Psychiatrist backs Crown case that Nilsen is not mentally ill

The Guardian, 1 November 1983

A Crown psychiatrist yesterday told an Old Bailey jury that Dennis Nilsen murdered his victims out of an overwhelming desire to kill and not because of any mental disorder which might have diminished his responsibility.

Dr Paul Bowden, who has been called by the prosecution to rebut the evidence of two defence psychiatrists, said he also believed that Mr Nilsen enjoyed the feeling of power over his victims. A final factor, he suggested, was that Mr Nilsen had always felt like a criminal because he was homosexual. “By killing, he was able to transfer his feeling of criminality so that it was no longer because of his homosexuality, but because of the fact that he was a murderer.”

Mr Nilsen has told police that he killed 15 or 16 people between December 1978 and February 1983. He has denied six charges of murder and two of attempted murder, and pleaded guilty to manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility.

Dr Bowden rejected the diagnosis of defence psychiatrists that Mr Nilsen has a severe personality disorder. He said he had found no significant evidence of a withdrawn character, sexual perversion, alcohol abuse, paranoia, or any of the other symptoms to which the defence has referred.

He rejected too the contention that Mr Nilsen is remorseless and unemotional. In Brixton Prison he had tried to press Mr Nilsen on the details of a particularly brutal killing. “Tears filled his eyes and he was about to start crying, and he spoke about never being able to show his feelings, then he got up and walked out.”

Mr Ivan Lawrence, QC, defending, read to him a statement by a Japanese student, Toshimitsu Ozawa, who told police that Mr Nilsen attacked him in his flat in Cranley Gardens, Muswell Hill, London on New Year’s Eve 1982.

Sitting in a chair drinking a can of lager, Mr Ozawa had seen Mr Nilsen advancing on him with a tie outstretched between his hands. “He had a normal expression on his face, but he was looking at me. He didn’t say anything to me. I wasn’t unnerved by what he was doing as I thought he was joking. He put the tie round my neck and started to pull the two ends together.”

Mr Ozawa said he had pushed the tie away and said: “What’s the matter?” Mr Nilsen had not answered, and, looking very serious, had advanced again with the out-stretched tie and started trying to wrap it round his neck. Mr Ozawa had kicked him with both feet, jumped from the chair and run out of the house.

Mr Lawrence suggested that Mr Nilsen’s behaviour had been far from normal. “It certainly isn’t normal,” said Dr Bowden, “but if Mr Nilsen’s intention was to strangle that man, he went about it very well.”

“But isn’t that abnormal behaviour?” Mr Lawrence asked.

“Of course, strangling people is not normal behaviour,” Dr Bowden replied.

“But what could he possibly be trying to do?” Mr Lawrence asked.

“I suspect he wanted to kill him,” Dr Bowden replied. “But I don’t think we can assume that there is mental disorder just on the basis that he was behaving abnormally.”

Dr Bowden told the court that he had started to feel some sympathy for Mr Nilsen and he denied a suggestion in a letter written by Mr Nilsen that he had extracted false information from him.

The trial continues today.