Inside story of the inquiry which exposed crimes in Fleet Street

The Guardian, 2 July 2014

On January 26 2011, News International passed Scotland Yard three email messages which contained possible evidence of crime. Three and a half years later, the investigation which was launched that day has morphed into 12 separate operations; and some 210 people have been arrested or interviewed under caution about phone-hacking, email-hacking, payments to public officials, accessing data on allegedly stolen phones and perversion of the course of justice.

From that first day, this was not simply an inquiry into allegations of crime but an attempt to rescue Scotland Yard from crisis, to prove that it was capable of taking on the power of Rupert Murdoch’s company where earlier attempts had failed.

The new investigation was codenamed Operation Weeting and given to Deputy Assistant Sue Akers. She got the job because she was one of the few career detectives who was senior enough to deal with its complexity as well as its political sensitivities. What turned out to be more important is that Akers is not somebody who marches in step. In her first posting as a detective, in Fulham in the early 1980s, she had been welcomed with the promise that she could expect her share of ‘brown envelopes’ – cash bribes from local villains. She refused to take them. As a woman, she did not even need to refuse to join one of the masonic lodges which then acted as nests of collusion between police and criminals: women were barred. Over the following 30 years, she became a specialist in investigating murders, never losing a single court case.

Akers immediately opted to base Weeting in a police office block, Jubilee House in Putney, partly because it has special security approved by MI5 and partly because it kept her well away from the machinations of the top brass on the eighth floor of Scotland Yard in Victoria. There, she brought in two detective superintendents – Mark Kandiah to deal with the victims of the News of the World’s phone-hacking, and Mark Ponting to run the investigation. They made a simple agreement: no cover-up. They would go wherever the evidence led them.

Akers had worked with Kandiah before, in the British Overseas Territory of Turks and Caicos, where they had gone with a forensic scientist to solve murders which were upsetting the tourist trade. She knew he had a good brain, which he would need if he was to untangle the mess of information which had been scrawled into notebooks by Glenn Mulcaire as he hacked his targets. Within 48 hours, Akers and Kandiah realised they were going to have to come clean and apologise to hundreds, possibly thousands of people who had never been approached and warned by the original Yard inquiry in 2006 – beginning with the embarrassing task of telling the former deputy prime minister, John Prescott, that contrary to Scotland Yard’s repeated denials, dozens of his voicemail had been intercepted.

For Mark Ponting, the criminal inquiry began in the same place: Mulcaire’s notes together with his computer and some phone-billing data which had been collected by the original inquiry. Like Akers, Ponting had experience of highly complex jobs. He had just emerged from running Operation Rize, which controversially raided 7,000 safety deposit boxes across London, finding a mass of criminal cash, firearms and drugs as well as legitimate property. For Ponting’s team, as for Kandiah’s, it was clear that the original investigation had been flawed.

During February and March, Ponting’s group simply went back to basics, assembling and analysing the material which had been lying in Scotland Yard’s possession since August 2006. They had a lot to learn – the methodology of phone-hacking, the business of ‘blagging’ confidential data, the inner workings of a newpaper. They made a series of break-throughs. They saw that Mulcaire was in the habit of writing the name of the journalist who had commissioned his work in the top left corner of his notes and started to see some names recurring with interesting frequency. They realised that he was hitting targets in groups, that names which meant nothing to them were important to Mulcaire because they were the friends or family of his primary targets. They also found 14 pages of Mulcaire’s notes about hacking Milly Dowler, which had been overlooked by the original inquiry.

They set out to see if they could match Mulcaire’s work with stories which had been published in the News of the World. Using an online cuttings service, they started to fear that some of the stories which were most revealing were being removed from the database, and so they switched to the more reliable but far more time-consuming strategy of sending officers to the newspaper library in Colindale, north London, to squint at years of microfiched backnumbers. By April – still relying largely on evidence which had been in police hands for nearly five years – they started to make arrests. As they did so, they seized more material from the homes and desks of their suspects and ran into a turning point in their relationship with News International.

