Phone-hacking trial reports February 2014

The Guardian, 4 February 2014

February 20 2014       Rebekah Brooks yesterday stepped into the witness box at the Old Bailey and told the jury that as editor of the News of the World, she had never heard of Glenn Mulcaire and had known nothing of his phone-hacking activity for the paper.

“It’s impossible for an editor to know every source for every story,” she added. “Of course that’s impossible with the sheer volume of stories coming into the paper.”

Questioned by her barrister, Jonathan Laidlaw QC, she gave glimpses of her dealings with Rupert Murdoch and Tony Blair, and described her experience of life inside tabloid newsrooms which included several examples of misogyny and tales of internal competition so intense that at one point she suspected colleagues of cutting her phone lines to stop her following up on an exclusive.

Before she began her evidence, the judge, Mr Justice Saunders, told the jury that, following legal argument, they should acquit her on one of the five charges against her. The prosecution had alleged that she had conspired to commit misconduct in public office by authorising payment to a military source for a photograph of Prince William in a bikini at a James Bond theme party at Sandhurst military academy. The judge said there was “considerable uncertainty” about where the photograph came from. A temporary jury foreman formally declared her not guilty on the charge.

After more than three months of prosecution evidence, Jonathan Laidlaw told the jury: “It is time for you to see Mrs Brooks as she is, not as she is described or spoken of elsewhere.”

She told the jury how, in only seven years, she had risen from a post as junior researcher on the News of the World’s Sunday magazine to become deputy editor of the paper in December 1995, aged 27. Along the way, she said, she had encountered “a bit of old school misogyny.” There was only a small percentage of women in the newsroom. The features department had more women and was, therefore, known internally to some as the ‘pink parlour’, and when she became a founder member of Women In Journalism, to promote the role of women in Fleet Street, she was aware of WIJ being referred to as “the whingers.”

She told the jury the story behind some of the stories which had helped her career. She had befriended the England footballer Paul Gascoigne after he broke his leg in the FA cup final in 1991. As a result, in July 1994, he had agreed to give her an interview about incidents of domestic violence in his marriage. The paper had paid him between £50,000 and £80,000 for doing so. “It’s a good story,” she said, “but also it’s a way of highlighting these issues.”

A year later, when the actor Hugh Grant was arrested in Los Angeles with a prostitute, Devine Brown, her editor, Phil Hall, had said that they must secure Brown’s story. With the help of a US-based freelance who had previously been a private investigator, they had found Brown. “The News of the World got there first and she agreed to do a deal with us.” She said they had paid Brown $100,000 for an interview and then spent up to $150,000 more to hide her from rival newspapers.

They had arranged to move Brown to an “oasis resort” in the Nevada desert, but Brown was “very smart” and insisted she be accompanied by her whole family, including cousins. The News of the World had hired a plane to transport them to the resort and then, fearing that the Daily Mail or the Sun might be on their trail, they had moved them to a second resort. At the time she had been features editor of the paper and the operation had “blown” her weekly spending limit. That could cause tension, she told the jury, but she had been moved by “the thought of not getting the story and of having to face the editor.”

During this time, she said, Rupert Murdoch had come into her office for the first time and given her “kind advice” to take her time and to learn as she went. He had told her he did not like editors who sought publicity, “going on Radio 4 and spouting forth about their opinions.” She added: “I think I made the fatal error of telling him that Womans Own wanted to interview me, and the reaction was extremely grim.”

As deputy, she would sometimes stand in for the editor of the News of the World and take calls from Murdoch on a Saturday evening, asking always “What’s going on?” She said the proprietor was “obsessed with news.” She went on to describe the annual session in which the four editors of Murdoch’s national newspapers would sit outside his office in Los Angeles or New York before going in one by one to try to persuade him to increase their budget.

