Mr William Whitelaw, the Home Secretary, last night agreed to consider setting up an inquiry into police corruption in London along the lines of Lord Scarman’s inquiry into the 1981 riots.
The need for an inquiry was pressed upon him by the Liberal leader, Mr David Steel, and the Liberal MP for the Isle of Wight, Mr Stephen Ross, during a 45-minute meeting at the Home Office yesterday.
The two Liberals told him they had prima facie evidence against some 20 London detectives, some of very senior rank, including a tape recording of officers apparently accepting a £1,000 bribe and statements made by supergrass informers that implicate detectives in crime.
But they declined to give Mr Whitelaw the names of the officers or to hand over their evidence, on the ground that much of it was already the object of an anti-corruption inquiry, and also because a general investigation was needed, not a witch hunt. They emphasised to the Home Secretary that they were concerned that Operation Countryman, which has spent nearly four years investigating corruption in London, had been obstructed and had been unable to persuade the Director of Public Prosecutions to bring suspected officers to court.
Mr Whitelaw told them he would consult the Lord Chancellor, the Attorney General, and the present head of Countryman, Sir Peter Matthews, before deciding whether or not to establish the inquiry. Mr Steel said later: “Some police officers themselves are concerned that they have not been able to bring all those involved in wrongdoing to book. One officer said that it was not corruption he was dealing with but organised crime by policemen.”
The Liberals asked the Home Secretary to establish a public inquiry under Section 32 of the 1964 Police Act, the same section used to create the Scarman inquiry. Mr Steel said that such an inquiry “would enable whatever nest of corruption there is to be rooted out more satisfactorily than the system of going to the courts. He undertook to consider it.” The MPs told him that the inquiry should review the evidence collected by Operation Countryman and by other similar inquiries and publish a report.
Corrupt officers should, they said, be dismissed from the force and publicly exposed although they would not necessarily be prosecuted. As an alternative they suggested that a senior QC should be given a team of officers and lawyers who would have inquisitorial powers to oblige suspected officers to answer questions and cooperate with anti-corruption inquiries.
The two MPs defended their decision to press the issue. Mr Ross said he had received information from long-term prisoners and from journalists: “I cannot sit in the House of Commons having received this sort of information and do nothing about it.” Mr Ross added that he had been compelled to act on the information which he had collected over the months when two City of London officers were gaoled for conspiracy last week and he read subsequent newspaper reports about the extent of Countryman’s inquiries and the difficulties which it had encountered.
UPDATE: No such public inquiry was established.