Even before detectives have begun investigating suggestions that the peace activist Hilda Murrell was killed by British intelligence, their inquiries have apparently been anticipated by a Home Office denial.
When Labour MP Mr Tam Dalyell first made the claim, Home Office Minister Mr Giles Shaw promised he would give it “full consideration and a comprehensive reply.” Nine days later he told Mr Dalyell in a letter: “I am now able to state unreservedly that your allegations about the intelligence services being involved are totally without foundation.”
In Shrewsbury, where West Mercia police are running the murder inquiry, Detective Superintendent Barry Maine said Mr Dalyell’s claim was still ‘on the file’: “We have an open mind. We have no evidence to support the allegation and we can’t begin to look into it until we have seen Mr Dalyell, which we hope to do soon.”
Mr Dalyell said yesterday: “This is just typical of the whole Belgrano saga: claims are dismissed before they have been properly considered and then sooner or later, lo and behold, the claims turn out to be true.
“I think that Giles Shaw has simply gone through his officials to the security service and asked them, and they’ve said: ‘There’s nothing in it, old boy.'”
Miss Murrell, 78, was abducted from her home soon after noon on Wednesday, 21 March, last year. Three days later her body was found in a copse six miles away. She had been punched and stabbed and left to die of exposure.
Although the police favour the theory that she was killed by a burglar who also had a sexual motive, Det Supt Maine agrees “there are a number of anomalies.” It is these, coupled with Mr Dalyell’s insistence that he has been tipped off by a well-placed source, which have encouraged speculation about the murder.
From evidence in her house, it seems likely Miss Murrell entered it that Wednesday morning and went up to her bedroom to change, unaware that an intruder was hiding on the ground floor.
The ‘burglar ‘ then acted in an extraordinary way. Rather than run out of the house, he chose to abduct her — which also meant he had to steal her car, since he does not appear to have had one of his own.
The ‘burglar’ stole nothing – small valuables, ornaments, pictures and jewellery were close to hand – and drove off with Miss Murrell. He did not head for open country, only half a mile away, but went in the opposite direction into the middle of Shrewsbury before eventually emerging into the country on the far side of the town.
It seems the man then lost control of the car, struggled with Miss Murrell in a field, beat her and stabbed her, and then ran off. Eleven witnesses have described a man running along a route back into Shrewsbury.
The most mysterious evidence covers the next two days, while Miss Murrell lay dead and undetected. A local landowner, Mr Ian Scott, went walking through the copse where her body was found early on Thursday afternoon. He says he is positive there was no body there.
An hour after Mr Scott’s walk, a tractor driver working in a nearby field saw a man in a big dark car stop on the road, walk across the field to the copse, then return 15 to 20 minutes later and drive off. Later that night, local people say, there were lights moving around in the copse.
At Miss Murrell’s home, rain water was found inside a door supposedly closed throughout this period. When the house was finally investigated on Saturday morning, all of Miss Murrell’s handbags, old and new, lay open on the kitchen table. It is suggested that, if they had been there when Miss Murrell entered the house on Wednesday, she would not have gone upstairs and started changing.
The idea that Miss Murrell might be burgled by British intelligence is not as absurd as some Tory MPs have suggested. She was a ‘known associate’ of her nephew, Mr Rob Green, whose access to GCHQ signals during the Falklands war had made him one of a number of suspects in an inquiry into leaks ordered by Downing Street.
The security service, MI5, has a sub-section known as A1A, Technical Operations, which specialises in ‘clandestine entry.’ According to intelligence sources, it is routine for Special Branch officers to conduct such operations in the provinces, although they would usually have colleagues outside a house to warn of the occupier’s return.
It is possible, the sources suggest, that the Murrell case was the work of a Special Branch officer who visited the house to make an inquiry, found the door unlocked and went in on his own initiative.
The Conservative MP for Shrewsbury, Mr Derek Conway, hopes to raise the murder in the Commons next week. “I am concerned that this is undermining confidence in the police and that Mr Dalyell has not produced a shred of evidence,” he said.