Four London detectives who were charged after the Operation Countryman inquiry into police corruption yesterday denied planting evidence, concocting false confessions and extracting money from criminals.
On the opening day of their trial at the Old Bailey the jury was warned to weigh with great care the evidence of police witnesses who might have old loyalties to the defendants, and of criminal friends who might have old scores to settle against them.
The four men – an inspector, a sergeant and two constables – all denied a joint charge of conspiring to pervert the course of justice by fabricating evidence against John Twomey and Patrick Carpenter after a bank robbery in Bayswater Road in October 1977.
Inspector Terence Babbidge also denied that he had knowingly made a false statement to the effect that he had seen John Twomey getting out of a taxi outside the Old Bailey on October 19, 1977, the day of the Bayswater Road robbery.
Detective Sergeant John Ross denied demanding £1,500 with menaces from Thomas Greene and accepting £1,500 from him. His brother, Detective Constable Michael Ross, and Detective Constable Paul Rextrew denied the same two charges and two similar charges involving another man, James Stevens.
Opening the case for the Crown, Mr John Blowfeld QC said that the evidence against the four officers fell into three parts: the planting of incriminating evidence on Twomey and Carpenter, both of whom had serious criminal records; the concoction of false accounts of interviews with them; and extracting payments from Greene and Stevens “as a price for not fitting them up”.
Officers would be called as witnesses, said Mr Blowfeld. “A particular police witness… might be less than entirely wholehearted in his desire to tell you all that he knows because there might well be questions of loyalty to his old friends, which might mean possibly that his recollection is not as complete as you might expect it to be.”
There would also be evidence from people with criminal convictions. “Anybody with a criminal past might well have a powerful motive to give false evidence against serving police officers.”
Mr Blowfeld told the jury that it was not necessary for them to decide whether the criminals involved were guilty of the crimes for which they were allegedly being ‘fitted up’. It was criminal and improper for an officer to manufacture evidence however much he suspected that he had found the guilty man.
He drew an analogy with the treatment of rape victims. “Whatever her background, whatever her sexual experience, be she somebody who walks the streets to sell her own body or be she the most respectable housewife, she is entitled to the same consideration.
“In exactly the same way, any criminal who is suspected of committing an offence is entitled to the same treatment by the police whatever the police suspect.”
The case continues today.