Sky admits its reporter hacked emails

The Guardian, 5 April 2012

Sky News has admitted that one of its senior executives authorised a journalist to conduct email hacking on two occasions that it said were ‘in the public interest’ – even though intercepting emails is a prima facie breach of the Computer Misuse Act, to which there is no such defence written in law.

Gerard Tubb, Sky’s northern England correspondent, accessed emails belonging to John Darwin, the ‘canoe man’ accused of faking his own death, when his wife, Anne, was due to stand trial for deception in July 2008. The reporter built up a database of emails that he believed would help defeat Anne Darwin’s defence. Her husband had pleaded guilty to seven charges of deception before her trial.

The same reporter separately accessed the email accounts of a suspected paedophile and his wife in an investigation that did not lead to any material being published or broadcast, according to Sky, which is part-owned by Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation. Both instances of hacking were approved by Simon Cole, managing editor of Sky News.

John Ryley, the head of Sky News, said the broadcaster had ‘authorised a journalist to access the emails of individuals suspected of criminal activity’ and the hacking in both cases was ‘justified and in the public interest”. Ryley said the broadcaster’s decisions were ‘subjected to the proper editorial controls’. Sky News said it stood by Tubb and that there were instances when the broadcaster believed breaking the law was justified to produce a news story of public interest.

Darwin faked his own death in 2002, ‘going missing’ after he was last seen paddling out to sea in a canoe. He secretly flew to Panama, where he was later joined by his wife, only to return to Britain in 2007. Walking into a London police station in December 2007, he declared: “I think I may be a missing person.” But later that month he and his wife were charged with fraud after it emerged that they had been photographed in Panama with an estate agent and that Anne Darwin had cashed in her husband’s life insurance policy. John Darwin pleaded guilty to seven charges of deception and a passport offence in March 2008, leaving his wife to face six charges of deception and nine of money laundering.

At around this point, Sky News said, Tubb discovered that John Darwin had used the identity of a friend, John Jones. According to the broadcaster, Tubb conducted an internet search to reveal a Yahoo email account in the name of John Jones and, in the belief that Yahoo accounts were ‘notoriously weak at the time’, the journalist was confident he could gain access with his existing background knowledge. He then sought permission to access the emails, an investigation that led him on to further email accounts.

In early July 2008, Sky News said executives met Cleveland police officials and handed over ‘pertinent’ emails. Anne Darwin was found guilty in the trial that followed shortly afterwards, and was sentenced to six and a half years in prison. John Darwin was given six years, three months.

Shortly afterwards, Tubb produced a story for Sky’s news channel and website in which he quoted from emails that had been written by John Darwin to his wife and to a lawyer. A web story said the channel had ‘uncovered documentary evidence’ that demonstrated ‘conclusively why John Darwin came back to Britain’.

Making only minimal effort to hide the basis of the story, Tubb’s report said Sky News had ‘discovered an email’ from John to Anne dated 31 May 2007, in which he said changes to visa rules meant he could no longer stay in Panama. The report cited evidence from emails between the couple, including a ‘final email’ from Anne that was not, ‘as suggested in court’, evidence of a ‘massive row’ between them. Tubb said the email had been handed to the police by Sky News.

The story displayed a picture of ‘John and Anne Darwin’s master plan’, showing a diagram that had apparently been produced by Darwin, and claimed to have obtained financial accounts prepared by Darwin. In another story, published in November 2009, Tubb quoted directly from an email written by Darwin to his wife in 2007, explaining that their property in Panama had been valued at $1m and adding: “You’re a filthy rich gringo.”

Sky News also published a voicemail message on its website, dated 19 May 2007, in which Anne Darwin is clearly heard leaving a message for her husband. The voicemail ends with her saying: “I’ll try and catch you tomorrow. Love you.” Sky News said this showed that “she was doing as much of the running as he was”.

The broadcaster said this was not obtained by phone hacking. A spokesman added: “All of the material obtained by Sky News was via the Darwins’ computer-based email accounts. As we have said previously, Cleveland police were made aware of the source of the material when Sky News shared it with them. We stand by our editorial decisions, which were justified in the public interest.”

Sensitivities at Sky News are running high because the broadcaster’s parent, BSkyB, is subject to a ‘fit and proper’ investigation being conducted by the communications regulator, Ofcom. Cleveland police said they inquired about the provenance of the emails at the time. A statement said they had “conducted an initial review into these matters and can confirm that inquiries are ongoing into how the emails were obtained”.

Tubb declined to speak to the Guardian. Cole forwarded inquiries to the Sky News press office.