She told the jury there was intense competition between the news and features departments at the paper. “They really didn’t like each other.” It was rare for people from the two departments to drink together in the pub. As features editor, she said, she had run a story about the relationship between the Conservative MP Alan Clarke and a judge’s wife. The story had ended with an appeal to readers to supply more information. When she had come into the office at the beginning of the next week, she had found all her phone lines had been cut. “No-one owned up to it, but I always suspected it was the news desk.”

On another occasion, she discovered that the news desk had compiled a file of “any perceived mistakes or stupid stories I had done.” The entries in the file had been labelled Twat 1, Twat 2, Twat 3. “It was a tough world.” Competition between the News of the World and the Sun was also intense, she said: when the Sun discovered that News of the World journalists were walking past their office on the way to the canteen, they had frosted all the windows to prevent them looking in.

She said she had got to know Tony Blair in 1996. Her then partner, the actor Ross Kemp, was “a card-carrying member of the Labour Party” and had taken her to a rally in Nottingham or Sheffield where she had met Blair and “the original New Labour crew.” In the following year, the Sun and the News of the World had switched their support from Conservative to Labour.

After two years as deputy editor of the Sun, she had returned to the News of the World as editor in January 2000. Jonathan Laidlaw asked her whether during the two and a half years she held that job, she had heard the name of Glenn Mulcaire.

“No,” she replied.

“Did anybody speak his name in your presence?”

“No.”

“As for phone-hacking – accessing voicemail messages – was any involvement he had in that practice ever drawn to your attention?”

“No. Not at all.”

She said that on taking over as editor, she had appointed as investigations editor Greg Miskiw who, the jury have been told, has pleaded guilty to conspiring with Mulcaire to hack phones. Brooks said she had ordered Miskiw to return from a new posting to New York because she thought it was a waste of money for the paper to have a New York bureau. She had a professional relationship with him, she said, but “he was quite insular, had an air of mystery.”

Asked if Miskiw’s investigation unit had been set up to hack voicemail, she said: “It’s just not correct.”

Rebekah Brooks denies conspiring to intercept voicemail; one remaining count of conspiring to commit misconduct in public office; and two counts of perverting the course of justice. The trial continues.

 

February 21 2014

Rebekah Brooks yesterday broke off her evidence in tears as her lawyer invited her to discuss sensitive details of her private life in open court at the Old Bailey.

After a short break, she went on to describe her attempts to have children using fertility treatments finally culminating in the surrogacy birth of her daughter, Scarlett, and to describe the detail of her relationships with men, including three periods of ‘physical intimacy’ with Andy Coulson. “My personal life – as everyone now knows – has been a bit of a car crash for many years,” she told the jury.

On her second day in the witness box at the phone-hacking trial, she also talked about her role as a “hands-on editor”, running the News of the World campaign to change the law after the murder of Sarah Payne in July 2000 and navigating the controversy over an undercover operation to expose the business activities of the Countess of Wessex.

Her barrister, Jonathan Laidlaw QC, told her he was “sorry to have to do this” before asking her a series of questions about her private life. As she described her relationship with the TV actor Ross Kemp, she said that after a 12-month separation, they had come back together in 2001 and “we brought up the subject of maybe living together, of taking it more seriously and buying a house and getting married and having children…”

Her voice then broke and she asked the judge for a break before leaving the court in tears. When she returned ten minutes later, she told the jury that in mid 2001, she had had “a scare” and ended up in hospital and had then started fertility treatment. In June 2002, she had married Kemp but, after becoming editor of the Sun in January 2003, their relationship had become more difficult. “We were both working incredibly long hours in completely different industries. The war in Iraq started pretty quickly after I became editor and we were doing 4am, 5am editions, and I and my senior team moved into a hotel next door to Wapping, where we lived… So probably 2003 was a lost year for us. Basically, life was put on hold.”

