Dennis Nilsen was baffled by his own success. Constantly expecting to be caught, he could not understand why he was still at liberty. “I was in a quasi- Godlike role,” he reflected later. “I thought I could do anything I wanted. While this was going on, there were people upstairs and people next door, and nobody knew.”
Nobody knew, or even suspected, because Nilsen not only possessed all the trappings of a thoroughly normal suburban life, he was positively dreary, the least eye-catching man in the crowd. That is one of the reasons why his case has been so fascinating.
For years he has lived in the red-brick maze of north west London, a neatly turned out middle-class chap, catching the Tube to work, pushing a pen for the Department of Employment, catching the Tube back home, taking the dog for a walk, closing his front door on the world, and minding his own business.
It was not only his neighbours who saw him without noticing him. Most of those who worked with him or drank with him were bored by him: his endless rambling about the Civil Service unions; his opinionated speeches about politics; and his feeble jokes. “Garcon, do you have frog’s legs? Then hop over here and get me a drink.”
And yet this dull, meek figure was, as one psychiatrist put it, “a living nightmare,” killing sometimes once a month, living and playing with the corpses of his victims in a secret world of the most grotesque squalor which he never betrayed for a moment to the outside world.
In that sense he is a throwback to the Victorian world of middle-class murderers, strangling and poisoning behind lace curtains – “more frightening in a strange way than a modern murder, which has guns and hit-men or explosives,” as one detective said.
But the man’s quiet facade is not enough to explain how he got away with it for so long. His own suggestion that he was “quasi-Godlike” is a curious echo of a comment by Peter Sutcliffe, the Yorkshire Ripper, to the effect that he had survived detection because God was helping him and obstructing the police.
The two men, are similar in some ways – particularly in the sheer scale of their killings. They were also committing their offences at roughly the same time – Sutcliffe killing 13 women between 1975 and 1980, Nilsen killing 15 men between 1978 and 1983.
The striking difference between them is the way in which their communities reacted. Sutcliffe’s offences cast a cloud of anxiety over women in cities all over the country, and there was a public outcry at the failure of the police to catch him. Not so with Nilsen.
In the middle of the largest city in the country, apparently hemmed in by all the bureaucracy of the welfare state, all the safety nets of voluntary agencies, all the vigilance of the Metropolitan Police, all the claustrophobia of urban life, 15 young men vanished into Dennis Nilsen’s secret world. and nobody noticed.
The reason why nobody knew that Nilsen was killing was that nobody, except Nilsen, knew that any killings were going on. Thirteen of the 15 he killed were never even reported missing. One of the victims, Billy Sutherland, was reported missing to the Salvation Army by his mother months after his death. Only Kenneth Ockenden, a 23-year-old Canadian tourist, was listed with police, who could do little more than seek publicity in the hope that it would yield some information.
Sitting in Melrose Avenue early in 1980, Dennis Nilsen watched Shaw Taylor on Police Five relay the police appeal for news of Ockenden. The young Canadian was at that moment lying dead under the floorboards under Nilsen’s armchair, and the police gained no clues from their appeal.
The crucial step that Nilsen took with each victim was to dispose of the body. A basic ground rule for an overworked police force is that if there is no body there is no murder inquiry.
Nilsen’s second layer of insulation was provided by his choice of victims – most of them young, homeless, down-and-out homosexuals grubbing a living from the ‘rent-boy’ scene in Soho and the West End of London. Most of them had no fixed abode from which their absence would be noted, no close family to worry about their whereabouts. Their friends in the world of male prostitution and drugs were unlikely to approach the police, and so their disappearances remained unreported.
With the death of his victims unremarked by the outside world, it was easy for Nilsen to get away with murder. What ought to have been much more difficult was to get away with attempted murder where the victims of his murderous attacks survived to complain or to report him.
Nilsen had killed only once when, in October 1979, he attacked a Chinese male prostitute, Andrew Ho, who was asleep in his flat. Mr Ho woke to find Nilsen trying to strangle him, hit him across the head with a candlestick and escaped. He complained to the police and then, perhaps because he was afraid of his background being brought out in court, he withdrew the complaint.
