The MI5 officer who led the hunt for some of Britain’s most notorious postwar spies has compiled a highly sensitive dossier about Russian penetration of MI5.
Yesterday he said he was prepared to break the Official Secrets Act and use the dossier to a obtain a full inquiry into the service.
In an exclusive interview with the Observer, Mr Peter Wright, aged 69, accused senior figures in M15 of covering up chronic weaknesses in the service to avoid political embarrassment.
He said: “I want to go before the Security Commission or any other suitable form of inquiry to argue my case, and I am not going to give up until they have listened to me.”
The dossier, which The Observer has seen, runs to 150 closely-typed pages. It provides the first comprehensive inside account of the hunt for Russian spies in Whitehall and the intelligence community, which began with the defection of Burgess and Maclean in 1951, and overshadowed MI5 for more than 20 years.
Mr Wright says that in case after case, MI5’s attempts to detect and trap spies were swept aside by leaks to the Russians.
In addition to MI5’s failures, he examines their successes – cases such as those of Gordon Lonsdale, the Krogers and George Blake – and produces detailed evidence that even here MI5 operations were damaged by leaks.
“The top management of MI5 got away with it despite the fact that at least one of them was a traitor,” he writes.
He concludes that to this day MI5 is fundamentally flawed because it has failed to weed out the disinformation which filled its files in that period.
He says the service is still not secure and suggests new methods for detecting spies, including the creation of a ‘Guardian Unit’ – an independent body to police the intelligence community.
Mr Wright launched his campaign on Monday with an hour-long interview on Granada TV’s World in Action, in which he insisted that the former director-general of MI5, Sir Roger Hollis, was a Russian spy and that the Prime Minister had misled the House of Commons in exonerating him in 1981.
“The whole reason why I am doing this – which is thoroughly illegal – is to get the dossier to people who will listen. I don’t mind if they cut up rough and prosecute me. I am willing to argue my case against any judge they care to produce.”
The programme provoked another former MI5 officer, Mr Arthur Martin, also to break cover, with a letter to The Times underlining the strength of the case that MI5 had harboured a Russian spy in its most senior ranks.
Mr Martin was one of the six members of the Fluency Committee, which investigated Russian penetration. Mr Wright was the committee’s chairman from 1965 until 1972.
The committee found eight hitherto undisclosed members of MI5 and MI6 who were firm suspects and who left the service. More than 30 other positive suspects were identified in other limbs of the government and in the universities.
However, Mr Wright last night squashed reports in the Sunday Times that Sir Edward Playfair, the former Permanent Secretary at the Ministry of Defence, had ever been listed as a plausible suspect.
“I had two interviews with Eddie Playfair,” he told The Observer, “and if you knew Blunt and people like that, you would realise that he isn’t even a starter. He was left-wing, yes, but Eddie is not a spy. Anybody who knows anything about the case knows that. Everyone is going to burn their fingers if they follow this one.”
Mr Wright’s decision to break the Official Secrets Act and publicly challenge MI5’s integrity is unprecedented. It reflects the bitter conflict within the service. Mr Wright, who lives in retirement in Australia with his wife, said he had agonised over the decision to break his vow of silence.
“I decided in the end that I had to speak out because the service has lost its way. It has been deeply compromised by Russian penetration. I know that, because I spent most of my career investigating it. Even now the service has failed to protect itself adequately against future penetration, and the Bettaney case has shown just how easy it still is.
“Instead of setting its house in order, it has taken the somewhat sinister decision to divert resources away to working against domestic groups – trade unions and so on.”
He angrily rejected suggestions that he was being disloyal to the service. “These people play fast and loose with their position and with their friends. When I think of what they did, it makes me feel absolutely disgusted. It really hurts. After fighting for this long, I am not about to give up.”