It is, at first sight, an oddity that the latest outbreak of police corruption should occur, not in the grimy backstreets of the crime-riddled inner cities, but in the peaceful middle-class haven of conservative Kent. Yet it is apt. For the roots of this abuse lie deep in the payment-by-results philosophy of the Prime Minister.
On the evidence of Police Constable Ron Walker, published in last week’s Observer, detectives have become obsessed with crime figures. Leaving the criminals at liberty and the victims of crime at a loss, they have devised a system which allows them to ‘write off ‘ hundreds of unsolved crimes in false confessions signed by co-operative prisoners. Success on paper has supplanted success on the streets. Crime figures have always been a mess; this growing new abuse makes them virtually useless.
On the evidence of Home Office statistics, such abuses are flourishing in forces all over the country. This is a direct result of a new mood in police forces in England and Wales: what was a service has become a business; the accountant has taken over from the magistrate as the arbiter of police activity; efficiency is all.
Historically, PC Walker is at one end of a chain-reaction which begins with Lord Rayner and the Financial Management Initiative, the massive exercise to force every public body to prove that it is being cost-effective. Just as the cult of efficiency has wreaked havoc in the hospitals and on the housing estates, so in a quieter way it has undermined the strength and morale of the police. The infinite subtleties of Home Office directives have been reduced to one great simplicity – lift the clear-up rate or the money dries up.
Now the Home Secretary has a real problem on his hands: the police have buckled under the pressure. One honest policeman has stood up and risked his career to restore sanity; it is for Mr Hurd to ensure that the rest of the police machine does not also buckle, that the complaints authority, the Inspector of Constabulary and the chief constables admit the truth. Then he can go back to the roots of the problem and try and put it right.