Laidlaw then asked her about her relationship with Andy Coulson. Earlier in the trial, the jury were given a letter, written by Brooks to Coulson in February 2004. The Crown claimed that it revealed that they had been having an affair for six years and that they trusted each other with secrets. “The fact is that you are my best friend,” she wrote. “I tell you everything. I confide in you. I seek your advice.” The Crown told the jury that the letter made it “simply incredible” that Brooks had not known about the hacking of Milly Dowler in April 2002 at a time when Coulson was editing the News of the World while she was on holiday.

Brooks said she had first met Coulson in 1995 or 1996 and they had become “extremely good friends.” Laidlaw asked her if that had involved “physical intimacy”. Brooks replied: “No, not then… It wasn’t until 1998 when Andy and I became close.” That period in their relationship had ended, she said, and had then resumed after her marriage to Ross Kemp had become troubled in 2003. “I’m sure if Ross was here, he’d say our whole relationship was a bit like a roller coaster. Sometimes it was good. Sometimes it wasn’t so.” She and Coulson had had a third “period of intimacy” in 2006, she said.

Turning to her letter to Coulson which, the jury have been told, was found by police on one of her laptops, she said: “I don’t even think I finished it. I don’t know if anyone has been in this situation, but at a time of hurt, you come home and have a few glasses of wine and get on the computer. That’s what I did. I wrote my feelings down at that time. These are my thoughts really to myself, but obviously I wrote it in a letter form with the intention of finishing it and maybe sending it. I saw it again when the police found it and produced it.”

Laidlaw asked her to comment on the claim that she had had a six-year affair with Coulson. “First of all, it isn’t true. I know that’s what the police and the prosecution say having analysed the letter. Obviously at the time I wrote this, I was in a great deal of emotional anguish as I think you can tell from the letter… The six-year period was not referring back to 1998.. Obviously I have read it a lot since the police found it. I think that’s what I was referring to… Andy and I were incredibly close during that time, and that comes across as well.”

Laidlaw asked if the affair had had any impact on her friendship with Coulson. She said: “I think any affair is by its very nature dysfunctional in some ways. I think it certainly added a complexity to what was a very good friendship…. It’s very easy to blame work but the hours were long and hard, you get thrown together. I know it was wrong and it shouldn’t have happened, but it did.”

She said that after separating from Ross Kemp in late 2005, she had meet her current husband, Charlie Brooks, at the beginning of March 2007. “I think it’s fair to say we both knew very quickly that we wanted to be together. I told Charlie obviously about the failed fertility treatment in the past and said that if we did get together and he wanted children, I probably wouldn’t be the right person.” He had told her he wanted to get married anyway. They had consulted a specialist, Dr Mohammed Taranissi, who had suggested surrogacy.

They had researched it and spoken to others who had been through it. “It’s a big thing to do,” she told the jury. “So, my mum was out shopping in Warrington one day and she bumped into my cousin who I was very close to at school.” They had started to talk about surrogacy, and the cousin had volunteered to carry Brooks’ baby, who was born in January 2012.

Brooks went on to describe her ten-year campaign to change the law after the murder of Sarah Payne. She told the court she had made mistakes, publishing details of one convicted paedophile which had provoked “a riot of sorts” in Portsmouth and wrongly including in a gallery of predatory paedophiles a teacher who had had an affair with an under-age pupil. But, she said, the campaign had succeeded in filling a series of loopholes in the Sex Offenders Act and giving the public the right to ask police for information about convicted paedophiles in their area.

She also recalled how she had asked her undercover specialist, Mazher Mahmood, to investigate the Countess of Wessex by posing as a ‘fake sheikh’. This was extremely costly, she said, because “he would live the life of a true sheikh with a Bentley and a penthouse suite which he always told me was imperative.” In the event, she said, she had agreed with the Palace that she would not publish the story if the countess gave her an interview. However, a week later, other newspapers had published inaccurate accounts of the countess’ commentys to the fake sheikh and so she had decided to publish the story after all. In an internal email at the time, she had warned other executives that “all our entrapment and subterfuge must be justified 110%. We have to be careful to ensure that everything we do is inside the law.”

