Police face unanswered questions about their links to Murdoch

The Guardian, 2 July 2014

It is not only David Cameron and Rupert Murdoch who are caught in the sticky web of the phone-hacking scandal. Scotland Yard too remains tangled in troubling questions which have been revived by evidence disclosed in the Old Bailey trial which ended this week.

The questions remain unanswered because while the Yard’s leadership has run a sprawling inquiry into allegations of crime by journalists and public officials, it has opted not to commission an investigation into what went wrong under its own roof.

All of the questions revolve around Scotland Yard’s five years of failure to deal with allegations of crime in Murdoch’s newsrooms before a new inquiry, Operation Weeting, finally took on the job. The scale of the Yard’s failure to investigate or to disclose what was known was writ large in the evidence which Weeting supplied to the Old Bailey trial.

While the original inquiry named only eight victims of Glenn Mulcaire’s phone-hacking and warned 28 others, Weeting found that Mulcaire’s own hand-written notes suggested that he had targeted 5,500 people either to intercept their voicemail or to ‘blag’ their confidential data. They traced and warned some 3,500 of them. The original inquiry, which had possession of the same notes, arrested only two people. Weeting and its offshoots have now interviewed under caution or arrested 210 people including 101 journalists from six Fleet Street papers.

The central question is whether that failure was in any way connected to the Yard’s links with Murdoch’s UK company, then known as News International; or to any personal links between Yard officers and Murdoch employees. Lord Justice Leveson’s inquiry found no evidence of improper conduct but added that the perception of these links had damaged the reputation of the Metropolitan Police and of some of the Yard personnel who were involved. Leveson limited his inquiry into the issue because of pending police inquiries. Fragments of new evidence from the trial and from Guardian inquiries raise more questions about how the links will be perceived. They fall into two timeframes.

The first covers the period from January 2006 to January 2007 when the Yard ran Operation Caryatid, the original inquiry into a complaint from Buckingham Palace that somebody was listening to the voicemail messages of the royal household. On August 8 2006, Caryatid arrested the News of the World’s royal editor, Clive Goodman, and the paper’s specialist phone-hacker, Glenn Mulcaire.

At the Old Bailey trial, Goodman told the jury that within 48 hours of his arrest, he saw the beginning of a campaign to persuade him to say that he was a ‘lone wolf’ and that nobody else from the paper was involved in any other hacking. This was a lie, as the trial exposed in painful detail. It was also a pointless lie if there was any risk that Scotland Yard would arrest other journalists. But… no other journalists were arrested by Caryatid.

During the trial, Goodman claimed that, following his arrest, his then editor, Andy Coulson, on several occasions suggested that he was directly or indirectly in contact with a source who knew what the police were doing and who was suggesting that they did not want to “go any deeper than me and nobody wanted it to end up in a jail sentence.” Coulson denied saying this. Even if he did, it is possible that he was misleading Goodman in an attempt to persuade him to plead guilty. The question which arises is whether there really was a source who enabled Coulson to know what the police were planning.

On August 16 2006, the assistant commissioner who was responsible for Caryatid, Andy Hayman, went to a social event organised by the Crime Reporters Association (CRA). He was accompanied by the Yard’s director of communications, Dick Fedorcio. A CRA event would normally be attended by crime reporters from all national newspapers. The Leveson inquiry criticised the social contact between senior Yard personnel and News International journalists on the grounds that it “created a perception that was more than capable of undermining public confidence”, but it found no evidence of any improper behaviour by Hayman or Fedorcio.

Six weeks later, on September 15 2006, a News International in-house lawyer, Tom Crone, emailed Coulson with a summary of information which, he said, had been provided to Rebekah Brooks by ‘the cops’. The email – which was disclosed in unredacted form at the trial – included an apparently accurate account of some of the evidence which had been collected by Caryatid and the suggestion that “they are not widening the case to include other NoW people but would do so if they got direct evidence”. The email added that so far the only evidence which detectives had found on journalists other than Goodman was circumstantial.

The trial heard that this message was written as a result of a meeting at the RAC Club between Rebekah Brooks and a Caryatid officer, DCI Keith Surtees, who had been tasked to tell her that her phone had been hacked by Mulcaire and to invite her to make a statement for the prosecution. Brooks declined to do so. The question here is whether Surtees was instructed not simply to ask for her co-operation but also to give her a briefing about Caryatid’s progress and intentions. The Independent Police Complaints Commission investigated and found that Surtees had done nothing wrong. Scotland Yard declined to answer Guardian questions about it.

