Brian Paschal Keenan has spent the last 20 days trying to persuade an Old Bailey jury that he is just an innocent TV repair man with unfortunate friends. In fact, he is the biggest catch the Anti Terrorist Squad has ever made – the Provisional IRA’s Director of Operations.
His trial for conspiring to cause explosions and possess firearms was a dry hair-splitting affair in which the prosecution overplayed its hand and then struggled desperately to bring its evidence before the jury.
The result was that the jury knew nothing of Mr Keenan’s career in the IRA, his steady rise to become their overall Director of Operations, his diary full of phone numbers linking him to guerrilla movements round the world, the police fears of an attempt to break him out of Brixton Prison.
Instead the jury heard the tiring recital of the hundreds of items found in the three bomb factories in London and Liverpool, the forensic links with the shootings which killed nine people in the autumn of 1975 and the handful of tiny clues which tied Brian Keenan into the conspiracy.
He had left school in 1957, aged 16, trained as a television engineer in Larne, Co Antrim, and travelled to England in May 1960 to work first in Corby and then in Luton with a TV rental firm. It was in Luton that he married Christina Campbell in October 1960. A few years later they moved back to Belfast.
Until 1971 Keenan meant nothing to the Northern Ireland security forces. He was just another Catholic worker, supporting his wife and their six children with his relatively steady job as production foreman at the Grundig works in Dunmurry outside Belfast. Years later, at the Old Bailey, he was to describe how he had tried to use his old skills to mend the television in one of the London bomb factories.
Then, in 1971, intelligence officers caught their first glimpse of his other face. All they knew was that he had some sort of command rank. Later that year they identified him as a quarter-master in the Belfast brigade, responsible for the supply of arms and explosives.
Everyone who knows Brian Keenan comes to the same conclusion about him: he is cool, articulate and very intelligent, a man of considerable character. All this is reflected in his IRA career, for by May 1973 he had reached the Provisionals’ army council without giving the security forces a chance to move against him.
Later in 1973 he became quartermaster for the whole of Dublin. He was now firmly established as a figure of national stature in the Provisionals; and army and police intelligence were closing in. On November 8 1974 he appeared before the DubIin Special Court to be sentenced to 12 months in prison for belonging to an illegal organisation.
He was released after eight months, on July 16 1975. Within a month he was directing the Balcombe Street Four in the second phase of their attack on the mainland. On August 27 a bomb exploded in the Caterham Arms tearing both legs and an arm off a Welsh Guardsman and injuring 32 others.
In the next four months, the same active service unit hit 16 more targets with guns and bombs, often laced with nuts and bolts and ball bearings which ripped through crowded rooms with devastating effects. Nine died, 130 were injured. Hundreds of thousands of pounds worth of property was destroyed.
Then on December 6 the four-man unit was snagged by the police net in the West End when they made their second visit to Scott’s Restaurant in Mount Street. As they shot through the window at diners, police moved in on them. There was a chase, and minutes later the Balcombe Street siege had begun. But Brian Keenan was safe.
He had taken no part in the raids: he was already too important to risk. It was at about this time that he is believed to have become Director of Operations, the highest operational rank in the Provisional IRA, giving him responsibility for IRA activity everywhere in the world.
But little of this came out in court as he sat passively in the dock, a wiry figure in blue denim jeans and a brown cord jacket, his blue eyes constantly on the move around the room as he scribbled notes to himself and to his barristers.
There was no question of refusing to recognise the court as the Balcombe Street Four had done when they sat in the same dock. He was so relaxed that even the three prison warders in the dock would share a joke with him.
His attitude to the court was a crucial part of his strategy: it highlighted his other face, that of the innocent family man. But when his wife and mother came and sat in the court and smiled at him, the strategy back-fired badly and nearly stopped the trial.
One of the jurors complained at the end of the third day that the wife and mother were staring, possibly remembering their faces for a vendetta. The judge ordered the two women to sit in the public gallery, out of sight of the jury.
Mr Michael Mansfield, Keenan’s barrister, quickly saw that this meant the jury was prepared to think of his client as a dangerous man, that they didn’t necessarily believe the face they were being shown. He asked that the jury be discharged. The judge refused.
But if the prosecution was winning this battle of atmospheres, it was losing the battle for evidence. The Director of Public Prosecutions ruled before the trial began that Keenan’s conviction for IRA membership was inadmissible since it was achieved on the word of only one police officer. The prosecution then tried to show the jury the diary that had been found on Keenan when he was arrested in Belfast in March 1979.
Some of the entries were coded, some written in Greek letters, but there was no mistaking the phone numbers in Japan, Western Europe, the Middle East, linking him to virtually every terrorist group in the world.
In his pocket there had also been three half bank notes, one Libyan and two Irish, all roughly torn. The other halves were never found. In the diary was the entry: “Hallo, Brian, my brother. Here is some money.” This was thought to be the code to be used on presentation of the missing halves.
The judge ruled that the diary and the notes were inadmissible because they were too remote from the charges in the indictment. Similarly he rejected a prosecution attempt to tell the jury that Keenan had given a false name when he was arrested, as well as carrying the papers for a third identity at the same time.