Rebekah Brooks denies conspiring to intercept voicemail; conspiring to commit misconduct in public office; and two counts of conspiring to pervert the course of justice. The trial continues.

 

February 25 2014

Rebekah Brooks yesterday told an Old Bailey jury that she had not been involved in the hacking of Milly Dowler’s voicemail and that as editor she had not been told that some of her staff believed they had found the missing girl alive and well three weeks after she disappeared.

On her fourth day in the witness box, Brooks also told the court that during her editorship of the News of the World, she had not realised that it was illegal to intercept voicemail. She had never sanctioned it, she said. “I can’t see that it would have been a particularly useful thing to do,” she added.

The jury in the phone-hacking trial have heard that Milly Dowler vanished on the afternoon of Thursday March 21 2002 and that on Wednesday April 10, the then news editor of the News of the World, Neville Thurlbeck, commissioned the paper’s specialist phone-hacker, Glenn Mulcaire, to access her phone messages.

Brooks’ barrister, Jonathan Laidlaw QC, asked her: “Did you have anything to do with Neville Thurlbeck’s tasking of Glenn Mulcaire and his accessing of Milly Dowler’s voicemail?”

“No,” she replied.

“Did you at the time know anything about that, before it happened?”

“No.”

“After it happened?”

“No.”

The jury have heard that Mulcaire intercepted a message which appeared to reveal that the missing Surrey schoolgirl had been offered a job interview at a factory in Telford and that, without informing the police who were searching for her, Thurlbeck had sent a team of reporters and photographers to Telford to try to find her.

Brooks, who was on holiday in Dubai at the time, said she had stayed in contact with the paper which was edited in her absence by her deputy, Andy Coulson, but she told the court she could not remember having any discussion about the missing girl during that week: “I think I would remember if Andy or whoever on the paper had said ‘we’ve found Milly Dowler’… I don’t remember having any discussions about her disappearance while I was away.”

She said that if she had heard about the Telford story, she would have told her staff to contact police. “It’s the parents. You want to tell them immediately via the police, as soon as possible. That would have been the right thing to do.”

Laidlaw asked her to comment on the evidence of an earlier witness, William Hennessy, who told the court that he happened to meet Brooks in Dubai that week and that he recalled her making a lot of phone calls and, on one occasion, walking away because she had to talk to someone about “the missing Surrey girl.”

She said: “I don’t particularly remember saying that. I don’t actually remember meeting Mr Hennessy that clearly… Being forced to remember something so far ago, you do try and remember the details but i just don’t particularly remember meeting him or saying that, but it’s possible that I did.”

She said that she had not seen the early editions of the News of the World on that Sunday, April 14, which quoted several voicemail messages from the missing girl’s phone and that she had seen only a later edition, in which the story had been cut down. During the following week, she said, she had not been aware that her managing editor, Stuart Kuttner, sent an email to Surrey police in which, the court, has heard, he challenged them to confirm that Milly Dowler had been offered a job in Telford and quoted a voicemail from her phone.

Earlier, Brooks told the jury that in the late 1990s she had heard that it was possible to access other people’s voicemail. “There was certainly some publicity about it, about the flaw in the system.” Looking back, she could not see how it would have helped the News of the World on any of the big campaigns or stories they had run under her editorship, she said, although it might have helped other departments with “celebrity tittle tattle.”

“No one – no desk head, no journalist – ever came to me and said ‘We are working on such and such story but we need to access voicemail; or asked for me to sanction it.'” She said she had not realised that it would have been a breach of the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act. She was pretty sure, she added, that she had not even heard of the act. She added: “Even though I didn’t know it was illegal, I still would have felt it was absolutely in the category of a serious breach of privacy.”

Rebekah Brooks denies one count of conspiring to intercept voicemail. The trial continues.

