Nilsen wrote to police debating the motive for his killings

The Guardian, 26 October 1983

Dennis Nilsen wrote a series of notes and letters from his prison cell to police officers who were working on his case, outlining his feelings about his killings and about his life.

In the letters, read to the court yesterday, Nilsen wrote that he was unsure of his motives for killing. “There is no disputing the fact that I am a violent killer under certain circumstances. The victim is the dirty platter after the feast, and the washing up is a clinically ordinary task. It would be better if my reason for killing could be clearly defined, ie robbery, jealousy, hate, revenge, sex, blood lust or sadism. But it is none of these.”

He wrote of the remorse he had felt since his arrest and quoted lines from Oscar Wilde’s Ballad of Reading Gaol: “Each man kills the thing he loves … the coward does it with a kiss; the brave man with a sword.”

Nilsen has denied murdering Kenneth Ockenden, Martin Duffey, William Sutherland, Malcolm Barlow, John Howlett and Stephen Sinclair and attempting to murder Douglas Stewart and Paul Nobbs. He has pleaded guilty to manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility.

Detective Chief Inspector Peter Jay told the court yesterday that he had arrested Nilsen on February 9 after four fingers and some flesh had been found in the drain outside his home in Cranley Gardens, Muswell Hill.

Mr Jay read to the court a series of notes and letters written in custody by Nilsen. The first, dated February 15, was headed: “Unscrupulous behaviour (sexual depression?)” and covered two pieces of foolscap. “I guess that I may be a creature, a psychopath,” he wrote, “who, when in a loss of rationality situation lapses into temporarily a destructive psychopath, a condition induced by rapid and heavy ingestion of alcohol.

“At the subconscious root lies a sense of total social isolation and a desperate search for a sexual identity. I have experienced transitory sexual relationships with both males and females before my first killing. After this event, I was incapable of any intercourse. I felt repelled by myself and, as stated, have had no experience of sexual penetration for some years.

“In a society of labels, it is convenient for me to let others believe that I am homosexual. I enjoy the social company of both men and women but prefer to drink socially with men.”

The court has heard that Nilsen told police he had picked up 15 or 16 young men in pubs, taken them home for more drinks, and then strangled them. “God only knows what thoughts go through my mind when it is captive within a destructive binge,” he wrote.

He suggested drink might destroy his feelings of morality and listed other possible motives. “It may be the perverted overkill or my need to help people – victims who I decide to release quickly from the slings and arrows of their outrageous fortune, pain and suffering.

“Or could it be the sub-conscious outpouring of all the primitive instincts of primaeval man ? Could it be a case of the individual exaltation in beating the system and a need to beat and confound it time and time again? It amazes me that I have no tears for these victims. I have no tears for myself or those bereaved by my action.”

He noted the fact that he had not been haunted by the ghosts of his victims and ended the letter with a reference to his dog, Bleep. “Memories of man’s best friend – i.e. my dog – are already a little faded.”

In a second letter, dated two days later on February 17, he described the attractions of alcohol, particularly in combination with good music. “That is a totally emotional experience. Glorious images and feelings are conjured up whilst in this state. I relive episodes of my life from childhood to the present (leaving out the bad bits).

“At the point where alcohol spirits me from my memory and control, I see myself drifting along and then moved out of my isolated prison (my flat). I bring back to my prison people who are not always allowed to leave. Maybe I want them to share my high experience of spirits and music. I still do not know the engine of my performance.”

On February 19 he offered police information on men he had attacked without killing them. “In some cases, the attempts were foiled by the struggle or escape of the subject. In others, I had a change of heart/presence of mind to desist from carrying through the task.”

He wrote of a Japanese man “in suit, collar and tie” whom he met in a pub on New Year’s Eve, 1982. Back at his flat, they drank cans of Pils lager before the man was attacked “in a muddled attempt at strangulation.” He had run screaming from the house, disturbing the girl tenants on the ground floor.

He also described a male prostitute who visited him that winter, offering him sex for £20. He refused. He provided a long account of his attempts to strangle Carl Strottor, who was a witness at yesterday’s hearing.

He said he had strangled him and thought him dead and left him laid out on a sofa while he had a drink and listened to Rick Wakeman’s Criminal Record. “Then Bleep appeared and pawed at my arm. She persisted, and I asked her if she wanted to go out.

“She went over to the man and started whining and licking what I thought was a dead body on his face. Then I noticed the corpse had started breathing and shivering with cold. I pulled him over to the fire and rubbed his arms and legs to get the circulation going…. I was desperate that he should live.”

In another note he told police that his favourite piece of music was Oh, Superman by Laurie Anderson. “It has a hypnotic, trance-like effect on me. I listened to its full eight minutes ten times one night. I was compelled to play it over and over and couldn’t stop myself until the Bacardi ran out, followed by my senses not long after.”

