Senior British officials say it was a mistake to allow four African nations to sell 102 tons of stockpiled ivory to China and Japan. The sale, starting in January 2009, was intended to reduce the poaching of elephants by satisfying demand with ivory gathered from animals who had died of natural causes.
South Africa, Zimbabwe, Namibia and Botswana were given CITES permits to sell the ivory for a total of $15.4 million. China and Japan have been releasing it into their domestic markets in annual tranches. But instead of going into decline, poaching has increased faster than ever. Critics say that the sales increased the demand for ivory carvings as a prestige possession and made it difficult for police to tell whether ivory being sold in shops and markets was from a legal or illegal source.
Two of the senior UK officials who backed the sale have now said it was a mistake. John Hounslow, who was head of UK CITES licensing from 2000 to 2011, told the Guardian: “In hindsight, it was a great mistake. It failed to satisfy demand. Indeed, it is difficult to understand now how CITES ever thought it would.” Rob Hepworth, who was directly involved in negotiations, wrote to the last CITES conference, in Bangkok in March 2013, to say the policy had failed, calling on them “to implement an urgent, indefinite and comprehensive ban on ivory trade including domestic markets.”
In contrast to its position on tiger farms, China has made significant moves to shut down its domestic market in ivory. The trigger appears to have been a decision by the US, in November 2013, to publicly crush six tons of seized ivory. Two months later, the Chinese responded by publicly crushing just over six tons. In February 2014, the US announced a ban on all commercial sales of ivory. A year later, the Chinese announced a one-year moratorium on all imports of ivory carvings. Finally in September 2015, the US and China jointly announced their intention to ban all ivory sales although China has yet to put any detail on the plan.
Supplier nations are divided. South Africa has tacitly accepted the change: in the past they have lobbied CITES for the right to sell more ivory but they surprised the NGO community by making no such proposal for this week’s meeting in Johannesburg. Twenty three countries with surviving elephant populations have called for a total ban on all ivory trade in all nations. Nevertheless, Namibia and Zimbabwe have tabled proposals which would allow them to sell more ivory.
ends