The Metropolitan Police yesterday admitted that during the first four years of the phone-hacking affair, they warned only 36 people that they may have been targeted by the News of the World’s private investigator, Glenn Mulcaire.
Scotland Yard’s latest inquiry, which was launched in January, is believed to be contacting up to 4,000 people whose names and personal details were found in Mulcaire’s possession by police during the original investigation in 2006.
The disclosure of the number – which Scotland Yard has previously insisted on keeping secret – exposes them to complaint that they breached an agreement with the Director of Public Prosecutions that they would warn all ‘potential victims’ in the affair. And it will revive criticism that they have consistently downplayed the scale of criminal activity commissioned by the newspaper.
Scotland Yard have previously repeatedly refused to disclose the number of victims they warned, rejecting applications under the Freedom of Information Act on the grounds that releasing the numbers would necessarily disclose the identities of those who had been warned and that this would breach their privacy.
However, in a sharp change of policy, the Metropolitan Police’s acting deputy commissioner, John Yates, yesterday volunteered that during the original inquiry in 2006, police had warned only 28 people that they may have been victims; and that after the Guardian revived the affair in July 2009, they warned only 8 more.
In a letter to John Whittingdale, chairman of the culture, media and sport select committee, Yates, who was responsible for dealing with the hacking affair for nearly 20 months, gave no explanation for the failure to inform more than 36 potential victims. He said simply: “I have accepted that more could and should have been done in relation to those who may have been potential victims.”
The new inquiry, which is no longer being overseen by Yates, is known to have approached scores of politicians, police officers, actors, sports personalities and others who had previously been unaware that police held evidence to suggest that their voicemail messages may have been intercepted by Glenn Mulcaire. Many are now suing News International which owns the News of the World. Some are also seeking judicial review of the actions of the Metropolitan Police.
Yates’ disclosure appears to contradict evidence which he gave to the media select committee in February 2010 that where police had evidence that “interception was or may have been attempted by Mulcaire, the Met police has been diligent and taken all proper steps to ensure those individuals have been informed.” He also told the home affairs select committee in September 2010 that Met policy was “out of an abundance of caution to make sure that those who may have been hacked were contacted by us.”
In his letter to the DCMS chairman, John Yates also confirmed that during a brief investigation last autumn, police interviewed under caution a total of four people. This included Sean Hoare, the former NoW journalist who had told the New York Times that he had been actively encouraged to hack voicemail by his editor, Andy Coulson, who went on to become the prime minister’s media adviser and who has always denied all knowledge of illegal activity. When Yates’ officers cautioned Hoare that anything he said might be used in evidence against him, he declined to answer questions.
Yates letter has also disclosed more details of his social contacts with senior editors from News International. He acknowledges that he had dinner with the NoW editor at the Ivy, one of the most expensive restaurants in London; that he had two dinners with the editor of the Sunday Times; and a further dinner with the editor and crime editor of the NoW four months after he had decided that there was no basis to re-open an investigation into the paper.