At around this time, according to evidence at the Leveson inquiry, the Yard decided to close down Caryatid. The precise timing and justification for this decision are not known: it was not recorded in writing. The effect of this was that:

* there was no further inquiry into evidence which Caryatid had gathered which appeared to implicate other News of the World journalists;

* there was no attempt to pursue other evidence which suggested that the News of the World might have been involved in making corrupt payments to police officers including some of those involved in the security of the royal family and of the Witness Protection Programme;

* the Yard breached its undertaking to the Crown Prosecution Service to ensure that ‘all potential victims’ of the phone-hacking were informed.

On October 24 2006, Andy Hayman spent two hours drinking with the deputy editor of the News of the World, Neil Wallis. Lord Justice Leveson found that this had ‘undoubtedly fuelled’ a perception that the failure to pursue Caryatid was a result of the relationship between the Yard and the Murdoch company

On November 29 2006, Goodman and Mulcaire pleaded guilty at the Old Bailey. On that day, according to her evidence to the Leveson inquiry, Rebekah Brooks went to Scotland Yard to meet Dick Fedorcio.

On January 26 2007, Goodman and Mulcaire were sentenced to prison without implicating anybody else at the News of the World.

After examining this history in detail, Lord Justice Leveson concluded that the Caryatid team had made mistakes in handling victims of the hacking and had failed to follow leads to other perpetrators but that they had acted in good faith, primarily because they had to deal with far more serious crime involving terrorist plots to commit mass murder. That conclusion is clearly well-founded. Specifically, there is no evidence that any Caryatid officer showed any fear or favour towards News International.

However, the objective fact is that Scotland Yard’s conduct enabled News International’s cover-up to succeed. Here, there are two key questions. Why was the hacking inquiry not passed to another squad to be completed? And was that decision in any way influenced by a desire to placate Murdoch’s company? Scotland Yard has opted not to try to answer any of these questions.

The second timeframe runs from July 9 2009, when the Guardian published its first story about the true scale of the hacking, to July 2011, when the Guardian disclosed that Milly Dowler had been a victim. Throughout that time, Scotland Yard presented press, public and parliament with a version of events which has proved to be false.

This included repeated denials that the Yard held any evidence that Mulcaire had targeted the deputy Prime Minister John Prescott; repeated claims that they had approached all potential victims of Mulcaire’s hacking; and the claim that they had pursued all available leads. All of these statements subsequently proved to be false. The Yard also failed to disclose that Caryatid had been closed down without completing the original investigation; and that News International had obstructed their work.

The Old Bailey trial disclosed a new fragment of evidence from this timeframe which remains unexplained and unexplored. This involved the celebrity PR Max Clifford, who was one of the eight hacking victims who was named at the sentencing of Goodman and Mulcaire in January 2007. Soon after the Guardian’s first story, in July 2009, Clifford sued the News of the World on the basis that somebody at the paper must have conspired with Glenn Mulcaire to intercept his voicemail.

On September 14 2009, a deputy master in the High Court ordered Scotland Yard to disclose relevant evidence, including the notes which Mulcaire had made as he targeted Clifford. The Yard said that they would do so by November 23. On November 5, the assistant commissioner who had inherited responsibility for the hacking case, John Yates, dined at the Ivy with the then editor of the News of the World, Colin Myler. The Yard missed the deadline for disclosing Mulcaire’s notes and, when they finally did so, on December 7, somebody had blacked out the name of the News of the World journalist who had tasked Mulcaire to hack Clifford as well as much of the rest of the notes.

The fragment of evidence which was disclosed at the Old Bailey trial concerned a meeting which was held at the News of the World’s east London office the following month, on January 20 2010, to discuss the Clifford case. The jury were shown a record of the meeting. This noted that when the police disclosed their evidence on Max Clifford, “there was nothing there.” The record then continued with a remark attributed to Colin Myler: “CM said that Andy Hayman and John Yates had indicated to him previously that this was probably going to be the case.” Contacted by the Guardian recently, Myler declined to comment.

The first question here is whether that record is accurate. It may not be. Andy Hayman had left Scotland Yard in December 2007. An investigation might establish whether Hayman had any means of discovering how the Yard was planning to respond to the order to disclose Mulcaire’s notes about Max Clifford.

Beyond the question of its accuracy, the record of that meeting raises two questions. The first is why Scotland Yard chose to redact Mulcaire’s notes so heavily. The high court subsequently ordered them to produce a less redacted version, although the case was then aborted when Clifford accepted an offer from News International of guaranteed income of £600,000 plus his legal costs. The second is whether Hayman, Yates or anybody else at the Yard provided information about their handling of the case to Colin Myler. Hayman did not reply to recent requests to comment from the Guardian. Yates declined to comment, but friends of his say he would not have had access to the detail of the Clifford case and would not have disclosed anything that was improper at the Ivy dinner or at any other time.

