On Saturday morning, the police arrested four journalists who have worked for Rupert Murdoch. For a moment, it looked like one more step in the death march of the News of the World, but then it became clear that this was something more significant.
This was the moment when the scandal which closed the News of the World finally started to pose a serious threat to Murdoch’s three other UK newspaper titles – the Sun, the Times and the Sunday Times.
The four men who were arrested on Saturday are not linked to the News of the World. They come from the Sun, from the top of the tree – the current head of news, his crime editor, the former managing editor and the deputy editor.
Nothing is certain. Nobody has been convicted of anything. The four who were arrested on Saturday – like the 25 others before them – have not even been charged with any offence. But behind the scenes, something very significant has changed.
Under enormous legal and political pressure, Murdoch has abandoned the defences which previously protected News International and ordered that the police be given everything they need. Whereas Scotland Yard began their inquiry a year ago with nothing much more than the heap of scruffy paperwork which was seized from the News of the World’s private investigator, Glenn Mulcaire, Murdoch’s Management and Standards Committee has now handed them what may be the largest cache of evidence ever gathered by a police operation in this country, including the material that led to Saturday’s arrests.
They have access to a mass of internal paperwork – invoices, reporters’ expense claims, accounts, bank records, phone records. And technicians have retrieved an enormous reservoir of material from News International’s central computer servers, including one particularly vast collection which may yet prove to be the stick that breaks the media mogul’s back. It is known as Data Pool 3.
This is several hundred million email which have been sent and received over the years by employees of the News of the World – and of the three other Murdoch titles. Data Pool 3 is so big that the police are not even attempting to read every message. Instead, there are two teams systematically searching it for key words: a detective sergeant with five detective constables from Scotland Yard working secretly on criminal leads; and 32 civilians working for the Management and Standards Committee, providing information for the civil actions brought by public figures and for the Leveson inquiry and passing relevant material to police.
For Murdoch and his journalists, past and present, Data Pool 3 is a nightmare. First, none of them knows what is in there. All they can do is wait and see how bad it gets. Second, the police clearly believe it may yield new evidence of the crimes which they set out to investigate – the ‘blagging’ of confidential data from phone companies, banks, tax offices etc; the interception of voicemails and emails; the payment of bribes to police officers.
Third – and most nightmarish – it has already started to yield some evidence of a previously unsuspected crime, an alleged conspiracy to destroy evidence which the High Court and the police were seeking. Data Pool 3 itself was entirely deleted from News International’s servers. If proven, such a conspiracy would be particulary serious, because it could see the courts imposing long prison sentences; and because it is claimed to involve ‘senior employees and directors’.
The Guardian last July revealed police suspicions that a huge number of emails had been deliberately destroyed. Since then, hearings in the High Court have disclosed more detail.
Late in 2009, News International decided to delete old email from their servers. This appears to have been a simple piece of electronic housekeeping. However, the plan was not executed. During the summer of 2010, Sienna Miller started to sue the News of the World for hacking into her voicemail. At the same time, according to High Court evidence, internal emails were being sent urging that the deletion plan be executed. Still, it was not.
On September 6 2010, Sienna Miller’s solicitor, Mark Thomson of Atkins Thomson, wrote to News International asking them to “preserve all the documents in your possession relating to our client’s private life”. On September 9, an internal message pressed for the emails to be deleted ‘urgently’. As Mr Justice Vos explained in a judgement last month: “Only three days after the solicitors for Sienna Miller had written their letter before action, asking specifically that the company should retain any emails concerned with the claim, what happened was that a previously conceived plan to delete emails was put into effect at the behest of senior management.”
In December 2010, the News of the World’s Scottish editor, Bob Bird, told the trial of Tommy Sheridan in Glasgow that the email archive had been lost en route to storage in Mumbai. Also in December, News International’s solicitor, Julian Pike from Farrer and Co, provided the High Court with a statement claiming that they were unable to retrieve emails which were more than six months old.
On January 7 2011, News International gained access to the evidence which had been assembled by Sienna Miller’s lawyers. On January 12, the company issued detailed instructions for the secure retention of relevant data. Later that month, News International handed three old email to Scotland Yard, triggering the new police inquiry .In the same month, a second significant mass deletion is believed to have happened. By this time, the entire contents of Data Pool 3 had been deleted.
However, under pressure from the lawyers involved in the High Court civil actions, News International were compelled to allow technical experts to examine their servers. On March 23 2011, Julian Pike formally apologised to the High Court and acknowledged that News International could retrieve emails as far back as 2005 and also that none had been lost en route to Mumbai. He said he had been misinformed.
In October, technicians started to restore the millions of deleted email. By December, the entire contents of Data Pool 3 had been recovered. The implications are considerable.
On Saturday, as police searched parts of the Sun office, a press release from NewsCorp referred discreetly to an “internal investigation into our three remaining titles.” The Times is already under some pressure from an allegation that one of its reporters hacked into a target’s email to obtain a story. In an unexplained line in his statement to the Leveson inquiry, the Sunday Times editor, John Witherow said that “a freelance journalist/researcher who has done occasional work for the paper was arrested on suspicion of breaching the Fraud Act. The police investigation is still continuing.”
Whether all of the UK titles are dragged into the police inquiry remains to be seen. The threat is there: it may or may not materialise. Similarly, it is not yet clear whether police will find any evidence that senior employees and directors really did order the destruction of evidence. Equally important, the police may find evidence of more victims who may choose to launch more legal actions. At the outer reaches of possibility, police may find evidence of illegal activity by other private investigators, which could conceivably lead them to other news organisations who also hired them. Since Saturday morning, nothing is certain.