Phone-hacking trial reports w/c March 10 2014

The Guardian, 10 March 2014

March 10 2014        It did not occur to Rebekah Brooks that a “military contact” for whom she authorised more than £80,000 of payments over a five-year period might be a public official and, therefore, that the payments might be illegal, an Old Bailey jury heard yesterday.

In her eleventh day in the witness box, Brooks was challenged by the prosecution to explain a series of emails, written between 2004 and 2009, when she was editing the Sun, in which a journalist asked her to authorise the payments for his “number one military contact” and his “ace military contact.” The court has heard that the cash was received by a public official at the Ministry of Defence, named as Bettina Jordan-Barber.

Cross-examined by Andrew Edis QC for the Crown, Brooks said repeatedly that she had not known the identity of the source and suggested that it could have been a retired military figure or a journalist: “I didn’t think that ‘my number one military contact’ or ‘my ace military contact’ was a public official.”

She agreed with Edis that the source was providing stories which were located all over the world, that they often involved military discipline and that all of them turned out to be true. “It doesn’t sound like it’s a man in a pub in Aldershot,” he said.

Brooks said that the journalist who was dealing with the source was experienced and very well connected in the military: “I did not assume that he was paying a public official.”

She said she had never asked the journalist to name the source, nor had she asked what category of person it was. Edis put it to her: “You really were just acting as a rubber stamp, weren’t you?”

“Yes,” she said.

Edis suggested that this was because she knew where the money was going, that this was the source that brought in the best stories. “It’s not likely to be a retired colonel, is it?”

“It could have been a retired colonel,” she said. “I didn’t know who this source was but, because of the way the military works, we often had senior ex military people writing and being involved in the paper.”

She repeated that she had relied on her knowledge of the journalist involved who was very well connected in military circles. Edis said: “You decided not to do your job because you thought he was doing his?” She had asked lots of questions about stories, she said: “What I didn’t do is read these emails and assume that there was potential criminality involved.”

Edis suggested that there was an obvious risk that it was a public official who was receiving the cash. “I think if you read the emails all together, I accept that,” she replied. “But that’s not how I read them.”

Edis said that during 2009 there were six emails about payments and suggested that she had a good memory. She replied: “Sometimes at the Sun – I kid you not – people would ask me what we splashed on last week, and I couldn’t remember.”

Brooks agreed that a selection of the stories which were mentioned in the emails were not stories which could be justified in the public interest. She said: “I would not have authorised these payments to a public official because they didn’t pass the ‘public interest’ test.” Edis asked her whether in any of the emails anybody ever mentioned the public interest. “No,” she said.

The trial judge, Mr Justice Saunders, asked her to clarify whether she was saying that she had thought about the source and assumed that it could not be a public official or whether she was saying that it had never occurred to her that the source might be a public official. “It didn’t occur to me,” she said.

Rebekah Brooks denies conspiring to commit misconduct in public office. The trial continues.

 

March 11 2014

Senior executives at the News of the World tasked the specialist phone-hacker Glenn Mulcaire on a series of stories about paedophiles and murdered children but never told their editor that they had done so, an Old Bailey jury heard yesterday.

In her twelfth day in the witness box, Rebekah Brooks agreed with prosecuting counsel Andrew Edis QC that, as an editor, her ‘agenda’ had focussed on paedophiles and sex offenders but she said repeatedly that she had never heard Mulcaire’s name until he was arrested in August 2006, three years after her editorship.

Edis asked her about notes kept by Mulcaire which suggested that the paper’s assistant editor, Greg Miskiw, and four other journalists had tasked him to locate convicted child sex offenders from the summer of 2000 when Brooks was publishing the names and addresses of convicted paedophiles. “Did any of them tell you where they were getting their information from?” he asked.

“No,” she replied.

The prosecutor went on to ask her about other notes suggesting that in September 2002, both Greg Miskiw and the news editor, Neville Thurlbeck, had tasked Mulcaire in relation to the murder in Soham of Jessica Chapman and Holly Wells.This was “something which is directly part of your agenda,” he suggested.

Thurlebeck had asked Mulcaire to investigate two detectives from the Soham inquiry who had been accused of downloading child pornography. “Did you know about that?”

“No,”she replied. “I don’t remember that.”

Miskiw had asked Mulcaire to target the sister of Maxine Carr, who had been arrested for perverting the course of justice. “Did you know that Glenn Mulcaire had been tasked apparently to hack Maxine Carr’s sister’s phone.”

“No,” she said. “I didn’t.”

Edis also challenged her over the hacking in April 2002 of the voicemail of Milly Dowler. The court has heard that Brooks was on holiday in Dubai in the week when Mulcaire intercepted a message suggesting that the missing schoolgirl was alive and possibly working at a factory in Telford.

Brooks agreed that she had been “extremely interested” in the missing girl and that the paper had run stories about her for the three weeks before she went to Dubai. Edis suggested that she would have wanted to “keep it under review” while she was away. She replied: “The problem is that it’s impossible to be in control of the newspaper – certainly back then – when you go away. I don’t remember saying to anybody ‘Keep in touch over Missing Milly.'”