Now the prosecution began to regret the bold opening statement made by the Attorney General, Sir Michael Havers, who appeared for the Crown on the first day. There was effectively no evidence to support his assertion that Mr Keenan was the organiser of the bombing conspiracy.
The prosecution could still hope to prove that he was part of a conspiracy, but not that he had led it. By the time Mr David Jeffreys QC summed up for the Crown he had dropped this central theme of Sir Michael’s opening. The defence pressed home the unexpected advantage.
In his speech from the dock, Keenan said: “The Attorney General said I was an organiser. What am I supposed to have organised? These people seem to have been very well organised before I came on the scene.”
His speech was a masterpiece. For nearly two hours he stood in the corner of the dock nearest the jury, gripping the bar in front of him, apologising for his accent and his nerves, constantly appealing to the jurors as ordinary people like himself. “I don’t know how you feel about being in this court,” he told them. “For me it’s just a nightmare.”
He explained how frightened he had been to find the Attorney General prosecuting him. “I’m glad the man went home,” he said. He said he could understand their prejudices about the Irish, their need to protect themselves with laws like the Prevention of Terrorism Act. But they had to see it from his point of view, that of an innocent man trying to raise a family in an armed ghetto.
He admitted to being a fanatic, but only for crosswords. “I like the Daily Mail crosswords and I like the Guardian,” he continued. “The Times is a bit too difficult for me. I do better with papers like the Sun. Sometimes I do the Daily Express. I don’t always get them out.”
It seemed almost inconceivable that this could be the man who on November 7 filled in the Daily Mail crossword, later found by police, while he ordered his men to place a lump of gelignite wrapped in nuts and bolts outside the home of Mr Edward Heath.
He said he didn’t remember the crossword. “Could you remember a copy of the Daily Mail after five years?” he asked the jurors. Just as blandly he dismissed the other four items which tied him to the London conspiracy: an Evening News found at one London Bomb factory and the book, carrier bag and mysterious ‘Cupal list’ found at the other, all four bearing his finger prints.
The Cupal list was a salesman’s order form produced by a pharmaceutical company. The Balcombe Street Four had used its convenient printed grid to list dozens of incriminating items, mostly parts of bombs, as a shopping list or as part of a code. On the back was the print of Mr Keenan’s forefinger, the most incriminating piece of evidence against him.
But he explained that he had visited only one of the London addresses on only one occasion to see his friend, Hughie Doherty, never suspecting that he was involved in the IRA. He supposed he had left his prints by moving all four objects from the top of the television when he tried to mend it, and then three of them must have been taken to the other address. The jury listened carefully. The prosecution twisted their hands.
Keenan agreed that his photograph had been found on a forged driving licence in the Liverpool bomb factory at 91 Scarisbrick Drive, but he explained that he had obtained this because he had been driving the illegal community taxis in West Belfast, and he had left it behind because he was afraid of being arrested on the ferry back to Belfast.
“This has been a nerve-wracking experience here in this box. I’m fighting for my life here. I wouldn’t wish it on anybody. I ask you not to convict me on this evidence. Circumstances can happen to anybody.”
He did not mention Captain Roger Goad, the explosives officer who was blown up trying to defuse a bomb in Kensington Church Street; nor Professor Gordon Hamilton-Fairley whose dog touched off a bomb and killed him in Camden Hill Square; nor Ross McWhirter, shot outside his home; nor any of the other victims of his unit.
He simply rejected the prosecution line that he was sent over to Liverpool and then to London to give a new boost to the ‘Great Britain Brigade’ whose leader, Mr Brendan Dowd, had been arrested in Liverpool on July 10 1975.
An extraordinary sign of his progress after the Balcombe Street siege in December 1975 is that he continued to move freely in and out of England.
His prints had been found at the London bomb factories, and by March 1976 the Anti Terrorist Squad had obtained a warrant for his arrest. But for three more years he continued to operate, probably from a base in the Republic. He had only to adopt a false name and possibly a moustache to slip into Liverpool among the 400 other passengers who use the ferry from Belfast.
But it was in Belfast that finally he was caught, probably trying to visit his family. The visits cannot have been easy since his home near the Falls Road was receiving regular visits from the security forces who were ‘turning it over’ as a matter of routine.
Finally he was picked up on a motorway outside Belfast at a roadblock manned by the RUC Special Patrol Group. Further down the road, two other leading republicans, Martin McGuinness and Joe Deerey, were stopped in another car. Some believe the police were tipped off; others that they were trapped by nothing more than bad luck.
It was March 20 1979. Brian Keenan’s extraordinary career had finally run aground. Three days later he was flying back to England in an army helicopter. As they crossed the English coast line, he said, two RAF jets buzzed them. “It was an exciting trip,” he was to tell the jury. “But it hasn’t been very exciting since.”
Now he faces a second trial, probably early next year, when he is one of 10 co-defendants, including his wife, who are charged with plotting an escape from prison.