March 17 2014 When he was royal editor of the News of the World, Clive Goodman repeatedly told his bosses that he needed cash to pay Palace police officers when, in truth, he was passing the money to other journalists, an Old Bailey jury heard yesterday.
The claim was made by Goodman who also told the court that his former editor Piers Morgan had made “a heartless commercial decision” to deliberately expose the identity of one of the paper’s genuine Palace sources, who was arrested and sacked as a result.
Giving evidence in his defence in the phone-hacking trial, Goodman denied paying royal police officers to obtain three confidential Palace phone directories. He said it was “fairly routine” for journalists to exaggerate the importance of their sources and that he had often done so. “If people thought your sources were more important than they actually were, you stood a much better chance of getting your stories in the paper.”
He said that he had invented false names – Farish and Anderson – for two sources who regularly sold him information and had then requested payments for them in internal emails which described them variously as “one of our Palace cops”, “a man who normally wears a uniform” and “a Buckingham Palace cop”. He told the jury that he had never discovered the real names of either source but he said that he believed Farish was an executive in another newspaper group and that Anderson was probably a freelance journalist.
It was these two sources, he said, who had received payments totally £2,750 for the three confidential directories. Answering questions from his barrister, David Spens QC, Goodman agreed that 25% of the stories credited to Farish and 8% of those credited to Anderson were about Palace police officers. But, he said, he had never paid police for a story: “There is no truth in that whatsover.” The jury has heard that detectives have visited the addresses recorded for Farish and Anderson and been unable to identify them.
Goodman went on to tell the court that one of Prince Charles’ valets, Kenneth Stronach, had been a long-standing source, providing stories initially through his son and then directly to Goodman. Stronach had decided to leave his job and to write a book about his long career at the Palace and he had asked the News of the World to find a publisher who would give him a £1 milllion contract.
Goodman claimed that the then editor, Piers Morgan, and an associate editor, Alex Marunchak, had concluded that the project was too complicated because of confidentiality problems and decided instead to expose Stronach for trying to sell royal secrets. “It was a heartless commercial decision that he would be of little use to them in the future as a contact.”
When the News of the World published its story, royal protection officers had arrested Stronach and threatened to charge him with theft of royal property. They had also tried to interview Goodman. In the event, the former valet had been released without charge and dismissed. “One of the golden rules of newspapers is that you don’t rat on your sources, and that’s exactly what we did do. It was a pretty shameful thing to do.”
At the beginning of yesterday’s proceedings, the judge, Mr Justice Saunders, told the court that he had discharged one of the jurors on grounds of ill health and that the remaining eleven jurors would stay in place.
Clive Goodman denies conspiring to commit misconduct in public office. The trial continues.
March 18 2014
The former royal editor of the News of the World, Clive Goodman, yesterday accused his one time editor and friend Andy Coulson of personally approving a plan for the paper’s specialist phone-hacker to monitor the phones of three members of the royal household.
Goodman also claimed that Coulson read the transcript of a voicemail left by Prince Harry and discussed the detail of stories which had been derived from hacked messages. He said that as editor, Coulson had chaired daily conferences where a senior journalist openly referred to messages that had been left on telephones and to the use of mobile phone data to locate the subject of a story.
After four months of the Old Bailey trial during which he has been seated next to Coulson in the dock, Clive Goodman yesterday sat ten meters across the courtroom in the witness box and told the jury of his own involvement in hacking phones – and of Coulson’s alleged role in it.
He said he had been taught how to intercept voicemail in January 2005 by the then associate editor of the newspaper, Greg Miskiw, who had started listening to Palace phones three years earlier but had begun to find it “tiresome” to do so himself. Then in October 2005, he had been contacted by the paper’s specialist hacker, Glenn Mulcaire, who was worried that his £2,000 a week retainer was going to be cut. “He was looking to make up this shortfall. Through Greg he clearly knew that I had been monitoring some royal voicemail.”