As the Leveson inquiry heard, both Hayman and Yates were in the habit of sharing drinks and meals with journalists, including some from the News of the World. Coulson himself previously has said he was on ‘not unfriendly terms’ with Hayman. Yates counted Coulson’s deputy, Neil Wallis, as a personal friend. As with Hayman, Leveson accepted that Yates had done nothing improper. He added that Yates “had developed an overly close relationship with News International and he should not be surprised if concern is expressed.”

Both Hayman and Yates have been criticised for public comments which they made about the extent of the hacking at the News of the World. This began as a reaction to the Guardian’s first story, on Thursday July 9, when Yates held a press conference outside Scotland Yard. He said he had been asked “to establish the facts” and went on to read a statement which challenged the core of the Guardian account and which has since proved to be misleading. He concluded that no further investigation was required. Two years later, when the scandal reached its climax, Yates apologised for his approach, saying he should have done more and that his decision not to re-open the investigation was ‘pretty crap.’

In the background, after resigning from Scotland Yard, Andy Hayman had gone to work for News International, as a columnist for the Times, who also bought the serial rights to his memoirs. Two days after Yates’s statement, on Saturday July 11, he published a Times column in which he said that Caryatid ‘had left no stone unturned’. He did not mention that the investigation had been closed down without completing the job. He went on to say that Caryatid would have pursued ‘the slightest hint that others were involved.’ The Old Bailey trial disclosed that Caryatid had done the opposite, for example opting not to pursue evidence of the possible involvement of Greg Miskiw and Neville Thurlbeck, who have since pleaded guilty to conspiring to intercept voicemail. Hayman told the Leveson inquiry that he had written his column from memory without having access to any of the original paperwork. Leveson added that Hayman had had little direct knowledge of Caryatid since his role was supervisory.

The following week, on Wednesday July 15, Hayman went to a party to mark Neil Wallis’ departure from the News of the World, held at the Century Club on Shaftesbury Avenue. One of the guests has told the Guardian that Hayman approached Tim Toulmin, the director of the Press Complaints Commission, who was standing by the bar, and said words to the effect that: “I can’t believe this Guardian thing. Such a lot of fuss about it. I have seen the file. There is nothing in there, just a handful of names.” In November, the PCC published a report which accepted the claim that Goodman and Mulcaire were the only culprits and which added that “the Guardian’s stories did not quite live up to the dramatic billing they were initially given.” Hayman did not reply to recent requests from the Guardian to comment on this.

Over the two-year timeframe, Yates repeated his misleading version of events to two House of Commons select committees and visited the Guardian to complain to the editor, Alan Rusbridger, about the paper’s coverage of the scandal. Later, he threatened to sue the Guardian for reporting that he had misled parliament. Yates and Hayman specifically denied that the former deputy prime minister, John Prescott, had been a victim even though Caryatid in August 2006 had found evidence that Mulcaire had been intercepting Prescott’s voicemail from the phone of his special adviser, Joan Hammell.

The home affairs select committee criticised Hayman for his ‘cavalier attitude’ towards his social contact with people from News International who were being investigated by his detectives and suggested this had “risked seriously undermining confidence in the impartiality of the police.” They also accused him of “deliberate prevarication in order to mislead the committee.” Lord Justice Leveson found that Yates had adopted an “inappropriately dismissive and close-minded attitude” to the scandal and had been dogmatic and defensive in comments which he made.

Neither the select committee nor Leveson concluded that Hayman, Yates or anybody else at Scotland Yard had allowed their judgement to be influenced by contact with or fear of News International. Leveson concluded that although there had been “a series of poor decisions, poorly executed”, there was no evidence to challenge the integrity of the senior police officers who had been concerned. On the specific questions which have been raised by the new evidence from the Old Bailey trial, simply there is no evidence at all – no phone records, no diaries, no internal memos, no expenses records, no interviews with the key players – because Scotland Yard has failed to commission the inquiry which might have found it. The questions hang there, looking for an answer.

A Yard spokesman indicated that they expected the outstanding questions to be addressed by the second part of the Leveson inquiry, which is due to be held when all associated legal proceedings have ended. Its proposed terms include inquiring into the way any “relevant police force investigated allegations or evidence of unlawful conduct by persons within or connected with News International.” Some doubt has been cast on whether the second part of the Leveson inquiry will take place.