 

February 26 2014

Rebekah Brooks turned down a police request to help the original 2006 prosecution of phone-hacking at the News of the World because of “complexities on the corporate level”, an Old Bailey jury heard yesterday (Weds).

Brooks then offered a job to the paper’s royal editor, Clive Goodman, even though he had been convicted of crime, because News International wanted to avoid a “potential publicity nightmare” if Goodman went public with allegations against senior journalists, she said.

Giving evidence for the fifth day in the phone-hacking trial, Brooks described the “startling” sequence of events after she heard on August 8 2006 that police had arrested Goodman and raided the News of the World’s office. She had discussed the case with the chief executive, Les Hinton, she said: “I think initially there was certainly concern about the investigation and what it would uncover and where it was going. It was all quite an anxious situation.”

Soon, she said, she had discovered that police had also arrested a private detective, Glenn Mulcaire, and that Mulcaire had worked for the News of the World during her editorship between May 2000 and January 2003. When police contacted her to tell her that Mulcaire had hacked her phone, she agreed to meet a detective, Keith Surtees, in the RAC Club. “I had a natural curiosity to find out what had happened to my own phone but of course, from a corporate point of view, I also wanted to find out where the police were in the investigation.”

The result, the court heard, was that Brooks reported back to Les Hinton and Andy Coulson that police had identified more than a hundred victims of Mulcaire’s victims; believed the News of the World had paid him £1 million for his work; and had noticed that routinely he would speak to the paper immediately before and after accessing a target’s voicemail.

She said the detective had asked if she would become a witness for the prosecution of Goodman and Mulcaire because she had been hacked with unusual frequency and consistency compared to other victims. She had consulted Les Hinton and others about this. “We all agreed it would not be the right thing to do for me to make a formal complaint and go on to be a prosecution witness with the complexities that would cause on the corporate level since the private detective had worked for the News of the World.”

She recalled that Goodman and Mulcaire had been jailed in January 2007 and that Andy Coulson had resigned as editor of the News of the World “although there was never any suggestion that he knew what these two people had been doing.” She went on to summarise public statements which had then been made by Les Hinton and by the new editor of the News of the World, Colin Myler, to the effect that Goodman had acted alone in hacking phones and was “a rogue exception” on the paper.

When Goodman was released from prison in March 2007, she said, he had been angry because he had been sacked and was planning to appeal to an employment tribunal and to identify others at the paper who, he alleged, had been involved in hacking. “It was pretty much everybody who had a senior role at the News of the World. He certainly named the editor, deputy editor, managing editor and executives on the news desk.”

She said she had had no reason to believe him: “I don’t think anybody – me included – thought that the allegations Clive was making had any basis. It was as a result of being turned down on his challenge for dismissal.” But Les Hinton had told her he could foresee a”potential publicity nightmare” at any employment tribunal and so she had arranged to have lunch with Goodman – again at the RAC Club – where she had offered him a job at the Sun. The jury have been told that separately Brooks wrote to the Press Complaints Commission to tell them that any journalist who broke the law would face instant dismissal. She told the jury that Goodman had turned down her offer and that she believed he had settled his dispute with News International.

Rebekah Brooks denies conspiring to intercept voicemail. The trial continues.

 

February 28 2014

Rebekah Brooks yesterday was pressed to explain the legality of a series of contacts between her journalists at the Sun and sources connected to the police, military and MI5.

The jury in the phone-hacking trial were shown an email, dated in April 2006, in which a reporter asked her to authorise a payment to a source who had provided a story about wife-swapping involving the royal mayor of Tetbury. The reporter wrote: “I would like to keep it anonymous because the contact is a serving police officer. He has supplied us with numerous other tips in the past.” The reporter asked that the payment be made in cash through a branch of the Thomas Cook travel agency.

