Dead England’s hearse

The Guardian, 10 March 1994

It is quiet in the graveyard. Away to the west, all Birmingham is on its way to work, the motorways are humming, the pavements are already choked with shoppers and on the radio they are wondering about the weather, but when the big, dark hearse rolls in through the heavy iron gates of Sutton Coldfield cemetery, there is silence.

The young undertaker steps out and pulls on his black leather gloves, the two officers from the Salvation Army slip their caps under their arms and look down at their feet, the nice woman from Social Services tucks her handbag into her side and all of them glance at the tiny wooden coffin, no bigger than a shoe box, almost hidden by its wreath of white lillies in the back of the hearse. There are very few mourners for the funeral of the unknown baby.

She was found two days before Christmas by two van men who were collecting bags of clothing which had been left for the Salvation Army in charity bins around the West Midlands. As they emptied the bin in the lay-by outside Yardley library, they found one bag which was much heavier than the others and when they parted the old towelling inside, they recoiled in horror and called the police.

A little of the story was easy to find. On Christmas Eve, the pathologist came and said that she had been born perfect, full term, weighing seven pounds and eight ounces, measuring twenty two inches from scalp to wrinkled toe, one healthy baby girl, hungry for life. But from her first breath, the pathologist said, she had struggled with the mucous in her airways, no one had helped her and, within minutes, she had suffocated.

The rest of the story was more elusive. Detectives from Acock’s Green knocked on all the doors of all the houses in the area, but no one had seen anyone by the clothing bin. They trawled all the casualty wards of all the hospitals in the West Midlands, but no one remembered treating a birth without a baby. There were no clues in the carrier bag and not so much as an old laundry mark on the towelling. They appealed for information in the local press but it was Christmas and everyone had other things on their mind. They had nothing to work on: no name, no fingerprints, not even a face that anyone would recognise.

And the mystery went deeper. The mother. The detectives could only begin to imagine the conspiracy of circumstances which had led the mother to allow her baby to die. Was it simply ignorance and fear – a young girl who concealed her pregnancy from everyone, even herself, and finally gave birth with nothing but confusion for company? Or had she encountered some overwhelming worry which had persuaded her to decide deliberately that she must let the baby go?

The possibilities crowded in. The bin where the baby was found was on the Outer Circle, the natural route around the city for anyone who lived anywhere within 50 miles of Birmingham. And it was only ten minutes away from the M42 and the whole network of national motorways. The more they looked, the more the detectives agreed that the baby could have come from anywhere.

Now, the young undertaker cradles the coffin in his arms and, with the two Salvation Army officers beside him and the woman from Social Services in their wake, he sets off down the long, sloping avenue that runs through the middle of the cemetery. The gravedigger stops sweeping old leaves and leans on the end of his broom to watch them go down the hill, past the graves where husbands and wives and whole families lie together, down to a little rectangle of lawn behind a hedge, the public plot for babies whose parents cannot afford their funeral.

The young undertaker rests the little box on two wooden staves across the mouth of the open grave, loops a cord through each of its gilt handles and stands back with the ends of the cords resting in one black leather glove. The granite tombstone at the head of the plot says “In Loving Memory of All Our Babies”. On the wall over the flower bed is a collection of 12 plaques with the names of the children who are buried there. But this child has no name. At least, none that the law will recognise.

The Salvation Army workers who watched the mystery unfold decided that she must be named, even if the name could not be registered without a parent, so they called her Sally-Ann, partly because it was their own nick name but more because it was cheerful, a perky little name. Now Cyril Halstead, the Army’s Divisional Commander for the West Midlands, opens his book of prayers and begins to speak over the grave. “As we stand here this morning, so much is unknown…”

He is right. After ten weeks of inquiry, no one is any the wiser about Sally-Ann, but the questions about her death have stirred up all kinds of disconnected scraps of fact: mothers who have no money for their children; children who beg food from door to door; mothers who have no partners, no home that’s worth the name, no help, no possible escape. And all of these different glimpses form part of one inescapable image, of impoverished mothers shoveled over the brink by the pressures of daily life in Britain in 1994. Like the unknown soldier in Westminster Abbey, Sally-Ann has become a symbol for all the unknown children who have become victims of the new poverty.

She could easily have been born on the upper floors of one of Birmingham’s tower blocks, where scores of young families are trapped for 24 hours a day and where the only playground for their children is a corridor decorated with urine and graffitti, the kind of place that the National Childrens Bureau had in mind last year when they discovered that one out of every 25 children in Britain now lives in a home that is officially condemned as unfit for human habitation.

She may have come from one of the city estates where the police helicopter comes out at night with its search light raking the streets, waging the war against drugs that now attacks the people it was supposed to defend and where no one feels safe enough to let their children out to play. In Birmingham, like most big cities now, the schools have to put out warnings about suspicious men outside school gates, selling smack and buying sex, and last week, there was a woman posing as a social worker who talked her way into a council flat and tried to abduct a child by pretending to have a court order to take it into care.

Violence surrounds these children like a wrapper round a sweet. A man in the Nechells area of the city keeps breaking into his ex-wife’s home to thrash her and steal her things. Sometimes, he is sitting there waiting for her when she comes in and he starts beating the place up and thumping her and threatening the three children. She’s so fed up with him that she’s afraid she’ll stab him, and now the social workers are asking about the children, and she’s afraid they’ll get taken into care.

Across the street, there is a man who has been leaving the imprint of his slipper in blue bruises on his two-year-old daughter’s legs. The police have been to see him twice, and he tells them that it wasn’t him. The truth is that he loves the girl but he can’t control his temper. Now, his young wife is living on a tightrope, trying to protect her daughter from the next explosion of rage and trying, too, to tell better lies to the police to persuade them not to take the little girl away from her.