Mulcaire had suggested that if Goodman chose three royal staff, he could provide their phone data, hinting that he could obtain this from the security service who were already monitoring Palace phones. Goodman told the court he took the offer to Coulson. The jury has heard that the two men had known each other since the late 1990s and were guests at each other’s weddings. “I said that Greg’s old contact, Glenn Mulcaire, had offered to monitor three royal phones for us. He would give us direct dial numbers and PINs. He would monitor them… I did say that there was a suggestion that this was feedback from the security services but I didn’t put any strength of belief behind that.”
Coulson had agreed that for a two-month trial period, they would pay Mulcaire £500 a week for the project. The money was paid in cash and with the recipient recorded internally under a false name, David Alexander. Goodman had told Mulcaire to target three aides who worked closely with Prince William and Prince Harry. Soon he was reporting back to Coulson, according to emails shown to the jury: “That new project is getting results.” Goodman claimed that Coulson asked him to “pop in” to his office, where they had discussed the project and how it was going. After two months, Goodman emailed Coulson: “Got a second on extending the Matey file please?” Coulson emailed back: “Another month.”
Early that December, Goodman told the court, he had recorded Prince Harry, who was then a cadet at Sandhurst, leaving a message for his private secretary, Jamie Lowther-Pinkerton, asking him for help on an essay about the 1980 Iranian Embassy siege. He had shown a transcript of the message to Coulson, he said. He and Coulson had then exchanged a series of emails as Goodman attempted to confirm the story without revealing its source to the Palace. In one message, Goodman told Coulson “As we know it is 100% fact” and had then gone on to tell him that in dealing with the Palace, he would not say that he knew the subject of the prince’sessay. “I think that’s too precise to get through unnoticed,” he wrote.
Goodman said that during this time the newsroom of the paper was engaged in hacking “on a pretty industrial scale.” As royal editor, he had attended the daily conference chaired by Andy Coulson where, he claimed, the subject of phones had often come up in discussion. He said that one senior journalist, Mr A, had been in the habit of referring to the telephone traffic between the subjects of stories and to the ‘Friends and Family’ numbers of some targets. Mr A had also referred to voicemail in conference: “It would be a story about a couple: ‘We had a great message last night from him to her or her to him.'”
He told the jury that Coulson had banned talk of phones in conference after Mr A spoke openly about the possibility of locating the target of a story by ‘triangulating’ the signal from his mobile phone. “After that Andy said ‘That’s enough of that. You’re not talking about this in conference any more.'”
Goodman said that Mr A had been using Mulcaire to hack the mobile phones of Andy Coulson and also of Rebekah Brooks, then editing the Sun, in an attempt to steal other reporters’ stories and “to find out what the Sun were up to.”
The jury were shown an email which Goodman wrote to Coulson on February 3 2006 after he learned that Coulson had decided to end “Matey’s weekly payment.” In the message, he listed the stories which Mulcaire had delivered in the previous eight weeks: “This information isn’t manageable on a story by story basis. There are costs for Matey in setting it up and maintaining it, which he has to cover. A few weeks ago, you asked me to find new ways of getting into the family, especially William and Harry, and I came up with this. Safe, productive and cost-effective. And I’m confident it will become a story gold mine for us if we let it run for just a little longer.”
Coulson, however, was unmoved and replied: “I’m sorry but it has to go.” By that time, the court was told, Coulson had authorised 15 payments of £500 from his editorial management budget. Goodman had requested the money in memos to the managing editor, Stuart Kuttner, in which he referred to “a source whose details are known to the newspaper but whose identity is security sensitive and must be protected.”
Mulcaire had continued to monitor the three royal phones, Goodman said, being paid a total of £4,800 over the following six months on a story-by-story basis. The jury were shown emails in which Coulson queried the source of stories. Goodman had replied that one was “from the source we had on a retainer: we absolutely know it to be true.” And that another was from “that fella who used to be on a monthly retainer”, adding that a quote from Prince William were “his exact words”.
