March 3 2014 Rebekah Brooks secretly met Andy Coulson to warn him about ‘incriminating evidence’ of phone hacking a week before Coulson resigned as the Prime Minister’s director of communications, the Old Bailey heard yesterday.
Brooks told the jury in the phone-hacking trial that an internal search of emails in January 2011 had disclosed three messages which showed that a News of the World journalist was “fully engaged” in the interception of voicemail. She had asked her personal assistant to arrange for her to meet Coulson early on the morning of January 14, specifying that the location should be ‘discreet’.
She said she had called the meeting after months of civil litigation in which public figures had been suing News International for allegedly intercepting their voicemail during 2005/6 when Coulson was editing the News of the World. “It was to tell Andy that we had found some pretty incriminating evidence. It was with the backdrop of the previous few months as well. It was evidently becoming very difficult for Andy’s position in Downing Street with this ongoing civil litigation process… It was a very difficult balance between running the communications for Downing Street and being part of the story.” The jury have heard that Coulson resigned seven days later.
In her eighth day in the witness box, Brooks traced the gathering crisis as the disclosure of the three incriminating messages led to the creation of the Operation Weeting police inquiry. As that inquiry began, on January 26, she arranged for her office to be swept for bugs. She did this, she said, because her Blackberry was behaving oddly and because so much information seemed to be leaking. “It probably sounds paranoid,” she said, “but maybe that’s the world we lived in… The level of paranoia was quite high. My own revolved about secrecy and privacy. Everything seemed to leak in some form or another. It got worse and worse.”
By April, for the first time, she was warned that she might be arrested. She was on holiday in Barbados, she said, when she had a telephone conference to discuss the arrest on April 14 of the News of the World’s former news editor, James Weatherup. She was told that the police were very angry and were threatening to take action against one of their lawyers, Ian Burton of Burton Copeland, because he had advised the paper to clear Weatherup’s desk before they had a chance to search it. “I was told that the team dealing with the Metropolitan Police believed that I could be arrested on my return.”
At around this time, she told the jury, she had learned that the head of Operation Weeting, Deputy Assistant Commissioner Sue Akers, had asked for her to be removed from the ‘confidentiality club’ of News International personnel who were allowed to read documents being disclosed in the civil actions. When she returned from Barbados, she had sought legal advice from a London law firm.
By June, she disclosed, the company were already considering closing down the News of the World – at least a month before the Milly Dowler crisis – in the hope that this would help Rupert Murdoch’s bid to take over BSkyB.
The jury were told of an email, written by the company’s director of public affairs, Simon Greenberg, in early June 2011, as News Corp sought to complete the take over, which was known internally as Operation Rubicon. Reacting to an allegation that the News of the World had been involved in hacking computers as well as voicemail, Greenberg wrote: “This is why we should consider the shut-down option. Is the brand too toxic for itself and for us? Unparalleled moments need unparalleled acts. Showing we get it, is important for us and for Rubicon.”
Brooks said that she had previously discussed the possibility of closing the paper with Greenberg and with the company’s general manager, Will Lewis. The shut down was eventually announced on July 7 following the disclosure that it had been involved in hacking the voicemail of the murdered schoolgirl Milly Dowler.
Rebekah Brooks denies conspiring to intercept voicemail. The trial continues.
March 4 2014
Rebekah Brooks yesterday recalled the moment when she “lost it” after her husband Charlie told her the “very odd story” of how he was facing arrest as a result of hiding two laptops and his collection of pornography behind rubbish bins in the underground car park beneath their London flat.
She told the phone-hacking trial that the incident came at the end of a fortnight of turmoil in July 2011 during which she closed the News of the World, resigned her job and spent 12 hours in police custody while, in the background, Tony Blair and Piers Morgan texted her messages of support and Michael Gove said he was keen to see her.
Answering questions from her barrister, Jonathan Laidlaw QC, she said she had not hidden any of her own electronic devices from the police when she was arrested on Sunday July 17 and had not realised that her husband had hidden his own until the following day. She had gone to sleep in their London flat that lunch time, she said, and woken a few hours later to be confronted with his story.
“In summary he said that he had given his bags to security – his mobile office basically, and there had been a mix-up over them. It sounded like a very odd story – and then he had put them here, and then they had taken them there. He pretty much told me everything at that point and said that he had hidden his rather large porn collection. I was quite exasperated. He then said to me that the police had found his bags by the bins. He had been talking to lawyers while I was asleep and he told me there was a chance of him being arrested. It sounded like a monumental cock-up.
“The idea that the police were going to arrest him! I had just been arrested. I was about to face Parliament. I did understand how important his horse business and his novel was. It was this rather complicated story, and the police were now threatening to arrest him. It just seemed the final straw in what had been quite a cataclysmic few days.”
The turmoil had begun, she told the jury, on the afternoon of Monday July 4 when she was attending a fertility clinic and received an email to tell her that the Guardian had published a story claiming that the News of the World had hacked the voicemail of the murdered Surrey schoolgirl, Milly Dowler, when she was editing the paper, in April 2002.
