Dennis Nilsen was sent to prison with eight life sentences yesterday, leaving Scotland Yard to explain why it had failed to interrupt his catalogue of at least 15 killings despite a series of warnings from victims who survived his assaults.
Nilsen, aged 37, was found guilty of six sample counts of murder and two of attempted murder by an Old Bailey jury who rejected his plea of guilty to manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility.
Mr Justice Croom-Johnson sentenced him to life on each count and recommended that he should serve at least 25 years. The sentence – one of the heaviest ever imposed at the Old Bailey – came after a 10-day trial which centered on the state of his mind when, by his own account, he strangled 15 or 16 young men, tried to strangle about seven others, and dismembered the corpses of his victims before burning them or flushing them down his lavatory.
Between December 1978 and February 1983, when he committed the offences, his activities were brought to police attention five times: three times by young men who complained that he had tried to kill them; once by a 10-year-old boy who said he had indecently assaulted him; and once by a neighbour who found a carrier bag of human remains.
On each occasion, police say, their inquiries were thwarted at an early stage: two of the young men withdrew their complaints, and the third lost touch with them; the parents of the 10-year-old blocked a prosecution because they did not want their child to face the ordeal of being a witness; the remains in the carrier bag were not thought at the time to have been human.
The five reports were never linked by the different officers who dealt with them over the years and, with no corpses and only one of the 15 dead reported missing to police, there was no murder inquiry. Since Nilsen’s arrest in February, senior officers have reviewed the handling of the five reports. It is understood that no further action is to be taken.
Yesterday’s murder verdicts were returned by the jury by a majority of 10 to 2 after a deliberation which began at 11.30 on Thursday morning and ended at 4.25 yesterday afternoon, when the jury foreman rose to his feet to announce their decision.
Nilsen stood quietly in the dock, his face expressionless, as it has been throughout the trial, while the foreman recited the verdicts. It took four minutes to complete the long indictment, and then the judge turned to him to pass sentence.
“Dennis Andrew Nilsen, on the verdicts of the jury on the murder counts, there is only one sentence which it is possible for me to pass,” the judge said, adding that even if the jury had returned a manslaughter verdict, the sentence would have been the same because his condition appeared to be untreatable and, therefore, unsuitable for a special hospital.
“I have had to consider whether I should make any recommendation in this case on the minimum period which in my view you should serve before any consideration is given to your release. It is a rare thing to be done but in the present case, I do make such a recommendation, that it be 25 years.”
At 4.31, Nilsen and his escort of four prison officers turned and walked down the dock stairs to the cells below. Mr Justice Croom-Johnson commended the three officers who have handled Nilsen since his arrest – Detective Chief Superintendent Geoffrey Chambers, Detective Chief Inspector Peter Jay and Detective Constable Lodge.
* Earlier, the judge asked the Attorney Generalto consider prosecuting six newspapers for contempt of court. London’s evening newspaper, the Standard; the Sun; the Star; the Daily Mirror; the Daily Mail; and the Daily Express all published background articles on the case while the jury was still considering its verdict. A spokesman for the Attorney General’s office said that no decision could be reached until the articles had been studied.