A violent robber who homosexually assaulted some of his victims was kept in a luxury hotel by the police and given a greatly reduced sentence because he agreed to become an informer, the Court of Appeal heard yesterday. But, the court was told, the evidence which William Amis subsequently gave was open to a huge number of objections; he had failed to tell the truth about his own crimes and had been under great pressure to testify. He was “a contemptible hypocrite”.
The court was hearing the appeal against conviction of one of the men against whom Mr Amis testified, Michael Morris. Mr Morris was gaoled for 14 years in July, 1979, for robbery. He was convicted on the evidence of Mr Amis, corroborated by two other informers, David Smith and George Williams.
Mr Martin Tucker, QC, for Mr Morris, suggested that informers had a vested interest in naming names, sometimes innocent ones. “The risk always is that someone will be drawn in so that their use to the authorities increases and they can be put into the category of supergrasses and gain all the considerable advantages that are granted to them ”
Mr Amis had a long record of housebreaking, assault and robbery. In 1976 he embarked on a series of violent robberies, using guns, clubs and ammonia sprays to force house-holders to tell him where they kept their cash and valuables. After his arrest he conceded that he might he sent to prison for 20 years.
In three cases he had tied up and sexually assaulted men after bursting into their homes with his accomplices. He had also assaulted a 16-year-old boy and bitten his genitals. He frequently posed as a policeman to persuade people to open their doors.
But Mr Tucker said that he had been less than frank about all this, despite his declared wish to tell the whole truth. Mr Tucker asked : “If a man can’t tell the truth about himself, how is it right, how is it just, to convict another person on his evidence?”
It was particularly unfortunate that Mr Amis had given his first supergrass evidence before being sentenced himself, Mr Tucker said. It was also surprising that the senior officer in the case, Mr Tony Lundy, had told a court that Mr Amis was not particularly violent. “It was a surprising thing to be said, and it shows once more in a very clear form the pressures which there are on a man to ingratiate himself with the authorities,” Mr Tucker said.
After he had first appeared in court and seen his accomplices gaoled for 15 years Mr Amis had not been sentenced. Instead, he had been kept in the Atlantic Towers Hotel in Liverpool by the police, who had taken him out to pubs to drink.
“Here is a man who in the ordinary way merited 15 or 20 years. But instead he gets a night out on the town. The pressures on a man to do this sort of thing are enormous,” Mr Tucker said. Mr Amis had eventually been given a- five-year sentence.
The evidence of such an informer was unsafe and unsatisfactory. Mr Tucker claimed.
The case continues.