Sienna Miller sues police and News of the World as Yard faces new criticism

The Guardian, 14 September 2010

Sienna Miller yesterday became the latest public figure to join the legal assault on Scotland Yard and the News of the World over the phone-hacking scandal.

Lawyers for the actor, whose private life has been a tabloid obsession, said she was ready to join the former deputy prime minister John Prescott and others in asking the courts for a judicial review of the police’s conduct of the case. Sources said she had taken the first step towards suing the paper for invading her privacy by allegedly listening to her voicemail messages.

The legal moves came after Miller, aged 28, discovered that the paper’s private investigator, Glenn Mulcaire, had procured her mobile phone numbers, account number and secret PIN code, needed to intercept the voicemail of the minority of people who change the factory settings on their phones.

It also emerged that Sean Hoare, a former News of the World journalist who told the New York Times and the BBC about hacking at the paper under Coulson, has been interviewed by police under caution. Lawyers said this indicated he was being treated by police as a suspect. “An interview under caution would follow someone being arrested as a suspect, except in the most exceptional circumstances,” said Peter Lodder QC, a criminal barrister.

Paul McMullan, a second former News of the World staffer who told the Guardian that hacking was rife at the paper, was also contacted by detectives yesterday and similarly was told that they would like to question him under caution.

MPs last night said they were puzzled by the Yard’s decision to interview Hoare and McMullan under caution and expressed concern that it could discourage other witnesses from coming forward.

David Winnick, a Labour member of the Commons home affairs select committee which has launched an inquiry into the law around phone hacking, said: “All this seems very strange indeed. The standards and privileges committee will be very interested in this development. It will certainly make [other potential witnesses] more cautious. I can well understand that those who thought they could put their part of what happened may now say to themselves they do not want to find themselves being questioned by police under caution.”

Scotland Yard has had possession of the information about the targeting of Sienna Miller since August 2006, when Mulcaire was arrested and his records seized, but police failed to say anything about it to Miller until her lawyer, Mark Thomson, of Atkins Thomson, wrote to ask them. Even then an answer was delayed for 14 weeks.

Miller has previously sued the News of the World for invading her privacy. In 2008, the paper settled the claims by paying her damages and sending her a written acknowledgement that they had been wrong to publish stories and photographs about her private life.

Friends of Miller said she had noticed warning signs with her voicemail, including new messages being recorded as old before she had listened to them. For this reason she had changed her mobile number, but the material seized from Mulcaire suggested he had been able to discover her new number. Former staff at the News of the World say Mulcaire was able to obtain confidential information from mobile phone companies and British Telecom.

Miller plans to join the legal action being run by Bindmans law firm to seek a judicial review of Scotland Yard’s failure to warn potential victims of the hacking. She is waiting for Scotland Yard to reply to a letter asking for an explanation of its failure to warn her. Those already involved in the action include John Prescott; Brian Paddick, a former deputy assistant commissioner at Scotland Yard; the Labour frontbench spokesman Chris Bryant; and the investigative journalist Brendan Montague.

Meanwhile it was revealed last night that MPs are to investigate whether parliamentary privileges were breached by Mulcaire. The Commons standards and privileges committee, which has been asked by MPs to investigate the matter, has decided to ask the clerk of the house and outside legal experts to advise on whether phone hacking is a contempt of parliament.