At about this time a 10- year-old boy in Cricklewood told his parents that Nilsen had indecently assaulted him. They complained to the police at Kilburn but then decided that they did not want their child to go through the ordeal of being a witness in court, and withdrew the complaint.
In the next 13 months Nilsen killed seven more times before, in November 1980, he allowed a victim to escape again. Douglas Stewart, who was to be a witness at the Old Bailey trial, woke to find that Nilsen had tied his feet together and was trying to strangle him with his own tie. Mr Stewart wrestled him to the floor and subdued him.
Nilsen then showed extra-ordinary resourcefulness, suddenly shouting “Take my money, take my money,” so that others in the house would hear him and support him if Mr Stewart told police that he had attacked him.
Mr Stewart left and returned with an inspector and a constable from Kilburn. Nilsen told them that he and Mr Stewart were gay and had had a lovers’ tiff. Mr Stewart’s tie was nowhere to be found. The police told Mr Stewart that they would contact him the next day at his brother’s house. They did not. Mr Stewart lost interest, and when the police did contact the brother he did not know where Mr Stewart was.
Another year passed, and Nilsen’s toll had risen to 11 when he attacked Paul Nobbs, a London University student, strangling him into unconsciousness and then, on his own account, having a change of heart and reviving him. Mr Nobbs never reported the incident.
Six months and one more victim later, Carl Stottor survived an attack in which he was strangled and nearly drowned by Nilsen. He, too, decided not to mention it. One of the factors in their extraordinary decisions seems to have been their homosexuality. They felt that the police would not treat them seriously. They just wanted to forget the incident.
A second, more peculiar factor was that in both cases the attack was so weird – so totally unexpected and unexplained – that they could scarcely believe that it had happened. Mr Nobbs decided that the marks on his neck must have been made by a mugger even though he had not been mugged. Mr Stottor half-believed Nilsen’s story that he had got tangled up in a torn zip on a sleeping bag and then had a nightmare so that he had to have his head ducked in cold water to bring him out of shock.
The unreality of the attack Is reflected in the experience of a Japanese student who was attacked by Nilsen after they had been drinking in his flat on New Year’s Eve 1982. Nilsen stalked up to him with a tie stretched between his fists. The Japanese student thought he was playing and pushed him away.
It was only on the second attack, with Nilsen muttering “disgusting, disgusting” and tightening his grip, that there was a struggle and the student ran out of the house. He went to the police, made a complaint, said it was too much trouble, and withdrew it.
By the time he was arrested, Nilsen had lost count of how many victims had escaped – seven, he thought. Police now have to face the fact that they failed to react effectively even though three people tried to tell them that they had been attacked; and a 10-year-old boy complained of indecent assault.
In the end they had a murder inquiry which ran from back to front, starting with the culprit and only then finding out about the killings through his confession. Eight of his 15 victims remain unidentified. In four cases — Kenneth Ockenden, Martin Duffey, Billy Sutherland, and Stephen Sinclair — Nilsen knew their names.
The other three have been identified by police inquiries : Malcolm Barlow from the records in the hospital to which Nilsen said he had been taken with epilepsy a few days before he was killed; and Graham Allen from dental records after his name was thrown up by Soho ‘rent boys’ who told police that they had not seen him for some time.
John Howlett was known initially only as “John the guardsman.” Police searched through military records and got nowhere until one officer had the inspired idea of checking the records at West End Central police station to see if anyone called John had been repeatedly stopped in the street, as a vagrant would, and was not stopped again after March 1982. Mr Howlett’s name came out. His claim to be a guardsman turned out to be false.
The impending trial meant that police could not release Nilsen’s descriptions of his eight unidentified victims for fear of creating some kind of prejudice. As newspapers reported them over the past two weeks, a special squad has been working at Hornsey police station, collating the dozens of inquiries they have provoked.