Beneath my passport stamp, the immigration officer wrote: “CIO R 3817/83”. CIO — the best known initials in Zimbabwe — stand for Central Intelligence Organisation, Ian Smith’s men in macs, now busier than ever, spreading fear on behalf of the state.
In three weeks in Zimbabwe, not one of the dozens of people to whom I spoke to agreed to be quoted by name. Some said they would meet me only after taking precautions which would have been comic had their fear not been so real. “Ring this number. Say you are called Michael. then go to this cafe ten minutes later… Stand on this street corner and wait for a man in a brown and white car. Go with him… Don’t use the phone… Make sure you’re not followed… Don’t quote me.” Many refused to speak at all.
Robert Mugabe’s government is under pressure: from white farmers and multinational companies, from armed dissidents and militant socialists, from drought and world recession. Seeing enemies everywhere, the government is reaching for any available weapon. Many of them come from the armoury of the old white regime.
Ian Smith’s notorious Emergency Powers Act, under which many of the present cabinet were once indefinitely detained, has been renewed with clockwork regularity every six months since independence three years ago. One EPA regulation allows the Government to detain a citizen for 30 days without charge or evidence — 60 days if a minister authorises it. A different regulation allows for indefinite detention.
Last August, Sydney Malunga, an MP in Joshua Nkomo’s Zapu party, criticised the use of detention in the Zimbabwe Assembly. Two weeks ago, Mr Malunga was detained along with hundreds of others during the military sweep through the townships of Bulawayo. There has been no news of his release. Other Zapu MPs, including Vote Moyo and Akim Ndlovu, have also been held along with countless Zapu officials, supporters and local councillors and the white RF MP, Wally Stuttaford, who was widely reported to have been tortured.
A Bulawayo magistrate, Johnson Mkindla, was among those beaten and detained in the townships sweep. J. C. Dlanini, superintendent of Mpilo Hospital in Bulawayo, was held for four weeks after a “dissident” patient escaped from his armed guard in February. Last week, two white farmers were in detention: they had been reported for making derogatory remarks about the Government.
The Minister of Home Affairs, Dr Herbet Ushewokunze, is unabashed about the use of the powers which he oversees. Last October, he made a public attack on food-hoarders. “Once we get them, we will lock them up until we feel they should get out,” he threatened.
With the detentions came reports of torture. The techniques, like the emergency powers, have been inherited from the days of Ian Smith — electric shocks and suffocation by water. Some claim that in Matabeleland in the last two months, they have been tortured by the same white officers who tortured them during the war for independence. Outside Brady Barracks in Bulawayo, at the far end of the old Kumalo airstrip, a special detention block has been built. One man who has seen inside it swears it is full of torture equipment. His story cannot be confirmed.
Even without the bludgeon of emergency powers, the Mugabe government has the legal steamroller of the Law and Order Maintenance Act, another unrepealed invention of the old regime. It permits detention without trial and reverses the burden of proof where a trial does take place; and, above all, it applies under normal conditions so that even if, for political reasons, the government were forced to repeal the Emergency Powers Act, it would still be able to imprison its opponents.
As Mugabe presses home the old laws, he has run into one problem which did not face Ian Smith: the judges. Under the old regime, they were keen to enforce the laws, dispatching Mugabe’s “terrorists” to the gallows and to prison cells for life. Now Ministers complain — more and more bitterly and publicly — that the old hanging judges won’t swing the rope for them and complain when confessions are obtained by torture and duress. “They worked for Smith. Why won’t they work for us?”
Several judges have been publicly castigated for failing to convict alleged spies. In January, two white men were acquitted and immediately detained again: the Security Minister said the South African Government had confirmed their guilt by negotiating for their release.
So far, the government has resisted the temptation to sack Smith’s judges and appoint others in their place. The outcome of the current trial, in which senior former members of Zapu’s armed wing, Zipra, including Lookout Masuku and Dumiso Dabengwa, are accused of treason, may be crucial. The case goes to the heart of the government’s attack on dissidents. The defendants were arrested after the discovery of arms caches in February 1982 and have been the object of ransom demands by kidnappers who took six tourists last year and a white farmer last week to secure their release. If the government is frustrated in that trial, observers fear, the judiciary may join the casualty list of victims of the new authoritarianism. The list is long.
The right of citizens to seek criminal or civil actions against members of the security forces has been curtailed by reviving Ian Smith’s notorious Indemnity and Compensation Act. The move sent shivers of apprehension through Harare. Under pressure from the Senate Legal Committee, the government has agreed to remove some parts of the bill. However, the new Act still means that citizens cannot sue security forces for damages or bring private prosecutions against them. The state alone will decide whether they should be prosecuted.
New powers have been taken to curtail the organisation of political rallies, which may now be held only with government permission, and that must be sought at least seven days in advance. Statutory Instrument 825(d) of the Emergency Powers Act allows the Minister of Home Affairs to seize the property of anyone declared to be an enemy of the state. It has already been used, for example against a white farmer who was acquitted on spying charges and fled to South Africa when he heard he was about to be detained again.
High on the list of institutional victims is the press. The killings in Matabeleland have gone unreported, apart from derogatory remarks about “false stories in the foreign press.” Even when specific allegations have been made in the Assembly and Senate, they have failed to find their way into print. This is often a matter of self-censorship by willing members of Mugabe’s Zanu party. The editor of the Harare Herald, Farai Munyuki, was Zanu’s information officer in the US. He wanted to study plant genetics, but he was given the newspaper instead. The editor of the Bulawayo Chronicle, Tommy Sithole, is also a loyal party man.
The CIO is woven through the legal and institutional drift to repression. They answer directly to Robert Mugabe’s office, as they once did to Ian Smith’s. They are flanked by the Zimbabwe Intelligence Police, Zip, revived to work for Dr Ushewokunze’s Home Affairs ministry. The two organisastions work without subtlety.
Joshua Nkomo exploited this when he decided to flee the country. One of his aides rang journalists in the Holiday Inn, Bulawayo, to say that he wanted to meet the press that afternoon. The phone was tapped. The hotel lobby filled up with journalists and CIO men while Nkomo trundled across the border in his Land-Rover.
Robert Mugabe is at the centre of this web of power. Five ministers, including those for Security, Defence, and the Civil Service, now report directly to him rather than to the Cabinet. Executive rule by decree thus erodes rule by parliament. To consolidate the pattern, Mugabe is pressing for the constitution to he amended so that the upper house, the Senate, is abolished and the state is formally declared to have only one party, probably composed of Zanu and the bourgeois faction of Nkomo’s Zapu.
But after three years of growing repression, the fact of a one-party state with all the trappings of terror is virtually established without the need for constitutional cosmetics.
NOTE: This story provoked outraged complaints from middle-class Guardian readers who refused to accept that Mugabe was anything other than a hero of the struggle against racism and imperalism.