Edis asked her about an email written during that week by her managing editor, Stuart Kuttner, asking Surrey police for details about convicted sex offenders who lived near Milly Dowler’s home. “I don’t remember saying to Stuart Kuttner ‘Please investigate paedophiles in the community.’ I don’t remember having that conversation but it’s possible.”

She agreed that if the paper had found the missing girl alive, it would have been a big story, which would have made the front page. She was told that the paper had sent five or six journalists to Telford to investigate and agreed that this was “quite a lot” of staff. She was shown phone records which showed she had called the editor’s desk from Dubai twice on the Thursday of the week and three times on the Friday, including one call which lasted 38 minutes. Edis asked her if the acting editor, Andy Coulson, had told her about the story.

“No. He didn’t.”

“Did anyone?”

“No.”

She said she did not recall having any conversation about Milly Dowler while she was in Dubai. The following week she had returned to the office. “Did nobody tell you at all what had happened while you were away?” Edis asked. “I don’t remember any conversation,” she replied. She added that she did not believe that Stuart Kuttner had mentioned that he had contacted Surrey police to ask them about the contents of the voicemail. “Nobody told me we had accessed Milly Dowler’s voicemail.”

Mr Edis said: “You say all this was hidden from you?”

“I did not know that Glenn Mulcaire worked under my editorship until 2006.”

“It was hidden from you by Greg Miskiw?”

“He did not tell me that he had a private detective called Glenn Mulcaire working for me.”

“You weren’t told by Mr Thurlbeck?”

“No.”

“By Mr Kuttner?”

“No.”

“Nobody told you anything?”

“People told me an awful lot. I was the editor but I had not heard Glenn Mulcaire’s name until he was arrested in 2006.”

Glenn Mulcaire, Greg Miskiw and Neville Thurlbeck have pleaded guilty to conspiring to intercept communications. Rebekah Brooks, Andy Coulson and Stuart Kuttner deny a similar charge. The trial continues.

 

March 12 2014

Rebekah Brooks yesterday rejected a claim that her 13 days of evidence in the witness box at the phone-hacking trial have been “a carefully prepared and presented script that bears little relation to the truth.”

The claim came on a day when the court heard how Brooks’ final week as chief executive of News International in July 2011 saw her receiving a stream of supportive text messages from Tony Blair while she contemplated seeking further advice from Lord Mandelson.

Ending his cross-examination of Brooks yesterday, Andrew Edis QC suggested that her 20-year career at News International had been a “meteoric rise in… a really tough world” during which she had tried to get the best stories. “And you didn’t much care how you got them.”

“That’s absolutely not true,” she replied.

“Getting them was what mattered to you. Is that fair or not?”

“It’s not fair.”

He challenged her over the detail of the three offences with which she is charged.
On phone-hacking, she said that two of her executives at the News of the World – Greg Miskiw and Neville Thurlbeck – had never told her of the existence of the paper’s specialist phone-hacker, Glenn Mulcaire. And that her managing editor, Stuart Kuttner, had never told her of the paper’s annual contract with Mulcaire.

On the charge that while editing the Sun she approved payments which were received by a source at the Ministry of Defence, she said that the journalist who asked for the payments had never told her that the source was a public official. She agreed that he should have told her.

On two charges that as chief executive of News International in July 2011, she conspired to hide or destroy evidence, she said she not known that her PA, Cheryl Carter, had removed from the company archive seven boxes which, the Crown claim, contained 12 years of her notebooks; and that she had not known that her husband, Charlie, had given some of his belongings to security staff before police searched their homes. “You were completely unaware of everything?” asked Edis. “Yes” she said.

“I’m going to suggest to you that that is quite untrue,” Edis continued.”You were running your world – and not much happened in it that you didn’t want to happen. Is that right? You were the boss?”

“I was the CEO.”

“And before that you were the editor.”

“Yes.”

“You were very much aware of what these people were doing?”

“Which people?”

“Kuttner. Thurlbeck, Miskiw. Cheryl Carter. The journalist from the Sun. Even your husband. All these people.”

“That’s not true.”

“In fact, Mrs Brooks, your evidence, I’m going to suggest to you, has been a carefully prepared and presented script that bears little relation to the truth about these offences.”

“It has not,” she said.

Earlier, the court heard that as the hacking scandal came to a head in July 2011, Brooks exchanged a sequence of messages with Tony Blair. On the evening of Sunday July 10, with the final edition of the News of the World on sale, Blair flew into Washington DC and texted her: “Hi it’s Tony. I’ve just landed. Is it too late to speak or should we stick with tomorrow?” She replied that they should speak the next day, then adding a second message: “Can’t wait xx.”

The jury has heard previously that on the following day, Monday July 11, she spent an hour on the phone with Blair, after which she emailed James Murdoch to report that the former prime minister was suggesting that they should set up a ‘Hutton-style inquiry’ and was offering to advise them generally on a ‘between us’ basis.