Andy Coulson and Stuart Kuttner deny conspiring with Clive Goodman and others to intercept communications. Andy Coulson and Clive Goodman deny conspiring to commit misconduct in public office.
March 19 2014
Andy Coulson suggested he was in contact with police and using his influence to keep his royal editor Clive Goodman out of prison after he was arrested for phone-hacking in 2006, an Old Bailey jury heard yesterday.
Goodman made the claim as he told the court that he had felt threatened by a News International lawyer who had told him he could keep his job if he agreed to say nothing about the involvement in hacking of others at the News of the World. He said that his own solicitor, Henri Brandman, who was being paid by the company, had also advised him not to name names.
Goodman told the jury that, following his arrest on Tuesday August 8 2006, he had been distraught when he saw the enormity of the case which detectives had assembled against himself and the News of the World’s specialist phone-hacker, Glenn Mulcaire. “I was immensely worried that I was going to be blamed for all of Glenn’s activities and so I told Henri that that wasn’t the case, that lots of people from the News of the World were doing this. I just happened to be the one that got caught.”
He had been surprised the next day when Brandman had suggested that his line of defence should be: “Under stress and some kind of lone wolf.” He told the jury: “I knew he was there to represent me, but he was being paid by News International and I had a pretty strong feeling that everything I said would probably go straight back to them.”
On Thursday August 10, he had received a phone call from Andy Coulson which had left him feeling disturbed and worried that he was being “bounced into pleading guilty.” He said Coulson had given him the impression that he had been discussing the case with the police or the Home Office, suggesting that they had no intention of seeking a prison sentence as long as he pleaded guilty and got the case out of the way quickly.
That same day, he had gone to an Internet cafe, created a new Hotmail address and accessed his email account at News International: “I felt at risk of being passed off as Glenn Mulcaire’s only conspirator. I was seeking email that would prove that others were involved and that Andy knew what was going on.”
On the following Monday, August 14, he had agreed to meet Coulson in a Cafe Rouge near his home in Wimbledon. Coulson again urged him to plead guilty, he said. “He expressed the view that through his and the newspaper’s contacts that he had discovered that the police didn’t want the case to go any deeper than me and Mr Mulcaire, and nobody wanted it to end up in a jail sentence. There was a clear suggestion his influence somehow had arranged for me not to go prison.”
Coulson had told him he could keep his job and that, if he did get a prison sentence, the paper would continue to pay him and would look after his wife and daughter. David Spens QC asked him: “Was that dependant on anything?”
Goodman replied: “Keeping silent.”
“About?”
“The involvement of others.”
Goodman said he had already hired a specialist employment lawyer “because I couldn’t really ask Henri Brandman because I thought he was representing News International as well.” In the meeting at the Cafe Rouge, he noticed that Coulson seemed to have a lot of detail about the criminal case against him. “The only way he could have got that was from Mr Brandman. He was supposed to be working for me, not for the paper. I thought it was not quite right that he should be telling the paper what I was telling him.”
And then, he claimed, Coulson had given him some advice: “All you’ve got to say is that you’re a lone wolf.” That had “really put the fear of God” into him, because it was exactly what Brandman had already suggested.
During November, Goodman said, he had drafted a Proof of Evidence for his court case in which he had implicated senior executives, including Andy Coulson, in knowledge and approval of phone hacking. However, Henri Brandman had advised him that a judge “would not take a benign view of someone who thrashed around blaming everybody else.” Goodman said he had not known whether Brandman was giving him his own point of view or News International’s. But eventually he had agreed to remove the references.
In the first week of November, a News International lawyer had asked to see the 2,000 pages of evidence which had been served on him by prosecutors. Goodman said he did not want to hand it over, because he did not trust the company. He had then discovered that Brandman had gone ahead and supplied the material to the lawyer. “It was the exact opposite of my instructions,” he said.