She said she had no way of knowing whether there was any truth in the story, which included the claim that the News of the World had deleted some messages and given the missing girl’s mother false hope that she was alive, a claim which was subsequently shown to be incorrect. “We were completely at a loss, all over the place, trying to find out what was true and what wasn’t.” The court has heard that the paper’s specialist phone-hacker, Glenn Mulcaire, has pleaded guilty to intercepting Milly Dowler’s voicemail.
That evening, she had exchanged texts with Piers Morgan, one of her predecessors as editor of the News of the World. “When it rains, it fucking pours,” he wrote. “Grit your teeth and stay strong.”
“Terrible,” she replied. “Made me feel sick watching the news. Can’t believe any reporter would do that. Must have been Mulcaire.”
“It wasn’t a staffer. You have got to get that out there fast. Lots of fury building on the Internet.”
“Will do. We are taking the usual News Corp tin hat approach.”
In the early hours of the following morning, Morgan texted again: “You’re trending worldwide on Twitter. Congrats.”
Later that day, Tony Blair texted her: “Let me know if there’s anything I can help you with. Thinking of you. I have been through things like this.”
“Thank you,” she replied.”I know what it’s like. GB (Gordon Brown) pals getting their own back.”
Michael Gove had then emailed, the court heard, to say that he was very keen to catch up with her, although Brooks had had to cancel a series of hospitality events at Wembley to which Gove and his wife had been invited.
On the Friday of that week, July 8, the prosecution claim, Brooks asked her PA, Cheryl Carter, to get rid of seven boxes containing 12 years of her notebooks by removing them from the company archive and destroying them. Brooks told the court that she had not generally used notebooks since becoming a features editor in 1995 and that she had never used the company archive at all. She said Cheryl Carter was brilliant but ‘scatty and forgetful” and cited a day when the PA had told Rupert Murdoch that Brooks was unable to speak to him because she was in the bargain furniture store, MFI. In reality, Brooks said, she had asked Carter to tell the proprietor that she was in a briefing with the security service, MI5.
Mr Laidlaw asked her if she would trust somebody scatty to help her conspire to pervert the course of justice. “No,” she replied. “But also because she is an incredibly decent and hard-working woman. She wouldn’t do it, not just because she’s scatty – which she is – but because she is true.”
Rebekah Brooks denies charges of conspiring to intercept communications and conspiring to pervert the course of justice. The trial continues.
March 5 2014
Rebekah Brooks never asked anybody what the News of the World’s specialist phone-hacker Glenn Mulcaire had been doing under her editorship at the paper, the Old Bailey heard yesterday. “I know it sounds ridiculous,” she told the jury.
Cross-examined by Andrew Edis QC, for the prosecution, Brooks agreed that she had become chief executive of News International in September 2009, two months after the Guardian had claimed that the company had paid £1 million to the chief executive of the Professional Footballers Association, Gordon Taylor, to suppress evidence of hacking at the News of the World. She said she had run no investigation because it had already been done. “There wasn’t a need for me to do an investigation.”
She then agreed that in February 2010, she had agreed to pay about £1 million to stop the celebrity PR agent Max Clifford suing over the hacking of his voicemail. The court has heard that the case was threatening to compel Glenn Mulcaire to identify journalists who had commissioned him. “I accept the motive, the objective was to stop Mulcaire naming names in the case,” she said.
She said she understood that Mulcaire had worked for the paper under her editorship, adding that she assumed that he was engaged in legitimate work. Edis asked her: “Did you ask anybody what he had been doing during your editorship?”
“Not specifically, no,” she replied. Edis suggested to her that she must have realised that there was a risk that he had been hacking phones during that time.
“I know it sounds ridiculous. I didn’t have any concern for my editorship. I didn’t think that it had happened. I didn’t believe it had happened. The position at the News of the World was that nobody had known that Mulcaire was hacking phones.”
“How did you know?” Edis asked her. “You didn’t ask anybody.”
Brooks replied that she had learned this from public statements and from conversations with Andy Coulson.
Earlier, Edis challenged Brooks repeatedly after she denied being aware that News International had been covering up the scale of the hacking. She agreed that in September 2006, the month after the original arrest of Glenn Mulcaire and the paper’s royal editor, Clive Goodman, she had learned from a Scotland Yard detective that police were aware of more than 100 victims of Mulcaire’s hacking, that there was no evidence of anybody other than the News of the World paying Mulcaire, and that his telephone records showed a pattern of his calling the News of the World before and after accessing a target’s voicemail.
Edis said: “You knew, didn’t you, that the whole truth did not come out during the first trial?” The court has heard that Mulcaire and Goodman were jailed in January 2007 for a total of only eight victims.
She replied:”I don’t think I saw it like that.”
She agreed that, as editor of the Sun in January 2007, she would have had a reporter in court for the sentencing of Mulcaire and Goodman and that she must have known that the judge said that Mulcaire had been working for “others” at the News of the World, not just for Goodman.