His final letter was written to Mr Jay and his senior officer, Detective Chief Superintendent Geoffrey Chambers, from Brixton Prison on May 25. “Dear Sirs,” it began. “I thank you sincerely for all your professional efforts in trying to unravel the multiplicity of detailed evidence and facts pertinent to solving the mysteries of enigmas surrounding this unfortunate, serious and monumental case.

“Whatever any future court may decide, I would like you to believe the truth – that I did not maliciously plan any of the acts which form the basis of the case. In clear conscience, I could never contemplate the commissioning of any act of assault against any person or living creature.

“My remorse is of the deep and personal kind which will eat away inside me for the rest of my life. I am, tragically, a private person, not given to public tears. The enormity of these acts has left me in permanent shock.”

He ends the letter with the quotation from the Ballad of Reading Gaol and signs off “Sadly, Dennis Nilsen, HM Prison Brixton.”

** Two young homosexuals yesterday described how Dennis Nilsen tried to strangle them at his flat in Muswell Hill, north London. Both told the jury that they had found Nilsen to be friendly and pleasant before attacking them – and afterwards.

In a soft voice, Carl Stottor told how he met Nilsen in a gay pub in Camden in May. “He said how pretty I was, and he seemed a very nice person, very kind. I was sort of depressed and be talked to me.”

They had taken a taxi back to Nilsen’s top-floor flat in Cranley Gardens, Muswell Hill. On the way, they had held hands. Inside the flat, they had drunk together, played with Nilsen’s dog, Bleep, and talked about Stottor’s problems with his boyfriend in Blackpool.

Mr Stottor said he had begun to feel ill and went to bed. Nilsen had warned him to be careful of a torn zip hanging off a sleeping bag on the bed. They had both gone to sleep in the bed. “Then I woke up feeling something round my neck. My head was hurting, and I couldn’t breathe properly and I wondered what it was.

“I felt his hand pulling at the zip at the back of my neck. He was saying in a sort of whispered shouting voice: ‘Stay still, stay still.’ I thought perhaps he was trying to help me out of the sleeping bag that he had warned me about.”

Mr Stottor’s voice broke as he described his next memory. “I remember vaguely hearing running water and then I felt very cold and I knew I was in the water, and he was trying to drown me. He kept pushing me into the water and on the third time, I came out and said: ‘No more. Please, no more.’ But he pushed me under again. I just thought I was dying. I thought: ‘You are drowning.'”

Some time later he had woken up on a couch with Bleep licking his face. When he saw his face in the mirror he saw a red line round his neck and broken blood vessels all over his face. His throat was swollen and sore.

Nilsen told him he had had a nightmare and that he had had to splash water over him to get him out of shock. He had never told the police because he had wanted to forget the incident.

Paul Nobbs, aged 21, a Ianguage student from Watford, told the court that he met Nilsen in a gay pub in Soho one lunchtime In November 1981. He had liked him and decided to leave the pub with him in order to avoid the attentions of a boy called Timmy who was pestering him.

Although they had not discussed sex, there came a time in the evening when after drinking Bacardi and Coke together, Nobbs got up and got into bed and Nilsen followed him. “We proceeded to kiss and cuddle and fondle each other,” he said. They fell asleep.

“I woke up between two and three o’clock in the morning, feeling very ill. I had a stinking headache and I went to get a glass of water and sat down in the living room.” He went back to sleep and woke a few hours later, still feeling ill.

“I went to splash some water on my face and in the mirror over the sink I saw my face. It was very red, and there were no whites in my eyes: they were all blood-shot. I had a sore throat and I felt very sick.” Nilsen had told him he was suffering the after-effects of the Bacardi.

But later, after finding a red mark round his throat, he went to a hospital where a doctor diagnosed “a classic case of strangulation.”

The court has heard that Nilsen told police after his arrest: “I had a tie around his neck. He was on the bed, and I was panicking. Then I remember trying to revive him because his heart was still beating.” He told police be had had “a change of heart.”

Mr Nobbs told the court that he had not contacted police after the incident. “I didn’t want anything to be said about it. I don’t know why, but I presumed I had been mugged. It seemed pointless. The fact that I’m a homosexual would probably have brought some doubts into the minds of the police.”

 

 

 

 

???????

The court has heard that Nilsen told police he had picked up 15 or 16 young men in pubs, taken them home for more drinks, and strangled them. “God only knows what thoughts go through my mind when it is captive within a destructive binge,” he wrote. He suggested drink might destroy his feelings of morality and listed other possible motives.

“It may be the perverted overkill of my need to help people – victims who I decide to release quickly from the slings and arrows of their outrageous fortune, pain and suffering. Or could it be the subconscious outpouring of all the primitive instincts of primeval man? Could it be a case of the individual exaltation in beating the system and a need to beat and confound it time and time again? It amazes me that I have no tears for these victims. I have no tears for myself or those bereaved by my action.”