Detectives tell court they did no wrong in shooting Waldorf

The Guardian, 18 October 1983

The two London detectives who shot Steven Waldorf went into the witness box at the Old Bailey yesterday and told the jury that they believed they had done nothing wrong.

Detective Constable John Jardine, who denies attempting to murder Mr Waldorf and wounding him with intent to cause grievous bodily harm, told the court: “If it happened again, I am very much afraid that I would act in the same way.”

Detective Constable Peter Finch, who has been cleared of attempted murder and still faces two charges of wounding with intent, said: “I believed I was doing the right thing at the right time.”

The court has heard that on January 14, Det Con Finch opened fire on Mr Waldorf as he sat in a car in a traffic jam and then struck him over the head with his pistol as he lay wounded while Det Con Jardine fired three more shots at him.

Yesterday Det Con Finch began his evidence in the witness box by describing the occasion in September last year when he helped to arrest David Martin, the “armed and dangerous criminal” for whom Mr Waldorf was mistaken in January.

Det Con Finch said he had been armed when he arrested Mr Martin. “Did you have any desire to shoot that person at that time?” asked his counsel, Michael Corkery QC.

“Not at all, sir,” replied Det Con Finch.

“Could you have shot him if you had wanted to?” asked Mr Corkery.

“With difficulty, yes.”

Det Con Finch described again the events in January this year leading up to the shooting of Mr Waldorf: the undercover surveillance of Mr Martin’s girlfriend; the discreet pursuit of the yellow Mini in which she was travelling; and the speculation between detectives that the front-seat passenger might be the wanted man.

Det Con Finch had trotted through the traffic jam to have a look at the strange passenger’s face. “I walked up to the front passenger’s door and, looking through the glass, I saw a three-quarter profile of Martin. It was his large nose, his hair, and even his high cheek bones. One hundred per cent, I was sure it was him, absolutely positive. I had made my identification as I had been told to.”

In a slow, deliberate voice, Det Con Finch went on to explain why he had decided to open fire. “I was nervous and I was tense. My intent was to walk away as soon as I could. I started to back off and, as I got to the back of the Mini, I saw the driver turn his head round to the left and look at me.

“He then turned his head back and said something to the front passenger who then turned round to between the two front seats and reached towards the rear seat. I immediately dropped down to my knees to make as small a target as possible, because I thought he was going for a gun.

“I then brought my gun up in a position in front of me with my arms stretched out. I feared for my life. I thought I was going to be shot. From my previous experience of Martin, that is what I thought.”

None of the witnesses in the case has said they heard Mr Finch shout a warning to the occupants of the car. Det. Con. Finch said yesterday: “The only words I could get out were ‘armed police’. It didn’t come out very well at all. My voice faltered. It was not a loud shout. It was just more or less my normal voice, which was faltering.”

The court has also heard that officers are taught not to shoot into the tyres of a car. “It was bad shooting,” said Det Con Finch. “I was nervous, and the gun was moving in my hand. It was aimed towards his body but it went too low. It was not a deliberate shot into the tyre.”

As his target kept moving, he had fired four more shots. Then he had seen a colleague who is not on trial, Det Con John Dean, at the back of the Mini, also firing. “This surprised me because I didn’t know there was another armed officer in the street besides me.”

He had gone round the back of the car and then seen the man he thought to be Mr Martin slumped out of the driver’s door. “He was moving and I still thought we were vulnerable – me without any ammuniton, and, by this time, Det Con Dean doing a reload. From my experience of Martin, even though he had been shot, he is still a very dangerous man.

“He was still capable of getting a gun out. I went up to him. I was not going to jump on him. I hit him on the head with my revolver at least three times with the chamber of the barrel, not the butt. I then did a reload. I put five bullets in; it should have been six, but I dropped one.”

A few moments later, as he stood over Mr Waldorf’s body, training his loaded gun at the wounded man, he had realised his mistake. “One of the officers pulled him round and towards me, and I looked down and I saw his face and it was not Martin. I felt absolutely terrible. The first person I saw to tell was Det Con Dean. I went up to him and said: ‘It’s not our man.'”

Cross-examined by Sir Michael Havers, Det Con Finch said: “It was not a question of me deciding to have a go myself. I went out there to identify him and I had done that and I was retreating, but the circumstances altered all that. I thought I was the only one on the street who was armed.

“I had to take some action. If I had run away, if I had hid myself under a car or behind a car, Martin would have run after me and shot me. I had to make a decision there and then on the street.”

Sir Michael pressed him on his decision to ‘pistol whip’ the man. “Is it really that difficult to restrain him?” he asked.

“With Martin it is,” said Det Con Finch. “That’s the thing. It was Martin I saw down there. Police Constable Carr (who was shot by Mr Martin last August) got too close to him and got shot. I nearly got too close to him and nearly got shot.

“I thought that by knocking him over the head I could knock him out. I didn’t want to beat him up or do him any more harm. I just wanted to knock him out.”

Det Con John Jardine described in the witness box how he had seen Det Con Finch approach the Mini and then heard the first shots. He had run to the car, passed Det Con Finch crouching down to take cover, and had seen the wounded man rolling in the street.

“His hands were the things that I noticed immediately. They were making what I would call groping movements down his body. There was only one explanation: from what had gone on before, the man had to have a gun.

“I decided to shoot him before I was shot. I brought the gun up in both hands and I fired two shots at him, probably, at his head. I had to stop him doing what he was doing.

“I didn’t see either of the shots land anywhere, and his movements just continued as before. The obvious conclusion was that I had missed so I fired a further shot. His movements virtually stopped, so I did not feel the need to shoot any more.”

Cross-examining, Sir Michael pressed him on his decision to shoot and suggested that he could have stood over his target and covered him with his gun. “That would have been an extremely foolish thing to do,” replied Det Con Jardine. “I would have been standing there waiting to see if he came up with a gun. Then it would have been a contest between him and me to see who could fire first. That only happens in films as far as I am concerned.”

Det Con Jardine also insisted that he could not have gone close to the man and pressed his gun against his head. “There are no circumstances under which I would approach a man like that, believing what I believed about him, with a gun in my hand. If he didn’t have a gun I would be giving him one. It’s contrary to all that we are taught in firearms training.”

The hearing continues today with the closing speeches of the prosecution and defence.