Almost everyone is short of money. Some borrow from loan sharks who charge interest at 140% and then come round and threaten to torch the house if they fall behind with their payments. Some steal, some smoke dope or drink, and a few dive off the tower blocks to escape. There was a man in Nechells who did that recently, who put a bag over his head before he jumped, as if he was so ashamed of everything that he wanted to die unrecognised.

If Sally-Ann’s mother grew up in a place like this, she would have known that one certain, simple way to make life even worse would be to have a baby. There was a time when the great fat safety net of the welfare state used to reach out and catch women with babies, but now it has been cut to pieces. Free milk, free vitamins, free meals have been snatched from the hands of most children. Maternity grants and maternity allowances have been abolished.

If Sally-Ann’s mother was working, she would have faced a financial disaster. At best, she would have been given only £52.50 a week in Statutory Maternity Pay. At worst, she would have joined the thousands of working women who are now pushed through loopholes in the law because they have not held the same job for at least two years or because they do not earn enough to qualify. Where once the law protected her, she might well now also have lost her job for ever.

If she was not working, she might have been able to beg a £100 Maternity Payment from the ruins of the welfare state – nowhere near enough to pay for clothing and a cot and bedding and a buggy and bottles and all the other props of parenthood. If she had more than £500 saved up anywhere, she would have lost even that small hand-out. It is there only for those who are poor and broke. Five years ago that accounted for one fifth of all the children who were born in Great Britain. Now, it accounts for one third: one in every three children in Britain is now born to parents who are poor and broke.

If Sally-Ann’s mother lived in a flat with a private landlord, she would probably have had trouble. “No pets, no children” – it’s almost a standard rule. If she tried to move, she would have had problems with the rent. When they changed the rules in April 1988, a million people lost their right to Housing Benefit and five million others had it cut. If she had trouble heating her home, she would simply have gone cold. Electricity and gas companies now routinely install meters in the homes of poor families: if they have no cash, they have no heat. In Birmingham alone, some 600 people die each year from winter hardship.

If she was in a council flat, she would have been at the mercy of the housing department. There was a woman in central Birmingham last week who was evicted from her council maisonette. She tried to explain that she had been working for a hotel which had stopped paying her when she took time off for a hysterectomy but she was working again now and ready to pay her arrears. It made no difference. Last Wednesday morning, at 10.30, four bailiffs came and locked her out. She went to a neighbour, weeping with fear about what would happen to her and to her children, while behind her, the bailiffs nailed boards over the windows of her old maisonette and left it empty.

If Sally-Ann’s mother had the confidence to inquire, she would have discovered that a single mother with two children is supposed to survive on Income Support of only £88.65 a week. The Child Poverty Action Group has worked out that she would need £23.08 more than that each week to break even. In Birmingham alone, there are 25,000 single mothers on Income Support.

On these estates, children die at twice the rate of their counterparts in the middle classes. Their diets are worse, they are shorter and lighter, their teeth are more rotten, they are more anaemic. The industrial economy which was built on the backs of their ancestors is being pulled down on top of them, and there is little that the local authorities can do to protect them. Maybe Sally-Ann’s mother simply looked at the wasteland around her and decided that if all life was as meaningless as this, then there was no meaning to her child’s life either.

But there is something about the way she behaved after the baby was dead that suggests that she was doing something more positive than that. She could have left the body on a rubbish dump or in a canal or in the litter bin at the next bus stop, but she didn’t. She went out, presumably on her own, presumably at night when no one would see her, and she sought out this Salvation Army box: her daughter would be looked after; someone would know what had happened. It is as if she cared about the child enough to be sure that she wanted to save her from the life that oppressed her, and, if she did feel that way, she would not be alone.

The price of a child is now too high for many mothers to pay. The National Council for One Parent Families say that financial hardship has become the overwhelming reason why mothers ask for their children to be adopted, even though their own wish would be to keep them; and senior social workers speak of “a new market in working class babies for middle class parents”. Others are pushed into abortion: advice workers at Marie Stopes clinics say the recession has seen a surge in women trying to terminate pregnancies because they don’t have the money or the security to cope with a child.

In the graveyard now, Cyril Halstead is reading from the Book of Revelations, the passage about the new Heaven and the new Earth with the new Jerusalem in its midst. A man and a woman hurry down through the cemetery. They are young detectives from Acock’s Green and they have brought a wreath with “Rest In Peace” on the label. They lay it down on the edge of the grave and stand quietly with the little group, heads bowed.

Cyril Halstead shuffles forwards with his hands clasped together. “We commend the earthly body of this dear child Sally Ann to the grave.” He pauses. “Earth to earth…” The young undertaker grips the cords tight and stoops to pull away the wooden staves beneath the coffin “… Ashes to ashes…” The cords slip slowly through the black leather gloves and then stop. “…Dust to dust…”

Cyril Halstead drops his chin on his chest, the second Salvation Army man says a slow prayer for Sally-Ann and her mother. The woman from Social Services and the two detectives glance down into the grave. And it is finished. It has taken only five minutes to say Goodbye to the unknown baby.

Away to the west, all Birmingham is afloat on commerce. All the trades of dire necessity run through the streets like waste water, beggars selling smiles, old women working shifts in litter bins, men slaving over cider bottles, and single mothers who tried to buy a dream and could not afford it. “The winner’s shout and the loser’s curse both dance before dead England’s hearse.”

Down in the ground in Sutton Coldfield cemetery, the tiny coffin lies alone. The bunch of lillies has been taken away now, the gravedigger comes with his shovel and sends the soil drumming down onto the lid, soon obscuring the four words that the undertaker had printed there in epitaph, “Unknown White Female Baby”.