A man who took part in one of Scotland Yard’s largest ‘supergrass’ operations has admitted that he lied in court and helped to convict an alleged bank robber, Alan Chard, who is now serving 12 years in prison as a result and who has always protested his innocence.
Mr Chard’s case has been taken up by Mr Stephen Ross, Liberal MP for the Isle of Wight. Mr Patrick Mayhew, Minister of State at the Home Office, met senior officials on Friday to decide whether he should take any action. He is expected to announce his decision later this week.
Now Peter Wilding, aged 28, who was one of three men who gave Queen’s Evidence against Mr Chard, has admitted in a statement to the Guardian that he lied. He says he was pressurised by other supergrasses who threatened to implicate him in crimes of which he was innocent if he did not co-operate.
Mr Ross, who initiated an adjournment debate on the Chard case last December, said: “Alan Chard must now be released. I have visited him in prison and I may not be a great expert on character, but I am quite satisfied that he is innocent.”
If the Home Office decides that Mr Chard’s conviction is seriously in doubt it can refer the case back to the Court of Appeal or recommend the use of the royal prerogative of mercy to have him released immediately.
The royal prerogative was used last year to release David Cooper and Michael McMahon, who served 10 years in prison and failed five times to persuade the Court of Appeal that they were innocent of murder. They, too, were convicted on the testimony of a man who turned Queen’s Evidence.
Mr Chard, aged 46, was convicted at the Old Bailey on November 21 1975, on three charges of conspiring to rob banks. The prosecution case consisted of the uncorroborated evidence of Peter Wilding and two other supergrasses, one of whom went on to help in the conviction of 40 other men. The case is bound to create new pressure on the Director of Public Prosecutions for a change in the supergrass system which allows criminals to earn their freedom by convicting others.
Mr Ross said: “All the evidence of previous cases and of this one is that it is most unsafe to rely on the evidence of supergrasses. This makes me doubly certain that it is totally unsafe.”
Mr Chard appealed against his Conviction on March 8,1977 but succeeded only in getting his sentence reduced from 15 years to 12. He has suffered a heart attack and a virtual nervous breakdown in prison.
He spent 12 months writing to MPs and pressure groups in an attempt to have his case reopened. In 1978, a fellow inmate in Parkhurst Prison on the Isle of Wight, Mr Jim Colla, offered to help him.
The two men spent six months in adjoining cells, gathering statements, comparing their contents, listing contradictions and assembling new evidence from witnesses outside until they felt that they had grounds to get the case reopened. Mr Colla wrote a 52,000-word study of the case.
Now Peter Wilding, who was traced at the weekend, has confirmed that he lied. In his statement to the Guardian, Mr Wilding said: “Alan Chard was not involved in any conspiracy that I know of. I had never met him or heard of him before my arrest in September 1974.
“Everything that I said about him is untrue. I realise now that I was wrong to have lied. I want to undo the damage that I have done.”
Mr Wilding says that officers working on the case allowed one of the other informers to sit and prompt him while he made statements. He says that he was taken to Alan Chard’s cell by officers who opened the hatch in the door so that he could see if he could identify him: “It was like another world. I was right out of my league.”