Edis asked whether she thought News International statements about the case had been honourable. “I had no reason to believe otherwise,” she said,
“You carried on with the cover-up when you became chief executive.”
“No,” she said.
Edis then asked her to explain why Andy Coulson had emailed her on the day that Mulcaire and Goodman had pleaded guilty to say “it’s all going so well today.”
She said: “I think it’s an odd way to describe the royal editor pleading guilty.”
Edis suggested that the comment might have been made “if you thought there had been an agreement that the case would be dismissed without anyone else being dragged into it.”
“Absolutely not,” she replied.
Rebekah Brooks and Andy Coulson deny conspiring to intercept communications. The trial continues.
March 6 2014
Rebekah Brooks yesterday acknowledged that she and Andy Coulson had been close enough to share secrets with each other during two periods when they are accused of conspiring to produce stories based on intercepted voicemails.
In tense cross-examination, Andrew Edis QC challenged Brooks over the meaning of a letter which she wrote to Coulson in February 2004. Edis suggested the letter showed that they had been having an affair and sharing secrets for the preceding six years, during which time they published stories about Milly Dowler and David Blunkett which, the Crown claim, were generated by hacking phone messages.
Brooks insisted repeatedly that although she and Coulson had begun an affair in 1998, it had not continued for six years. The affair had stopped and both of them had got on with their lives before it had resumed briefly in 2003. “I hadn’t been sitting there like Miss Haversham for six years,” she said.
Edis quoted part of the letter to Coulson in which she wrote: “I confide in you. I seek your advice.” He asked her: “That included work matters, didn’t it?”
“It could have done.”
“Confide means trust – trust people with your confidences. No?”
“Yes.”
“And that would include secrets relating to work?
“And emotional issues as well.”
Edis then referred to another passage in the letter in which she wrote: “For six years I have waited.”
“It suggests doesn’t it that the relationship had lasted six years?”
Brooks said that was not correct.
“You would be telling the truth when you were writing?”
“I was in a very emotional state when I wrote this letter.”
“That’s all the more reason why you would be telling the truth. It’s your heart-felt anguish.”
“Yes.”
“Which is absolutely genuine.”
“Yes.”
Edis repeated that the letter suggested they had had an affair for six year. “That’s not true…. Andy had got on with his life. I’m clearly saying that it has been six years since we had got together. I hadn’t been sitting there like Miss Haversham for six years. I had gone out, got married, tried to have a baby, got on with my life. The emotional feeling that I had towards Andy obviously came out in the letter. But we didn’t have an affair for six years. We were close friends, good friends.”
Edis turned to the state of their relationship in April 2002 when the Crown claim that Brooks and Coulson plotted to use voicemail intercepted from the phone of the missing Surrey schoolgirl Milly Dowler. Brooks was then editor of the News of the World but Coulson was editing the paper while she was on holiday in Dubai.
“At that time were you talking with him in that confidential way?”
“We were close friends.”
“So you would trust each other?”
“I trusted him as a friend and as a deputy editor.”
“If the deputy editor was committing a crime, he might not want the editor in normal circumstances to find out about it. But he might be able to tell the editor if he really trusted her.” Mr Edis paused. “Was the relationshjp in April 2002 such that Mr Coulson could trust you with any confidence at all?”
“Yes,” she whispered.
Edis then asked her about August 2004 when, the court has heard, Andy Coulson, as editor of the News of the World, revealed an affair between David Blunkett and a woman whose name he witheld; and Rebekah Brooks, as editor of the Sun, followed up the next day by naming the woman as Kimberly Quinn, publisher of the Spectator magazine. The Crown claim that Coulson obtained the story from messages which Blunkett had left on Quinn’s phone and that he then passed her identity to Brooks.
Brooks has told the jury that she wrote her letter to Coulson in February 2004 after he had told her he wanted to end their second period of physical intimacy. In the letter, she wrote that this meant that “I can’t discuss my worries, concerns, problems at work with you any more.”
Edis put it to her that by August 2004, they were “back talking confidentially to each other by then?”
“We were certainly talking.”
“But in that confidential way?”
“I think we were back to confiding, particularly on an emotional level by that stage.”
Edis then showed her the billing record for a mobile phone which Coulson was using in August 2004 which showed that he had phoned Brooks immediately before he met David Blunkett in Sheffield to tell him that he planned to publish a story about his affair.
“Do you remember what he was saying to you?”
Brooks said she could not remember, that Coulson had often called or texted her at the beginning of the day. Edis said: “He is in Sheffield, going to see a Cabinet minister. Surely he told you that.”
“No. He didn’t,” she replied.
She went to say that she thought she had come up with Quinn’s name after checking stories which had previously been published which mentioned that Quinn knew Blunkett and that, based on that suspicion, she had “taken a punt” and called Blunkett’s special adviser, Huw Evans, to persuade him to confirm that she was right.
Edis said: “You would have to take a punt if you knew it was a phone-hacking story.”
“I didn’t know it was a phone-hacking story,” she said.
“Didn’t you?”
Brooks and Coulson deny conspiring to intercept communications. The trial continues.
ends