The same News International lawyer had attended Goodman’s meetings with Brandman and with his barrister, John Kelsey-Fry QC, and had told him several times that he could keep his job at the News of the World only if he agreed not to name others who were involved in the hacking. Following one such meeting, Goodman emailed Brandman, complaining that the presence of the News International lawyer had been “unhelpful” and that he had delivered “a fairly crude carrot and stick from the NoW…. I found the attempt to dictate lines of our defence highly inappropriate and just a bit shocking. I felt more threatened by the message that he was asked to deliver than I have by much of the prosecution case.”
Clive Goodman and Andy Coulson deny conspiring to commit misconduct in public office. Andy Coulson and Stuart Kuttner deny conspiring to intercept voicemail.
March 20 2014
The former royal editor of the News of the World, Clive Goodman, yesterday denied colluding with the paper’s specialist phone hacker, Glenn Mulcaire, to steal money from the paper.
Goodman has told an Old Bailey jury that in October 2005 the then editor of the paper, Andy Coulson, personally agreed to pay Mulcaire £500 a week in cash to ‘monitor’ the phones of three members of the royal household. The payments were to be recorded under a false name, David Alexander, with a false address, he said.
Questioned yesterday by Coulson’s barrister, Timothy Langdale QC, Goodman said that each week he would collect the £500 from the office cashier and then meet Mulcaire somewhere near the office, quite often in his car, to hand it over.
Langdale asked him whether he had ever paid money direct into Mulcaire’s bank account. Goodman said he did not recall that.
“Had you come to some arrangement with Mr Mulcaire about getting some of the proceeds of the Alexander project for yourself?”
Goodman replied: “That’s untrue.”
Langdale asked Goodman to explain why it was that for a 28-month period when he was regularly claiming cash for three other anonymous sources, his personal account at Lloyds Bank showed no record of his withdrawing any cash for himself. Goodman replied that this coincided with his getting married and having his first child. “I lived a much more quiet life because things had changed.” He said he had spent less and got cash back when he made payments at the supermarket or the garage.
Langdale asked him: “Did you keep for yourself any of the money that you got from the News of the World?”
“No. I did not,” he replied.
Langdale asked if it was a coincidence that payments to all three anonymous sources had ended in March and April 2006, when the newspaper introduced tighter rules on cash payments. Goodman said he did not know: “I’m sorry. I don’t have an answer for you.” Langdale asked if it was a coincidence that he had resumed drawing cash from his Lloyds account in June 2006. Goodman replied: “You are talking about events that are two months apart so I don’t see the connection.”
Questioned about a story which he had written about minor injuries sustained by Prince Harry, Goodman told the jury that the information had come from a voicemail which had been hacked from the mobile phone of the prince’s personal secretary, Helen Asprey. Langdale then asked him why it was that a schedule of his payments to contributors showed that for the same story, he had claimed £700 in cash for an anonymous source recorded internally under the alias Ian Anderson. Goodman has told the jury that Anderson was a freelance journalist.
Goodman replied that the Anderson alias was sometimes used to pay other contributors and that, on this occasion, Mulcaire’s handler, the assistant editor, Greg Miskiw, thought Mulcaire should be given something in addition to his regular payment of £2,000 a week because the hack was “above and beyond his duties.”
Langdale said: “How can it possibly be above and beyond a hacker’s duties to hack Helen Asprey’s phone?”
“You’d have to ask Greg,” replied Goodman.
Langdale suggested that his answer was a fiction: “This was a device where you could get £700 out of the News of the World in cash when in fact the source of the story was a hacked voicemail message.”
“No. That’s not true.”
Langdale asked why Goodman had authorised five cash payments for up to £650 for another anonymous source, recorded internally with the alias Alec Hall, for information which, the court heard, had already appeared in other newspapers or magazines. Goodman said that Hall was a reporter working for another newspaper, which would not be interested in these particular stories, and that he was paying Hall for spotting and packaging the information. “It’s the sort of thing that is done all the time,”he added.
Clive Goodman and Andy Coulson deny conspiring to commit misconduct in public office. Coulson also denies conspiring with Goodman and others to intercept communications. The trial continues.
ends