More serving policemen have come forward to confirm disclosures in last week’s Observer that police have been cooking the books so that they can claim to have solved hundreds of crimes they have not even investigated.
The officers, whose identities we are not revealing, have described how:
* Notorious criminals have been given a licence to burgle after agreeing to sign phony confessions, clearing up crimes they did not commit;
* Guilty men have been persuaded not to admit their crimes because some other criminal has already confessed to them;
* Scores of fictitious crimes have been invented and then ‘solved’ with false confessions, to bolster the crime figures.
Last week’s disclosures came from Ron Walker, a serving Kent officer and former detective . He secretly gathered evidence which proved that criminals had been admitting offences which they could not possibly have committed, while others were confessing to offences which had never occurred.
In January he submitted his evidence to Scotland Yard but after six months not one officer has been suspended or charged. There is now growing concern that the Yard inquiry may be unable to get to the bottom of his allegations. It is understood that there was a furious row between the Police Complaints Authority and the Director of Public Prosecutions in the early days of the inquiry when – without the authority’s knowledge or consent— officials from the DPP met Scotland Yard officers conducting the inquiry and agreed to limit its scope.
Although Mr Walker stated that the abuses involved 60 officers in Kent and hundreds more around the country, only one detective was appointed to investigate. The inquiry was then jeopardised by leaks which alerted suspect officers and disclosed Mr Walker’s role. Key documents have since gone missing from Kent police stations. One of the suspect officers, whose role in a false confession is being investigated, has been offered a secondment to a foreign police force.
The Police Complaints Authority, which is known to be deeply concerned at the extent of the allegations, is considering trying to rescue the inquiry by offering immunity against prosecution to suitable officers who are prepared to give evidence.
With the Home Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, being pressed to take a hand, Mr Walker has received support from MPs of all parties. His local Tory MP at Gillingham, Jim Couchman, tried to force an emergency debate in the Commons last week; and both Clive Soley and Alex Carlisle, the Labour and Liberal police specialists, have met Mr Walker to hear his evidence.
The Police Federation is due to discuss the issue at its next executive meeting. At its recent annual conference, the federation agreed to call for an end to the practice of ‘writing off’ crimes in confessions taken from prisoners, one of the main sources of abuse.
The detectives who came forward last week to confirm Ron Walker’s allegations say the abuse is deeply rooted. “It has always been considered that if you get on to CID, it is an honour,” said one. “It is as if you owe the force something. You are expected to bend the rules or break the rules and then cover up when the shit hits the fan. I have been part of these bent write-offs. I have done them with 10 or 12 villains. It was expected of me to do it . Had I refused, I would envisage that I would have been slung off the CID.
“You visit your villain in prison, take the sub-divisional crime book with you and just go through the unsolved crimes and he says ‘OK, I’ll have that one; yes, you can put that one down to me.’ You know, and he knows, that it’s not the way it happened. You know full well that he is clearing up crimes that someone else has committed.
“Sometimes, he is just doing it for an ounce of tobacco. Sometimes, he is getting a licence: so long as he doesn’t go to work on your patch, you’re not going to search his house in the middle of the night or give him any trouble. It is an unspoken understanding that, when he comes out, you are not going to give him any more grief than is necessary.”
The detectives, who come from different forces, say that perversion of the course of justice in order to boost crime figures is commonplace in forces throughout England and Wales. Sometimes, however, the system breaks down. In an incident described by one of the officers, a teenage boy broke a pub’s windows and fled; the landlord reported it to the police; the boy’s father then offered to pay for the damage if the landlord agreed not to tell the police that his boy had done it; the landlord accepted. Six months later, the police – unaware that the the affair had been settled – called at the pub to say that the guilty man had confessed.
In another incident, a local thief was persistently stealing women’s underwear from clothes lines. The police were annoyed, because it was damaging their crime figures and persuaded a man in prison to ‘write off’ the offences. Months later, a man was arrested for indecent exposure and admitted to stealing the underwear. “We had to tell him to shut up. He didn’t know what was going on, but we couldn’t have him admitting what he had done.”
One detective, with more than 20 years’ experience, said: “It is all one big untruth, which is taken as an official white lie, and there is a knock-on effect. The police authority sit there telling us we are doing a wonderful job, when we’re not. The real truth is that the figures are fixed to keep the local politicians off the chief constable’s back. I think we should tell the truth.”