Since the end of January, Sue Akers and News International’s lawyers had been trying to agree a protocol which would allow Weeting to get access to emails, invoices and other material held by the company. After laborious negotiations about privacy and protection of journalistic sources, they finally signed an agreement on March 25. But the Weeting team concluded that some of the Murdoch lawyers were not being as co-operative as they needed to be. On April 14, Weeting arrested James Weatherup and went to search his desk at the News of the World, only to find that its contents had been bagged up and taken to the offices of one of the paper’s external law firms, Burton Copeland. Ponting telephoned a senior partner, Ian Burton, and threatened to arrest him if he did not hand over the material. Burton complied, although Weeting then interviewed him under caution and sent a file to the CPS, who concluded that there were no grounds to prosecute him.

The side effect of this was that News International withdrew its lawyers from the front line and replaced them with two executives, Will Lewis and Simon Greenberg. More and more doors now opened. Police began to retrieve some of the 300 million emails which had been deleted from the company’s servers and to search them for key words. In June, News International disclosed a collection of email messages which suggested that payments had been made to police in the royal palaces. Mark Kandiah was dispatched to set up a separate inquiry, Operation Elveden. By the end of June, they were scoping a third inquiry, Operation Tuleta, to look into a collection of allegations about email hacking and other access to confidential data. That was headed by a third detective superintendent, John Levett, who had worked with Sue Akers on the highly sensitive investigation into allegations that British intelligence officers had been involved in the torture of terrorist suspects.

Since then, each operation has grown like bindweed. Weeting discovered that a News of the World journalist, Dan Evans, had acted as the paper’s second specialist phone-hacker. Evans agreed to co-operate, making allegations not only about his time at the News of the World but also about his earlier career at the Sunday Mirror. So, two more operations were launched.

Operation Elveden got access to the News International accounts department in Peterborough, which disclosed a history of cash payments which had been made by the Sun through the Thomas Cook agency, some of them to public officials. So Elveden opened a new front, investigating the Sun, finally uncovering more than 400 suspect payments. Operation Tuleta picked up more than 110 allegations of illegal access to data, including claims that ministerial computers had been hacked, eventually spawning five new operations.

However, progress was not easy. The various operations approached dozens of former News of the World journalists, but – other than Dan Evans – none was willing and able to act as an effective witness. And Weeting’s relationship with News International ran into a cul de sac in April 2012 when Akers confirmed that they were seriously pursuing the possibility of charging the company itself. For several weeks, all co-operation ceased and then resumed with the company imposing new boundaries which yielded far less material.

The whole future of Weeting and its linked operations is now in some doubt following the decision of the Old Bailey jury this week to reject phone-hacking charges against Rebekah Brooks and Stuart Kuttner. But even if the CPS abandons all future prosecutions for phone-hacking, there are already a dozen more trials scheduled at the Old Bailey arising from Elveden and Tuleta and potentially still more as prosecutors work their way through the files on the rest of those who have been arrested or interviewed under caution.

Police are now running 12 investigations:

Weeting into allegations of phone-hacking for the News of the World by Glenn Mulcaire;

Pinetree into allegations of phone-hacking for the News of the World by Dan Evans;

Golding into allegations of phone-hacking for Mirror Group Newspapers by Dan Evans;

Elveden into allegations of payments to public officials by the News of the World, Sun, Mirror Group and Star on Sunday;

Tuleta into allegations of email hacking and other illegal access to confidential data;

Carizzo into allegations of illegal access to allegedly stolen mobile phones at the Sun;

Kalmyk into allegations of email hacking for the News of the World and for commercial clients;

Sabinas into allegations of email hacking for the Times;

Cerritos into allegations of email hacking for commercial clients;

Kerrville into allegations of computer hacking in relation to a legal action;

Sacha into allegations of perversion of the course of justice

Rubicon into allegations of perjury, phone-hacking and illegal access to confidential data for the News of the World in Scotland.