home affairs spokesman Alex Carlisle is to press for a House of Commons debate.

It comes after more than a year of friction, with the POA complaining to the Prison Department, blaming Mr Anderson for incidents at the prison, including fires, protests and physical and sexual assaults on inmates.

Mr Anderson is being moved at three weeks notice to a youth custody centre in Lancashire. The Prison Department explanation is that he was ‘caught in the net of routine transfers.’ Mr Anderson last week dismissed this explanation as ‘ludicrous.’

He said the department had not given him any explanation for the move, nor had he been asked to reply to the complaints made against him by the POA: “I find it all very sad and mysterious.”

The trouble began in January 1985 with a series of ‘kangaroo courts’, disclosed in The Observer ,when inmates took advantage of the lack of night staff to hold mock trials of unpopular prisoners, who were physically and sexually abused.

Mr Anderson asked the Prison Department for more night staff. In the short term he tried to reduce the problem by mixing young offenders, who were running the ‘courts’, with adult offenders, who had a restraining influence. Such a mix is illegal, but all sides agreed that it helped.

Two months later, when staffing levels remained unchanged, POA national officers went direct to the Prison Department, by-passing the governor, to demand more staff. The department said it would look into the problem.

Mr Anderson had been governor of Styal for two years, but his attempts to maintain a relaxed regime had alienated the officers.

At disciplinary hearings, where he favoured a compassionate approach, the officers wanted more punishment, and complained that their authority was being undermined.

Mr Anderson promoted an open style of management. “I tried to talk with people and consult and not indulge in secret management,” he said. The POA complained that they needed clear rules and orders.

Mr Anderson said publicly that he believed that women with small babies should not be jailed. Officers complained that he was being soft on criminals.

He pressed for inmates to have long periods of ‘association’ and access to facilities for sport and education. The officers complained that they were too short-staffed for all this supervision.

By the end of last year, the Prison Department had still failed to provide extra night staff. There was an outbreak of minor arson attempts, and a return of the kangaroo courts. The POA openly blamed the governor, and leaked reports on internal incidents to increase the pressure on the department.

In one, they claimed that a senior officer had been caught in bed with an inmate by a junior officer but that Mr Anderson had ignored the incident. Mr Anderson said: “That is absolutely scandalous. I have no idea what they are referring to.”

In another incident, three weeks ago, the assistant regional director of the prison service, Mike Langdon, paid an unannounced night visit to the prison. That night, someone started a small fire and balanced a bucket of water on top of a door through which Mr Langdon walked. The POA said this proved the governor had lost control of the prison.

Mr Anderson said last week: “Mike Langdon did pay a night visit and I did hear that someone tried to booby-trap a door. But I don’t know what conclusions he drew from that: I have not heard another word about it.”

While Mr Anderson was away at the Civil Service Commission earlier this month, two POA national officials spent two days at the prison and held a lengthy meeting with Mr Langdon, the local POA officials and the deputy governor.

The prison department has now agreed to provide five extra night staff, met POA demands for new security measures, and told Mr Anderson that at the end of this month he will be replaced by George Walker, a governor with a reputation as a trouble-shooter.

Other prison governors said privately last week that they were appalled at Mr Anderson’s treatment. The National Association of Probation Officers expressed its sympathy and criticised the department for ‘an obsession with cost cutting which makes liberal ideas impossible.’

Mr Carlisle said: “I am deeply disturbed that a genuine attempt by Mr Anderson to turn Styal into a more humane and effective prison appears to have had the skids put under it by the prison officers. Once frustrated, such an attempt can be extremely hard to revive.”