Questioned by her barrister, Jonathan Laidlaw QC, Brooks said: “Obviously, a police officer selling information directly associated with their duty, I was absolutely aware of the illegality.” She said such a payment could be justified in the public interest only with a high threshold, such as the exposure of high-level police corruption. She continued: “But, of course, police officers are just as likely to come across a story that comes about in their daily lives. If a copper is living next door to the royal mayor of Tetbury wife-swapping situation, it’s not in the course of his duty. People may have an issue with it, but it’s not – as far as I’m concerned – against the law for me to authorise it.”

She was shown another email, dated in February 2006, in which the Sun’s crime editor, Mike Sullivan, suggested that the then Home Secretary, Charles Clarke, had given the News of the World a story about a police cover-up and then asked her to authorise a payment of £500 for a source who had helped on stories about Kate Moss’ drug dealer and about a woman who had hired a hit man who turned out to be a police officer. Sullivan added: “With respect, I’m not sure it’s wise putting this kind of thing down on emails where there is a permanent record.”

Brooks told the court that Sullivan had been crime editor for a long time and received “a lot of information from serving police officers but also not necessarily – I would say rarely – for money.” She said that the Sun had a pretty good relationship with Scotland Yard, which included sponsoring their football team. Turning to the email, she said: “Nothing would suggest to me that this was payment going to a serving officer. I would probably have read it and thought it was one of Mike’s contacts – crime journalists, ex crime journalists, all with contacts at the Yard.”

Asked to explain Sullivan’s final line about it being unwise to record “this kind of thing” in an email, she told the jury that that could refer to writing about sources. “If you want to see something sinister, you could read it that he didn’t want this payment to be discussed on email. But it could be that you shouldn’t be naming a source for the police cover-up in email.” She said Mike Sullivan was a senior journalist: “It sounds a little bit chippy, the end. It could be that he just didn’t like to be questioned about a payment for one of his sources.”

Another email, dated in April 2008, asked her to authorise a payment of £1,000 for a picture of an army officer who had been involved in a road accident which had killed a policeman: “We need to pay in cash as the guy who got us the picture works at Sandhurst and went into Sandhurst and took the picture off the wall so he doesn’t want it to be traced back to him.” Brooks said she did not remember the email but said that it did not necessarily refer to a public official.

On another occasion, in July 2005, an executive emailed her that “a tipster who says he’s a policeman” had told the news desk that George Michael had been arrested on suspicion of driving under the influence of drugs and had then been released without charge. Brooks said that this had nothing to do with money. “It isn’t unusual, in my experience, for a police officer to ring up the paper. He is clearly not doing so for money.”

Questioned about an email from a senior journalist in which he referred to “my man in Five”, she said she understood that that referred to a source in the security service, MI5. She told the court that at some point, MI5 and MI6 had decided to be “a little bit more open” with the media and that she had attended briefings with both services.

She went on to describe an incident in March 1998 when, as deputy editor of the Sun, she had been called in to Downing Street to meet representatives of MI5, MI6 and GCHQ after a source had told them that all ports had been alerted to watch for anthrax being smuggled into the country on the orders of Saddam Hussein. She said they had asked her not to publish the story but they had accepted that the public had a right to know about the threat. On the basis that this was justified by high public interest, she had authorised a payment to the source, a chief petty officer who subsequently had been arrested and prosecuted for breaking the Official Secrets Act.

She said she had been offered the chance to pay a source for details of the “MPs’ expenses fraud” in the spring of 2009 but had found it a very difficult decision. “In terms of error of judgement, I think this is probably quite high on my list. I thought about it too long. I drove my news team crazy with my indecision.” In the end, the information had been bought by the Daily Telegraph who had done a brilliant job with it. “It was quite embarrassing that we didn’t get it,” she said.

Rebekah Brooks denies conspiring to commit misconduct in public office. The trial continues.

ends

(The trial was stalled repeatedly during February, mainly because one of the defendants, Clive Goodman, was too ill to attend, but also because lawyers were struggling with the volume of evidence and asked for delays.)