During the rest of the week, the court heard yesterday, Blair texted again on the Tuesday: “I’m in the Mid East. Call me when you can. Tx.” Again on the Friday, when Brooks announced that she was resigning from News International: “I’m really sorry about it all. Call me if you need to. Tx.” And again on the Saturday, as she prepared to give evidence the following week to the House of Commons media select committee: “If you’re still going to Parliament, you should call me. I have experience of these things! Tx.” She replied five minutes later “Definitely.”

The court has heard that by Saturday, Brooks knew that she was to be interviewed by police on the following day. She continued the text exchange, telling Blair: “Feeling properly terrified! Police are behaving so badly.” He replied: “Everyone panics in these situations and they will feel they have their reputation to recover.” Then he added: “I’m no use on police stuff but call me after that because I may be some help on Commons.” “Great,” she replied. “Will do.”

The court heard that in preparation for their appearance before the select committee, Rupert Murdoch, James Murdoch and Brooks planned to have a full rehearsal and that Brooks had wanted to ask Lord Mandelson to help with “mock sessions”. In the event, however, her arrest and questioning by police had prevented that happening.

Rebekah Brooks denies conspiring to intercept communications, commit misconduct in public office and pervert the course of justice. The trial continues.

 

March 13 2014

Princess Diana sent the News of the World a confidential Palace phone book and then personally called the paper’s royal editor, Clive Goodman, to recruit him as an ally against Prince Charles, an Old Bailey jury heard yesterday.

The claim was made by Goodman as he went into the witness box and spoke of bullying he had suffered at the hands of his editor, Andy Coulson, and of a newsroom which was so riven with internal rivalry that one senior journalist sabotaged an important undercover investigation by a colleague while another hired a private investigator to identify one of Goodman’s secret contacts.

The jury has heard that when Goodman was originally arrested for phone-hacking in August 2006, police found 15 royal phone directories in his home. He is now charged with obtaining three of them illegally by paying a public official. Goodman said that one of those which is not covered by the charges arrived in his pigeon hole in an envelope which was addressed to him by name.

Shortly afterwards, he told the court, the Princess of Wales phoned to ask if he had received it. He said he was not the only reporter to whom she spoke. She was “very close” to Richard Kay from the Daily Mail and to Andrew Moreton who went on to write a biography of her, he claimed.

“She was at the time going through a very very tough time. She told me she wanted me to see this document to see the scale of her husband’s staff and household compared to the scale of hers. She was in a very bitter situation with the Prince of Wales at the time. She felt she was being swamped by the people close to him in the household. She was looking for an ally to take him on, to show just the kind of forces that were ranged against her, to put the press on her side. We were quite a powerful organisation.”

Goodman said that two of the other directories which are not covered by the charges had been given to him by a senior valet to Prince Charles, whom he identified as Kenneth Stronach. He told the court that Stronach’s son had started selling him royal stories on his father’s behalf but that the valet had then started to deal with him direct. He had been hoping to negotiate a book deal and provided the directories as a sign of good will. “It became clear that he was thoroughly fed up with working for the royal family and for the Prince of Wales in particular.”

Goodman told the jury that he had been “well thought of” as the paper’s assistant editor, specialising in royal coverage, until Andy Coulson took over as editor in January 2003. Previously, he said, he had got on well with Coulson. “Then my relationship with him changed. He became more aggressive, more combative, more bullying.” The culture of the paper under Coulson had been “extraordinarily competitive, very fast, quite bullying and menacing.”

He said one senior journalist had sidled up to him after a conference at the beginning of the working week and told him his ideas were not good enough: “Listen, Clive. It’s a big story, or the Big Issue.” This same journalist, he claimed, was so competitive that when he heard that the paper’s undercover specialist, Mazher Mahmood, was planning to expose a famous model who was working as a prositute, he had secretly called the model’s agent to warn her. In the same way, he said, one of the executives, Alex Marunchak, had hired a company called Southern Investigations to follow him in the hope of identifying one of his contacts so that he could either blackmail the contact into working for him or else simply expose him as a source.

Under the new editor, he personally suffered a series of three demotions, he said. First, he had been ‘downgraded’ by Coulson’s deputy, Neil Wallis, who did not like his work or the way he did it. “He came up in the 1980s under Kelvin Mackenzie at the Sun – everybody shouted all the time and screamed at each other. Very very aggressive. That was part of the Neil Wallis approach to journalism. Full stop.” The result, he claimed, was that in the ‘pecking order’ in daily conferences, instead of being allowed to speak third or fourth, he found himself relegated to speak “after Jamie Oliver’s recipes” or not at all.

Then he had been told he could no longer work direct for the editor but must take orders from the news desk and then, when he was unable to go on a royal trip to the United States, Coulson had been “very cross” with him and had appointed a new royal reporter, Ryan Sabey, who was given the job of covering the younger members of the royal family, including Prince William and Prince Harry. “That was 40 to 60% of royal coverage. It left me wondering where I was.”

Coulson had often berated him for the quality of his stories and had excluded him from the leader-writers conference although he was supposed to be one of the leader writers. “These things sound petty,” he told the jury, “but they were meant to degrade you in the eyes of the people at the paper.”

Clive Goodman and Andy Coulson deny two counts of conspiring to commit misconduct in public office. The trial continues.

ends