It’s all a question of necrophilia. When a group of veteran journalists gathered one weekend last year to teach the skills of investigative reporting to an audience of working journalists and students, it was certainly exciting. The news editor of the Guardian said it was “fantastic – really, really interesting, thought-provoking, useful and inspiring”, and so we are doing it again – in Sheffield, this June.
And yet, for all the excitement, last year’s event had the whiff of the cemetery about it, because we were enthusiastically embracing a craft which is widely thought to be dead – thrillingly satisfying for those involved, absolutely essential in a modern democracy, the finest form of reporting but, well, dead, suffocated by outrageous legal restraints and by the creeping commercialisation of the media.
On the face of it, the year since that first course has seen few signs of life for investigative reporters. Peter Mandelson might look like Fleet Street’s scalp, but in truth, he was brought down by the eagle-eyed Liberal Democrat Norman Baker. The reporting was embarrassingly weak: we still don’t know what Mandelson did to deserve to lose his job; and nor do we know the wider truth about contacts between the government and the Hindujas.
In the same way, we still don’t know – as random examples – why George W Bush really bombed Iraq last month (military necessity or post-electoral politics?); or why the last commissioner of the Metropolitan Police suddenly became so alarmed about corruption in his ranks; or what the Prime Minister says to the Queen each week; or what civil servants ever say to their ministers. We do finally know what the former chief inspector of schools really thought about the education secretary – but only because the chief inspector turned reporter and told us himself. We still suffer from the Official Secrets Act, absurd libel laws, the culture of secrecy in government and the failure to introduce a decent Freedom of Information Act; and it looks as though we are about to suffer a new privacy law, created by unelected judges at the behest of unedifying celebrities.
Yet, when you reach for the corpse, you feel it breathe. In a weekend of solid learning, the greatest single lesson of last year’s course at the University of Sussex was the sheer scale of enthusiasm which survives for the idea of the reporter as trouble-maker. Within a fortnight of the course being announced, some 500 people had applied for the 200 tickets – from as far as the Shetlands, Dublin and Hong Kong, all would-be journalists and working journalists wanting to break free and use their job to make a difference. One rising star threatened to sell her kidney to get a place on the course. At the end of the final day, two television presenters separately confided that they were going to resign to become ‘real reporters’, and even some of the veterans confessed that they had learned from each other.
This year, we have a bigger room, tickets for about a quarter of the price of comparable courses and we are also giving away fifty free seats to students through a national contest. If the course works, it does so partly as a matter of inspiration. Paul Foot had that effect last year. Phillip Knightley is likely to this year – the only print journalist to twice win the award of Journalist of the Year, with an extraordinary track record through some of the most devastating scandals of the last 30 years – the Philby affair, Thalidomide, Profumo, the whole long season of classics from the old Sunday Times Insight team.
The course should work, too, as the disclosure of technique – the daily nuts and bolts of investigation. So, Don Hale, currently Journalist of the Year, is going to relive the old-fashioned, door-stepping, clue-sifting detective work which – despite death threats and judicial lethargy – led to his securing the release of Stephen Downing after 27 years of wrongful imprisonment.
A lot of this work involves side-stepping legal obstacles, and we’ll look specifically at the Official Secrets Act from the point of view both of the reporter and the whistleblower: Mark Hollingsworth who broke the story of MI5 officer David Shayler will share a platform with Shayler himself (unless someone in heavy boots is stupid enough to stop him).
John Troup, who ran the Bruce Grobbelaar match-fixing story for the Sun will talk about covert filming and his seven-year libel marathon. I’ll talk at alarming length about first principles and techniques, and we’ll have special sessions on the Internet and on the use of public records to expose corruption. And, with any luck, at the end of the weekend, several hundred investigative reporters will emerge, alive and looking for trouble.