Accused detective denies corruption

The Guardian, 29 June 1982

Detective Chief Inspector Philip Cuthbert, accused of corruption, yesterday described to a jury at the Old Bailey his 23-year career in the police, which had seen him become the youngest detective sergeant in the history of the City of London Police.

He spoke of the commendations he had received in the past and of previous unfounded allegations which had been made against him. He had been told early in his career never to accept money from contacts, although a bottle of whisky at Christmas might be acceptable.

His counsel, Mr Felix Waley QC, said that the image of a lone detective solving a case was a fiction; detection was team work. “Unless all the members of a squad are corrupt, it suggests that it would be very difficult to pursue the kind of conduct which has been alleged,” he said.

Mr Cuthbert and former Detective Sergeant John Goldbourn deny conspiring to sell bail and weaken evidence during two robbery inquiries. Mr Waley described Mr Alfie Sheppard, the main prosecution witness, as a “despicable life-long criminal, trading his lying stories.”

Mr Waley continued: “Mr Cuthbert will say that, however the facts may be twisted against him and whatever lies may be told, he has in fact remained loyal to his duty and has not ever taken any money at all to betray the trust his fellow citizens have placed in him.”

Last week the jury heard a tape-recording in which Mr Cuthbert spoke of corruption which went “right to the top of the tree” in the London police forces. Mr Waley said that his client would not understand why he had said such things. They were quite untrue.

The trial continues today.