A doctor has called publicly for Peter Sutcliffe, the Yorkshire Ripper, to be transferred from prison to a special hospital to serve the 20 life sentences he was given at the Old Bailey in May last year.
In an interview with the Guardian, Dr Hugo Milne, a forensic psychiatrist, who gave evidence at Sutcliffe’s trial, said: “Sutcliffe thinks he has had a pretty poor deal from British justice, and you can’t really dispute that.”
Sutcliffe’s treatment has provoked a bitter dispute between the Home Office and psychiatrists, who have privately warned Whitehall officials that the case has opened a dangerous breach between medicine and the law.
All six psychiatrists who have examined Sutcliffe since his arrest in January last year agree that he is a paranoid schizophrenic and should be placed in a special hospital.
They cite his behaviour in Parkhurst Prison on the Isle of Wight, where he keeps a diary of his life as one of God’s disciples, paints religious pictures, complains of visits from one of his victims and is, in the words of one qualified observer, “going pottier and pottier.”
Last month a professor of psychiatry whose opinion has been sought and accepted by the Home Office in the past, and the principal medical officer at Parkhurst, Dr David Cooper, signed the necessary forms to have Sutcliffe moved to hospital.
The transfer cannot be made without the agreement of the Home Secretary, Mr William Whitelaw. He has yet to give it, and Whitehall sources say he is likely to wait several months before declaring whether he will yield to the doctors and risk a public outcry.
Sutcliffe, aged 36, was gaoled after being convicted of the murder of 13 women and the attempted murder of seven others. He had denied murder, but admitted manslaughter with diminished responsibility – which would have permitted him to be committed to hospital immediately.
The psychiatrists have privately accused the prosecution of hypocrisy and ignorance of psychiatry. They have also attacked the role of the jury, the use of diminished responsibility pleas and the Court of Appeal’s behaviour.
Dr Milne examined Sutcliffe on behalf of the defence before his trial and again before his unsuccessful appeal in May. He said: “I am quite convinced that he was mentally ill before he started to offend and at the time of the offences and at the time of the trial and when I examined him last.
“We may not know what causes schizophrenia any more than we know what causes cancer. But that man is schizophrenic, and he is in the wrong place.”