A London man was wrongly sentenced to 25 years’ imprisonment after Scotland Yard’s robbery squad had unlawfully arrested him, held him incommunicado for eight days, and extracted unreliable confessions from him, an appeal court judge said yesterday.
He added that Daniel Gowan, aged 52, of Cheshunt, had started a hunger strike in protest at his treatment; he had fainted during one police interview. The behaviour of the robbery squad officers had been a breach of the judges’ rules on arrests and interviews.
In a reserved judgment on Mr Gowan’s appeal, Lord Justice O’Connor said: “It seems to us that it is quite unsafe to say that Gowan’s will was not overborne by the treatment to which he had been subjected.”
Mr Gowan was gaoled for 25 years in July 1979 on three counts of armed robbery and one of conspiracy to rob. He appealed and in October 1981 the convictions were quashed. Yesterday, the court gave the reasons for its judgment.
Lord Justice O’Connor said that Mr Gowan was one of several suspects arrested in the early hours of November 8, 1977 by a robbery squad which had been set up under the command of Detective Chief Inspector Tony Lundy to investigate attacks on security vans.
Mr Lundy had ordered his men to refuse the suspects access to anyone, including their solicitors.
A clerk for Mr Gowan’s solicitors had repeatedly tried to see him and had been refused. The solicitors had decided after six days to apply for a writ of habeaus corpus. Later, officers had admitted that their strategy was designed to “get Gowan to crack.”
The arrest itself had been unlawful since Mr Gowan was not told that he was being arrested, or what offences were supposed to be involved, but this had not by itself put pressure on him.
Lord Justice O’Connor said that Mr Gowan should have been brought before a magistrates’ court by November 10 at the latest. He had finally appeared on November 16. He should have been charged, on the evidence, by November 13; he had not been charged until November 15.
At his trial, the prosecution had relied on the evidence of informers and three admissions which Mr Gowan was said to have made during his eight days in custody. Mr Gowan had always denied making any admissions.