Court of Appeal to hear Chard case

The Guardian, 30 March 1983

Mr William Whitelaw, the Home Secretary, is to ask the Court of Appeal to review the case of Alan Chard, the alleged bank robber who was sentenced to 12 years in prison on the evidence of an informer who has now admitted that he lied.

Mr Chard was sentenced at the Old Bailey in November 1975 on three charges of conspiring to rob banks. Evidence against him was given by three police informers.

M Stephen Ross, the Liberal MP for the Isle of Wight, who has taken up Mr Chard’s case, said last night that he was delighted at the news. But he added: “I would prefer them to make a straight decision, to release him. Still, at least we’re making some progress at last.”

Mr.Chard, who is serving his sentence in Parkhurst Prison on the Isle of Wight has always protested his innocence. Another Parkhurst inmate, Mr Jim Colla, produced a 52,000-word dossier on the case, detailing the contradictions in the evidence of the informers.

At the beginning of this month, one of the informers, Mr Peter Wilding, admitted to The Guardian that he lied in court and that he had never even met Mr Chard. He said: “Everything that I said about him is untrue, I realise now that I was wrong to have lied.” He said that he was pressurised by other informers.

The Home Office asked Scotland Yard’s Serious Crimes Squad to investigate Mr Wilding’s statement and to review the background to the case. It is on the basis of the results of that inquiry that Mr Whitelaw has now decided to refer the case back to the Appeal Court.

He is doing so under a section of the Criminal Appeal Act, 1968, which enables the court to re-examine the facts of the case. It was not known last night how soon the Appeal Court would be able to consider the the case.